So the verdict on Ashley?

Comments

• Bellarooo Posts: 2,412

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  06/01/13 - 19:30 #2

  Anyone is better then Louis Spence :rolleyes:

  0
• ElectricBoy171 Posts: 20,776

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  06/01/13 - 19:31 #3

  She's good and has given fair marks I think. She just needs to explain a bit more at times.

  0
• LazySusan Posts: 6,413

  Forum Member

  ✭

  06/01/13 - 19:31 #4

  Yes better than Emma but I liked Louis and I really don't like Jason at all.

  0
• PrincessEssex Posts: 1,414

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  06/01/13 - 19:32 #5

  I like her!! Interesting how she scores very similarly to Jason.
  
  I feel shes more eloquent with her explanations though

  0
• lucy mane Posts: 10,462

  Forum Member

  ✭✭

  06/01/13 - 19:32 #6

  I like her. She has a quirky personality. Some of scores are not right but it is her first week on the panel.

  0
• ll_Calypso_ll Posts: 4,537

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  06/01/13 - 19:33 #7

  She's sweet and manages to offer the contestants criticism without sounding like an asshole a la Jason.

  0
• Lennie Posts: 25,359

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  06/01/13 - 19:37 #8

  ll_Calypso_ll wrote: »

  She's sweet and manages to offer the contestants criticism without sounding like an asshole a la Jason.

  
  Agree
  
  Also motivates them in her Ashley way

  0
• Emmersonne Posts: 4,532

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  06/01/13 - 19:38 #9

  She sounds like she knows what she's doing! hurrah!

  0
• ScouseBird Posts: 1,140

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  06/01/13 - 19:46 #10

  I loved her in the jungle but i think she is trying to be a bit like nicole scherzinger hopefully she becomes more comfortable in the next few weeks.
  
  A million times better than louis though the panel was crap last year but this one is good

  0
• [Deleted User] Posts: 24

  Forum Member

  ✭

  06/01/13 - 19:51 #11

  ll_Calypso_ll wrote: »

  She's sweet and manages to offer the contestants criticism without sounding like an asshole a la Jason.

  
  Agreed.

  0
• Tiger Rose Posts: 11,782

  Forum Member

  ✭✭

  06/01/13 - 19:59 #12

  Will give her a few more weeks but she's not doing it for me so far - she seems to be a harsh marker without explaining herself really (what was she going on about with Matt's score)

  0
• [Deleted User] Posts: 1,115

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  06/01/13 - 20:00 #13

  Love her. Very critical but nice at the same time. It's spot on that she starts off with low marks because she'll be able to grow into high marks throughout the season.

  0
• gcmac Posts: 4,020

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  06/01/13 - 20:04 #14

  I like her. Think she just kept the marks low since its week one so she's got somewhere to go.

  0
• Glinny Posts: 4,426

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  06/01/13 - 20:06 #15

  Why on earth is she there She was in a girl pop band who did dance routines like most other girl bands.
  
  Only there off of the back of coming second on ITV's IACGMOOH.
  
  Hardly the credentials for judging ice dancing is it?

  0
• southlad Posts: 1,140

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  06/01/13 - 20:07 #16

  I thought she was great...much better than Emma Bunton.

  0
• ScouseBird Posts: 1,140

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  06/01/13 - 20:07 #17

  Glinny wrote: »

  Why on earth is she there She was in a girl pop band who did dance routines like most other girl bands.
  
  Only there off of the back of coming second on ITV's IACGMOOH.
  
  Hardly the credentials for judging ice dancing is it?

  
  She is a professional dancer she didnt just jump around when she was in the pcd! She has more right judging dance skills than emma or jason

  0
• ll_Calypso_ll Posts: 4,537

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  06/01/13 - 20:08 #18

  Glinny wrote: »

  Why on earth is she there She was in a girl pop band who did dance routines like most other girl bands.
  
  Only there off of the back of coming second on ITV's IACGMOOH.
  
  Hardly the credentials for judging ice dancing is it?

  
  Pussycat Dolls used to be an all dance troupe before developing into a girl band, so she's certainly more qualified than your casual band member (i.e Emma Bunton.)

  0
• -Sid- Posts: 29,365

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  06/01/13 - 20:09 #19

  It's all about the 'fierceness'. She's just another Alesha.
  
  One performance judge is more than enough.
  
  She's pointless.

  0
• R2Y5A0N2 Posts: 54,679

  Forum Member

  ✭

  06/01/13 - 20:10 #20

  Yeah I like her. She's a good judge but feel her scores tonight were a little bit low x

  0
• Sallyforth Posts: 7,404

  Forum Member

  ✭

  06/01/13 - 20:11 #21

  Qualified, constructive and pleasant on first impression. Sorry as I was to see the other two go, she seems a decent addition to me.

  0
• willows Posts: 6,169

  Forum Member

  ✭

  06/01/13 - 20:12 #22

  Thought she did well tonight. I like her

  0
• lucy mane Posts: 10,462

  Forum Member

  ✭✭

  06/01/13 - 20:12 #23

  Glinny wrote: »

  Why on earth is she there She was in a girl pop band who did dance routines like most other girl bands.
  
  Only there off of the back of coming second on ITV's IACGMOOH.
  
  Hardly the credentials for judging ice dancing is it?

  
  Pussycat Doll Ashley Roberts Choreographs Suns Dancers Auditions
  http://blogs.phoenixnewtimes.com/uponsun/2009/08/pussycat_doll_ashley_roberts_c.php
  
  She is a professional dancer.
  
  http://forums.digitalspy.co.uk/showpost.php?p=63235296&postcount=29

  0
• [Deleted User] Posts: 176

  Forum Member

  ✭

  06/01/13 - 20:13 #24

  I really like her! I think shes adorable! Cant wait to see her settle in over the next few weeks!

  0
• deivu74 Posts: 3,001

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  06/01/13 - 20:14 #25

  Pointless. All she kept saying was "your lines were great but your Arabesque needs a bit more".

  0
• gingercodgers Posts: 1,037

  Forum Member

  ✭✭✭

  06/01/13 - 20:18 #26

  -Sid- wrote: »

  It's all about the 'fierceness'. She's just another Alesha.
  
  One performance judge is more than enough.
  
  She's pointless.

  
  Come on Sid she isn't pointless. Someone had to sit between Jason and Karen and Robin didn't fancy the job:rolleyes:

  0