In Home Alone did u prefer the shovel guy or the Pigeon Lady?

TheSlayer10 · 18/12/10 - 21:35

Both basically served the same purpose towards Kevin in both 1 and 2

Personally I prefer the Pigeon Lady as she reminded me of an old Primary School teacher I had as a kid.

Pencil · 18/12/10 - 21:47

Guy with the shovel all the way.

Dunce-2007 · 18/12/10 - 21:51

The shovel guy.

rufnek2k6 · 18/12/10 - 21:52

Definitely the shovel guy, scared the crap out of me at first, but then got to love him.

jjesso123 · 18/12/10 - 22:11

I hated the Pigeon Lady. Was that the second one ? I think that was my worst one. out of the 3 not pointless spin offs.

TheSlayer10 · 18/12/10 - 22:12

awww no love for Mama Pige

meglosmurmurs · 18/12/10 - 22:19

I liked Pigeon Lady best.

Guy with the shovel did not suit those boots, and he just allowed those guys to flood his house. wtf was he doing while they were doing that?

Meanwhile Pigeon Lady can get into music concerts without paying.

Shaiya · 18/12/10 - 22:34

Shovel Guy. Found the Pigeon Lady a little boring.

[Deleted User] · 18/12/10 - 22:49

Isn't the Pigeon Lady, in Casualty? I am sure she is?

Also does anyway notice that Santa's Elf in the first film is a Flight Stewardess in the second film?

Rincewind78 · 18/12/10 - 23:11

I prefered pigean lady, as its Megan from Casulty.

I dont even remember Shovel guy, on account of not seeing Home Alone for nearly 20 years! saw it once at the pictures and thats it!!!!!

fmradiotuner1 · 18/12/10 - 23:15

Like them both but Old Man Marley is better.

treefr0g · 18/12/10 - 23:43

Shovel guy made me cry. I can't say the same for pigeon lady.

Didn't really like Home Alone 2 tbh.

[Deleted User] · 19/12/10 - 00:09

Shovel guy for me. I hate the pigeon lady part of the film.

TheSlayer10 · 19/12/10 - 20:29

So Its

Shovel Guy: 8
Pigeon Lady: 3

booooo

[Deleted User] · 19/12/10 - 20:51

Shovel Guy.

OT - Why do the classic Home Alone's not get shown on tv around Christmas time any more? I miss these films.

fmradiotuner1 · 19/12/10 - 21:00

Ben Etchells wrote: »

Shovel Guy.

OT - Why do the classic Home Alone's not get shown on tv around Christmas time any more? I miss these films.

Because $ky have them

[Deleted User] · 19/12/10 - 21:11

Pigeon Lady. I was properly scared of her. I don't even remember Shovel Guy, but I can still remember what pigeon lady gave to Kevin at the end of the film.

TheSlayer10 · 19/12/10 - 21:13

qwerty282 wrote: »

Pigeon Lady. I was properly scared of her. I don't even remember Shovel Guy, but I can still remember what pigeon lady gave to Kevin at the end of the film.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hwK0kgOq0E8

Vennegoor · 19/12/10 - 22:30

Shovel guy

rfonzo · 19/12/10 - 23:18

The 'shovel guy' was a better character. Nevertheless, he had the advantage on starring in the first film and therefore it was less predictable that he was going to turn out to be a heroic figure.

treefr0g · 19/12/10 - 23:39

Pigeon woman is just a female version of Shovel guy with pigeons instead of a shovel.

cnbcwatcher · 20/12/10 - 01:24

Pigeon lady

[Deleted User] · 20/12/10 - 10:21

SHOVEL GUY.

DUDE HAD A SHOVEL!

Pigeon lady looked like she needed a wash. And pigeons are bogging.

SHOVEL GUY!

RodriguezMan267 · 20/12/10 - 11:05

I'd love to see them in a fight. Imagine his twatting her several times over the head with the shovel as her birds peck his eyes out. Awesome.

[Deleted User] · 20/12/10 - 11:29

kyri wrote: »

I'd love to see them in a fight. Imagine his twatting her several times over the head with the shovel as her birds peck his eyes out. Awesome.

This just made me laugh out loud!! As Harry Hill would say 'So who was better? Shovel Guy or Pigeon Lady, there's only one way to find out.....FIIIIIGHT!!!!

Brass Drag0n · 20/12/10 - 12:27

Another vote here for Shovel Guy.

Hey there!

Quick Links

In Home Alone did u prefer the shovel guy or the Pigeon Lady?

Comments