I think the opposite actually. They weren't urban or edgy enough in my opinion, they sang very safe and boring songs (and not very well). They just seem dated to me, it's a shame as I think with their energy they could really have pulled off some more upbeat modern songs and perhaps I'd have enjoyed them a bit more.
I do think they went down that road to fit in the show.I suspect they were advised to do so.If they sang songs in their genre they wouldnt have got to the semi final because the demographics of te viewers dont comprehend or know those songs.If Nicole had been their mentor they would have done urban street songs.The songs were Gary Barlow style.
They did enough to get a deal to record their style of music.
I do think they went down that road to fit in the show.I suspect they were advised to do so.If they sang songs in their genre they wouldnt have got to the semi final because the demographics of te viewers dont comprehend or know those songs.If Nicole had been their mentor they would have done urban street songs.The songs were Gary Barlow style.
They did enough to get a deal to record their style of music.
Lets face it, nothing that enters and exits from X Factor is leftfield/edgy/street or original for that matter.
I do think they went down that road to fit in the show.I suspect they were advised to do so.If they sang songs in their genre they wouldnt have got to the semi final because the demographics of te viewers dont comprehend or know those songs.If Nicole had been their mentor they would have done urban street songs.The songs were Gary Barlow style.
They did enough to get a deal to record their style of music.
Have you heard any of their own songs? They are actually pretty good and definitely R&B.
I hope they get a deal with someone who gets them and they don't do a JLS and sell out completely for fame and money.
As bad as Gary was as a mentor, if they wouldn't have had the problems last year with Kaz then Louis would have been their mentor and they'd have been wearing shiny suits and performing Westlife covers on stools doing airgrabs
They are an R&B band who allowed themselves to be watered down to get exposure on a tv talent show.
Having heard material they've done prior to the show, it is a million miles from most of the dross they were asked to churn out for prime time tv.
I think it ended up not quite working as their image and style didn't fit with the songs they were performing. The few times they did do up tempo or showed glimpses of who they really are were their best weeks by far.
Hopefully, they'll get something out of this on a label who gets them more than the XF did
I would suggest it was their inability to sing in tune.
That is exactly what i was about to say...and the crowd at my local who watched it on the big screen for a laugh thought the same... Luke was liked....:)
That is exactly what i was about to say...and the crowd at my local who watched it on the big screen for a laugh thought the same... Luke was liked....:)
I'm not sure you can trust the opinions of ethanol addicts at one of their "sessions".
RC might be Gary Barlow's idea of edgy/urban, but by definition anyone who really fell into that category wouldn't be seen dead on this show. And they were pretty weak singers who couldn't harmonise. They only lasted so long because they performed well and had a little bit of charisma.
Have you heard any of their own songs? They are actually pretty good and definitely R&B.
I hope they get a deal with someone who gets them and they don't do a JLS and sell out completely for fame and money.
As bad as Gary was as a mentor, if they wouldn't have had the problems last year with Kaz then Louis would have been their mentor and they'd have been wearing shiny suits and performing Westlife covers on stools doing airgrabs
No I havent but from the show I could tell that they pretty knew what they were doing.Them and Gary and those around them knew who they are and that they had to fit in the show to give themselves a platform.
I have watched some of their interviews pre Xfactor,they have been supporting big acts and are known on the circuit.
I watched them this morning and even the presenters were like 'this was just a competetion'.Stirling talked of a single and album after the Xfactor tour.
I cant see them not being signed.They have more commercial value than any of the finalists.They did enough to get a record deal for their own songs.
Imo Rough Copy's performances were not very Urban, and I think they got the least votes last night because certain demos keep ruining the competition by keep voting for Nicholas when I don't think he should be getting votes.
They are an R&B band who allowed themselves to be watered down to get exposure on a tv talent show.
Having heard material they've done prior to the show, it is a million miles from most of the dross they were asked to churn out for prime time tv.
I think it ended up not quite working as their image and style didn't fit with the songs they were performing. The few times they did do up tempo or showed glimpses of who they really are were their best weeks by far.
Hopefully, they'll get something out of this on a label who gets them more than the XF did
You know I would agree with you. I know they can sing and that is what disappoints me about them...and I agree that some of the materials they did before XF was good. I'm hoping someone signs them as well because I know they are not as bad as what we seen on TV or what people think
They are not in the final because when there was not a track of backing singers covering them they were very obviously woefully out of tune. I do like them but they did have tuning problems.
