[StratusSphere]

I know Nicole's been confirmed as the judge, but it would be interesting to see which Spice Girl everyone thinks would have been a better substitute for her.

Not sure how to do a poll, so if anyone wants to change this into a real poll, (or tell me how to) I'd appreciate.

Anyway
Geri Haliwell
Emma Bunton
Victoria Beckham
Mel C
Mel B

[mmeister2]

Victoria Beckham. Just because she'd never do it.

If we're talking about actual possibilities then I'd go with Mel C. She probably had the best solo career out of the bunch and she seems pretty nice.

[Zone_Out]

Geri Or Mel B Mel for how loud she is she certainly wouldn't be boring same for Geri she's mad as a hatter that one lol

[LandslideBrad]

Mel B or Mel C

[mashitup]

Victoria

[Rose-Addict]

Mel C by miles!

[caren197]

Mel c is the only one with a solo career that went beyond a few top 10 hits so I'd say her purely for that reason!

[CUP OF TEAAA!]

Victoria She's really famous!

[LunarLegend]

Mel B.

[jackbell]

Mel C for credibilty. Geri for drama.

[Zack06]

Mel B. I find Geri far too trashy and try hard and she would almost certainly try to takeover the panel. Mel B is also trashy, but she is great on X Factor Australia as the tough female judge and could have worked on the panel...However, I'm glad Nicole did get the job, I'm sure she'll be better than her stint on X Factor US.

[So 3008]

Mel C or Geri.

[wsidi]

Aaahh this thread depresses me. Any Spice Girl would have been exceptional! (Apart from Emma because she's too nice to be a judge)

BUT NO. They go for Nicole Schnitzelseller

[E05297535]

None of them really!!

[Nastyman69]

I wouldn't have any of them at all as a judge, all damn right annoying and no talent whatsoever

[Poison_Ivan]

Geri would have been perfect!

[Poison_Ivan]

Originally Posted by caren197

Mel c is the only one with a solo career that went beyond a few top 10 hits so I'd say her purely for that reason!

Thats where your wrong! Geri has had loads of solo hits and 4 number ones.

[wsidi]

After looking at some videos of their reunion yesterday, Victoria could be GOLD.

I find her fascinating! Tulisa and her would HATE eachother!

[XFactorFanatic1]

Is there a none option?

[yohinnchild]

Mel C by a huge mile... she's had by far the most successful post music career (only really rivaled by Emma).

[Poison_Ivan]

Originally Posted by yohinnchild

Mel C by a huge mile... she's had by far the most successful post music career (only really rivaled by Emma).

I dont agree. If you check the facts then i think your find Geri has and shes only really rivaled by Melanie C. Just because Melanie releases more music doesnt mean shes the most successful. I admire her for it but shes not exactly setting the charts on fire. Shes had the most singles and albums released yes but you cant really say most successful. Worldwide sales rank Geri as the most successful followed by Melanie C. And when people say Geri hasnt had a hit for years well that maybe true but shes not released any sort of single since Desire which just missed the top 20. If Melanie gets that chart postion then thats a hit for her! Having said that i really do admre Melanie shes so good to her fans.

[E05297535]

Originally Posted by wsidi

After looking at some videos of their reunion yesterday, Victoria could be GOLD.

I find her fascinating! Tulisa and her would HATE eachother!

Well....if VB can kick (Tuloosa's) butt, she would have made my day!! I've changed my mind......VB for XF judge!!

[THEXFACTORKING]

Posh spice. So I can laugh at her criticizing people about notes lol

[blueface2222]

Mel C.

Although all will be good.

Still abit miffed at Victoria's attitude at the musical launch...
Why act so distant and seperate!? she has no confidence issues so its obvious she didn't want to be there but crack a smile woman! The others seemed quite annoyed of her too.