It wouldn't surprise me if they both came back. Obviously, this story comes out every year but I think if Simon was to come back to the UK version (which seems more likely than ever), then I can see Cheryl back on the show too.
I think Dannii will be the question mark. Didn't she comment about Sharon's return - something about it's not always a good idea to go back? I would love Dannii to come back but I think she's the one least likely to.
This is perhaps the reason why Sharon was brought back this year; someone the audience already knows to temporarily fill a seat before the 2010 panel returns in 2014?
To be honest, as long as Simon comes back to XF - I'll be happy.
I just hope if it's a case that Dannii doesn't return, that Nicole doesn't stay - I love Nicole but I'd hate to see her treated in the same way Dannii was in 2008
It wouldn't surprise me if they both came back. Obviously, this story comes out every year but I think if Simon was to come back to the UK version (which seems more likely than ever), then I can see Cheryl back on the show too.
I think Dannii will be the question mark. Didn't she comment about Sharon's return - something about it's not always a good idea to go back? I would love Dannii to come back but I think she's the one least likely to.
This is perhaps the reason why Sharon was brought back this year; someone the audience already knows to temporarily fill a seat before the 2010 panel returns in 2014?
To be honest, as long as Simon comes back to XF - I'll be happy.
I just hope if it's a case that Dannii doesn't return, that Nicole doesn't stay - I love Nicole but I'd hate to see her treated in the same way Dannii was in 2008
I'm sure they trotted this story out last year as well?
Definitely PR to try and keep people interested, Cheryl will never come back after the X Factor USA fiasco.
I think she will ... as shown by them now settling the court case.
I think this has been planned for over a year and they agreed way back and its why she took the career break. I don't think the story trotted out last year was for PR ... i think it was for real, she was coming back and they made the decision to delay.
I don't see Danni back, probably Mrs O again.
Always predicted the court case would get settled, that was never going to court
I think she will ... as shown by them now settling the court case.
I think this has been planned for over a year and they agreed way back and its why she took the career break. I don't think the story trotted out last year was for PR ... i think it was for real, she was coming back and they made the decision to delay.
I don't see Danni back, probably Mrs O again.
Always predicted the court case would get settled, that was never going to court
I dont see Dannii returning either. Shes on the Oz version now.
I think she will ... as shown by them now settling the court case.
I think this has been planned for over a year and they agreed way back and its why she took the career break. I don't think the story trotted out last year was for PR ... i think it was for real, she was coming back and they made the decision to delay.
I don't see Danni back, probably Mrs O again.
Always predicted the court case would get settled, that was never going to court
I dont see Dannii returning either. Shes on the Oz version now.
I agree. I personally love Dannii as a judge, but I do not think she would return to the UK show. She left on a high back in 2010 and going back would ruin that moment in my opinion. I think she will do a few more series of the Aussie show though.:)
I think she will ... as shown by them now settling the court case.
I think this has been planned for over a year and they agreed way back and its why she took the career break. I don't think the story trotted out last year was for PR ... i think it was for real, she was coming back and they made the decision to delay.
I don't see Danni back, probably Mrs O again.
Always predicted the court case would get settled, that was never going to court
Good post.
I see Nicole staying next year, rather than Sharon. I think a Nicole/Cheryl/Louis and Simon panel next year is more likely than A Sharon/Nicole/Louise/ Simon panel, or a Dannii/Louis/Simon and Cheryl panel.
i think SImon will be back, he might bring Demi with him (Which i wouldnt mind) and IF Dannii and Louis come back that would be a good panel!
Demi Lovato is a pretty good mentor and so would be a fabulous addition to the UK XF. The fact that she's as cute as a button can't be bad either, but two American judges is going too far and Nicole is an excellent judge/mentor. Cheryl Cole is a stunningly attractive woman, but all she has to do is open her mouth and I want to turn the telly off - and that's not just when she's "singing". Let's not have her back.
I agree. I personally love Dannii as a judge, but I do not think she would return to the UK show. She left on a high back in 2010 and going back would ruin that moment in my opinion. I think she will do a few more series of the Aussie show though.:)
Never say never,but I dont think Dannii would join as a judge again. She has meetings lined up soon so who knows what will happen.
Demi Lovato is a pretty good mentor and so would be a fabulous addition to the UK XF. The fact that she's as cute as a button can't be bad either, but two American judges is going too far and Nicole is an excellent judge/mentor. Cheryl Cole is a stunningly attractive woman, but all she has to do is open her mouth and I want to turn the telly off - and that's not just when she's "singing". Let's not have her back.
Sorry no. Just no. How she murdered Jennel and Danie and is about to murder Khaya makes me say no just no.
She's annoying and makes the show look tacky. At least Nicole brings a bit of class to the panel. No way should the one good American in the panel be substituted out for another who can't even sort out her own hair colour.
they wouldnt move dannii from oz XF, especially after she's just won.I doubt she'd want to work directly with simon either. They also wouldn't change 3 members of the panel in one go.