I would also say they were not edgy or left of field enough - they were actually a bit boy band IMO.
That is exactly what i was about to say...and the crowd at my local who watched it on the big screen for a laugh thought the same... Luke was liked....:)
Luke can be liked but he doesnt have the commercial value RC have.Record Executives use their heads not hearts.That is why Sharon did a runner because she used her heart to allow a boring final.
They are not in the final because when there was not a track of backing singers covering them they were very obviously woefully out of tune. I do like them but they did have tuning problems.
I would also say they were not edgy or left of field enough - they were actually a bit boy band IMO.
Huh? They are not girls?
That was a show image which they adopted to get exposure.They are not a pop act.
I do think they went down that road to fit in the show.I suspect they were advised to do so.If they sang songs in their genre they wouldnt have got to the semi final because the demographics of te viewers dont comprehend or know those songs.If Nicole had been their mentor they would have done urban street songs.The songs were Gary Barlow style.
They did enough to get a deal to record their style of music.
I think you're right, I mean, this is the show that tried to market Cher Lloyd as urban, it makes sense that when they actually have a potentially interesting act they'd mess it up. I never warmed to these guys on the show, but I do hope they get to do what they want now they've had a bit of exposure.
Imo Rough Copy's performances were not very Urban, and I think they got the least votes last night because certain demos keep ruining the competition by keep voting for Nicholas when I don't think he should be getting votes.
Ruining the competition by voting for someone who could sing? Cool story, bro.
well they used to be all those things , i don't like that kind of style or music but it is what made them different , not just a generic boy band you normally see on this show. in the end other than the clothes, they abandoned it and lost who they were. they became like other bands that had been on the show , normal singing. im sure they used to rap before they got into the final?
Comments
I do think they went down that road to fit in the show.I suspect they were advised to do so.If they sang songs in their genre they wouldnt have got to the semi final because the demographics of te viewers dont comprehend or know those songs.If Nicole had been their mentor they would have done urban street songs.The songs were Gary Barlow style.
They did enough to get a deal to record their style of music.
Lets face it, nothing that enters and exits from X Factor is leftfield/edgy/street or original for that matter.
Exactly and anything else is cocky and arrogant.That is the truth.
How many urban/street acts have been on the Xfactor?? Even rappers,country and rock singers wouldnt win it.It is a pop show.
Have you heard any of their own songs? They are actually pretty good and definitely R&B.
I hope they get a deal with someone who gets them and they don't do a JLS and sell out completely for fame and money.
As bad as Gary was as a mentor, if they wouldn't have had the problems last year with Kaz then Louis would have been their mentor and they'd have been wearing shiny suits and performing Westlife covers on stools doing airgrabs
Absolutely. I doubt The Do or GY!BE would get much beyond the room auditions.
Love your post. I agree with you 100%
I'm not sure you can trust the opinions of ethanol addicts at one of their "sessions".
No I havent but from the show I could tell that they pretty knew what they were doing.Them and Gary and those around them knew who they are and that they had to fit in the show to give themselves a platform.
I have watched some of their interviews pre Xfactor,they have been supporting big acts and are known on the circuit.
I watched them this morning and even the presenters were like 'this was just a competetion'.Stirling talked of a single and album after the Xfactor tour.
I cant see them not being signed.They have more commercial value than any of the finalists.They did enough to get a record deal for their own songs.
You know I would agree with you. I know they can sing and that is what disappoints me about them...and I agree that some of the materials they did before XF was good. I'm hoping someone signs them as well because I know they are not as bad as what we seen on TV or what people think
I would also say they were not edgy or left of field enough - they were actually a bit boy band IMO.
Luke can be liked but he doesnt have the commercial value RC have.Record Executives use their heads not hearts.That is why Sharon did a runner because she used her heart to allow a boring final.
Huh? They are not girls?
That was a show image which they adopted to get exposure.They are not a pop act.
I think you're right, I mean, this is the show that tried to market Cher Lloyd as urban, it makes sense that when they actually have a potentially interesting act they'd mess it up. I never warmed to these guys on the show, but I do hope they get to do what they want now they've had a bit of exposure.
Ruining the competition by voting for someone who could sing? Cool story, bro.
they're very near the edge of the correct note
Yes ruining the Xfactor franchise by voting for someone who wiill not sell a single record and contribute to a boring final.
Oh ok, Mystic Meg.
Honestly surprised they got this far to be honest.