Options
Why do people on this site hate Rose Tyler *SO* Much?
MrsDavidTennant
Posts: 1,760
Forum Member
✭✭✭
I can't help but notice the massive anti-Rose feeling on this Site? But I a not against people having there own opinions but loads of people say she was smug?
But this site does seem to have a high number of haters, :eek:
So whats this smugness?! And that they LIke Season 1 Rose more to season 2
But this site does seem to have a high number of haters, :eek:
So whats this smugness?! And that they LIke Season 1 Rose more to season 2
0
Comments
Rose is popular in the Fan "world" but this site maybe I am wrong does have a high number of haters, maybe I just notice it more because I am like what! what! :eek:
But she was indeed popular with in her fans, but I doubt that she was being treated as if she was bigger than the show
I could be wrong, but I donno it just sometimes get me down when everyone is talking about bad things, and how she ruined season 2 :rolleyes: maybe I am being over senstive
I agree with you there that some people cant help but moan about every aspect of the New Version
i like rose but dr was ready for a change
Nah I think that, I don't think I would enjoy the old show as much, maybe because I am a different generation and have grown up on a different style of Tv Shows
I would have to agree I hope they have not bought her back for the sake of it and it is something integral to the storyline.
I also agree with you there, and I felt that Donna could have moved the show on.
But I hope that we get a whole new cast soon, just a brand new Doctor and a brand new compiaion so we cant go back there, there isn't really any ties.
But now that Rose is coming back I am looking forward to it, but I feel that I have season 1 & 2 to enjoy her, I don't really need anymore but I am pleased there is
If that makes any sense
It felt to me like her personality was designed to over shadow The Doctor entirely at times, I didn't feel like we really got to understand anything about DT's Doctor until series 3, which was frustrating. It was obviously a conscious choice of the writers though. I suppose it doesn't help that series 2 was a bit on the weak side overall.....
what has the old series got to do with Rose Tyler except it is yet another opportunity to bash it over the wonderful new one.
The finale was good, plus School Reunion, The Girl In The FirePlace and The Impossible Planet two parter..other than that I didn't really care for series 2 much....