Cheryl agreed to come back a year ago. Everyone said at the time it was rubbish and she never would, she's suing them, blah blah blah. Ask yourself why she'd rest and do nothing if she didn't know she already had another job lined up. The idea that these people sign up just before the series is total rubbish - its at least rough planned years ahead.
Sharon is desperate to do the US version of X Factor, providing it's not axed obviously. I think it was popbitch who said Kelly had been overheard saying her mum is only doing XF Uk so she can the US gig next year.
Sharon is desperate to do the US version of X Factor, providing it's not axed obviously. I think it was popbitch who said Kelly had been overheard saying her mum is only doing XF Uk so she can the US gig next year.
If it isn't axed would they move simon? I think more likely they will move X-Factor UK in the schedules so he can do both.
I could see sharon doing xf usa but also staying if asked. Basically, anything for a job.
The panels could be so much stronger without louis but that aint ever gonna happen..
I'm not sure what to believe in all honesty. Reports suggest that Cowell is definitely returning to the UK show next year. Some are saying he's going to leave TXFUSA, while others are saying TXFUSA is going to get entirely axed. I personally think the latter option is more feasible, but we'll see.
I love Dannii even more now then I did then but Im confused with all the stories of them all returning. Cheryl and simon arent exactly besties nowadays, Dannii has moved awayfrom it all not commeting on her and Simon and Simon is just glowing like hes the one whos pregnant.
If they were to return they would have to bring XFUS stage and production to next years series cos that is awesome.
Comments
I think Dannii will be the question mark. Didn't she comment about Sharon's return - something about it's not always a good idea to go back? I would love Dannii to come back but I think she's the one least likely to.
This is perhaps the reason why Sharon was brought back this year; someone the audience already knows to temporarily fill a seat before the 2010 panel returns in 2014?
To be honest, as long as Simon comes back to XF - I'll be happy.
I just hope if it's a case that Dannii doesn't return, that Nicole doesn't stay - I love Nicole but I'd hate to see her treated in the same way Dannii was in 2008
What happened with Dannii in 2008?
I think she will ... as shown by them now settling the court case.
I think this has been planned for over a year and they agreed way back and its why she took the career break. I don't think the story trotted out last year was for PR ... i think it was for real, she was coming back and they made the decision to delay.
I don't see Danni back, probably Mrs O again.
Always predicted the court case would get settled, that was never going to court
I dont see Dannii returning either. Shes on the Oz version now.
Sharon has said she's only doing this series.
Well, the reports of Dannii returning weren't untrue. She was offered the job, but she ultimately turned it down.
I agree. I personally love Dannii as a judge, but I do not think she would return to the UK show. She left on a high back in 2010 and going back would ruin that moment in my opinion. I think she will do a few more series of the Aussie show though.:)
Good post.
I see Nicole staying next year, rather than Sharon. I think a Nicole/Cheryl/Louis and Simon panel next year is more likely than A Sharon/Nicole/Louise/ Simon panel, or a Dannii/Louis/Simon and Cheryl panel.
Demi Lovato is a pretty good mentor and so would be a fabulous addition to the UK XF. The fact that she's as cute as a button can't be bad either, but two American judges is going too far and Nicole is an excellent judge/mentor. Cheryl Cole is a stunningly attractive woman, but all she has to do is open her mouth and I want to turn the telly off - and that's not just when she's "singing". Let's not have her back.
Never say never,but I dont think Dannii would join as a judge again. She has meetings lined up soon so who knows what will happen.
Sorry no. Just no. How she murdered Jennel and Danie and is about to murder Khaya makes me say no just no.
She's annoying and makes the show look tacky. At least Nicole brings a bit of class to the panel. No way should the one good American in the panel be substituted out for another who can't even sort out her own hair colour.
Dannii is 42, which is hardly old.
so had louis ... but things change.
it will be sharon or nicole.
they wouldnt move dannii from oz XF, especially after she's just won.I doubt she'd want to work directly with simon either. They also wouldn't change 3 members of the panel in one go.
Cheryl agreed to come back a year ago. Everyone said at the time it was rubbish and she never would, she's suing them, blah blah blah. Ask yourself why she'd rest and do nothing if she didn't know she already had another job lined up. The idea that these people sign up just before the series is total rubbish - its at least rough planned years ahead.
If it isn't axed would they move simon? I think more likely they will move X-Factor UK in the schedules so he can do both.
I could see sharon doing xf usa but also staying if asked. Basically, anything for a job.
The panels could be so much stronger without louis but that aint ever gonna happen..
According to Wootton they are both wanted back by Simon.
It would feel like they are going backwards, but who cares. It was the best judging panel and i want it back.
If they were to return they would have to bring XFUS stage and production to next years series cos that is awesome.