Options
F1 Korea Recording
Badvok
Posts: 972 Forum Member
✭✭
Does anyone have a Freesat+ box that actually handled recording all of Sunday morning's F1 fiasco? (Fantastic final result though 
Go Alonso!)
Mainly due to rain on the freshly laid track the race was both delayed and interrupted. So the original schedule of BBC 1 6:00am - 9:15am was revised to be BBC 1 until 9:30am and then switch over to BBC 2 until 10:30am.
My Foxsat HDR recorded only the BBC 1 bit from 6:00am to 9:30am. The recording is a series linked schedule entry so I would have expected it to be able to handle this sort of thing. Instead I had to wait until the afternoon repeat to see the second half of the race.
I have no idea whether this was this the fault of the box, the EPG entries or whether it is a fundamental issue with the way the EPG is managed that means this sort of thing can never be handled. Any ideas?
Go Alonso!)Mainly due to rain on the freshly laid track the race was both delayed and interrupted. So the original schedule of BBC 1 6:00am - 9:15am was revised to be BBC 1 until 9:30am and then switch over to BBC 2 until 10:30am.
My Foxsat HDR recorded only the BBC 1 bit from 6:00am to 9:30am. The recording is a series linked schedule entry so I would have expected it to be able to handle this sort of thing. Instead I had to wait until the afternoon repeat to see the second half of the race.
I have no idea whether this was this the fault of the box, the EPG entries or whether it is a fundamental issue with the way the EPG is managed that means this sort of thing can never be handled. Any ideas?
0
Comments
I don't know if the boxes, or the indeed the system, is capable of such an action - but regardless, it's pretty likely that the BBC made no such changes anyway.
My Sky+ box didn't do it either, so I reset it to record the afternoon version - I also impressed myself by starting playing it back from 82 minutes, and hit dead on lap 40 which is where it went off in the morning
CHEAT ! Use of "DIY" firmware extension.
It was great though to have the ability when I had a Topfield, shame no one else has followed this model to allow firmware extensions and even Topfield have dropped from later models - maybe YouView will allow such things, seems like its being placed as a more open platform.
The BBC were good in that they had updated the BBC2 schedule well ahead of the time at which it switched over (9:30). Looking at my recordings list, I had a 0m recording that started and ended at 9:30 on BBC2. The error message was "conflict with higher priority recording".
So it looks like it was close to working! It clearly didn't though, luckily I heard the box turn off and manually turned it back on and hit record.
One thing I did notice when I turned the box on to manually record it at 9:30 was that the schedule on BBC2 didn't appear to have rolled over - i.e. it was still showing the previous programme when you pressed 'i'. I suspect this may have had something to do with it.
To be honest, I don't really expect a PVR to be able to cope when a broadcaster moves a programme from one channel to another whilst it's airing - it's a pretty tricky thing to cope with.
It failed on my HDR and on Sky HD too. Luckily i was able to view the "missing" laps on Red Button - I wasn't around during the day to record the repeat. I agree that it would be a great feature to have on both platforms.
However, the idiotic system is quite capable of setting up a scheduled timer for the first episode of The Big Silence on BBC Wales tomorrow night, when I have already recorded this episode last Friday on BBC2! Presumably, BBC Wales didn't show The Big Silence last Friday.
Back on topic, I was fortunate with the F1 race on Sunday as I was watching it live and thus able to follow it over to BBC2.
Isnt that because the TV companies give a different ID to the same program on different channels?
After all, the HDR can only record from the info given to it.
My Series Link for the F1 yielded some oddities. Apart from the air being blue when the recording stopped, I did get the re-run recorded later in the day. No failed recordings but two differnt folders! One said Japanese GP, the other Italian!