If you could swap one new judge for one old judge, who would it be?

[Deleted User] · 22/10/11 - 23:35

If you could swap one new judge for the old judge they "replaced", which would you choose?

[Deleted User] · 22/10/11 - 23:35

Kelly off, Sharon back on. yeh I now thats not technically what you asked, but she was a judge.

If I HAD to pick one that left - id take Simon back in place of Kelly.

Dandem · 22/10/11 - 23:35

Louis for Brian Freidman

Mr Blonde · 22/10/11 - 23:35

Kelly Rowland for Sharon Osbourne...

[Deleted User] · 22/10/11 - 23:36

I'd swap Tulisa for Dannii

whoyouarexo · 22/10/11 - 23:37

Kelly for Cheryl/Simon

Contains Nuts · 22/10/11 - 23:37

Nicole Scherz & Nikki Chapman off Pop Idol for Tulisa & Kelly

Unigal07 · 22/10/11 - 23:37

I've loved the new panel but tonight I would happily swap Tulisa for Dannii.

[Deleted User] · 22/10/11 - 23:38

Kelly for Danni.

Simon and Gary aren't really all that different in the way they judge. Garys probably a somewhat better mentor.

Tulisa is a far better judge than Cheryl, who cared more about herself.

Danni is imo a better judge than Kelly.

OK Then!!! · 22/10/11 - 23:39

My ideal panel of current and former judges would be-

Simon (head judge, no category and making guest appearences)
Cheryl
Kelly
Dannii
Gary

I do really like Tulisa as a mentor, but as a judge i dont feel she gives great or original enough comments.

[Deleted User] · 22/10/11 - 23:40

Either Kelly for Danni or Tulisa for Cheryl. I'd keep Gary.

Actually can I swap Tulisa for Simon?

funkycub · 22/10/11 - 23:44

tim38x wrote: »

I'd swap Tulisa for Dannii

same..

[Deleted User] · 22/10/11 - 23:47

Definitely get rid of Kelly and bring back Dannii. Kelly is just really irritating and always thinks that her opinion is all that matters. At least Dannii was honest with the acts and told it like it was exactly the way Tulisa is.

Visitor Q · 22/10/11 - 23:48

Bring Sharon back. Yes, she can be a horrible bitchy old trout, but at least her opinions were worth listening to. Sometimes.

[Deleted User] · 22/10/11 - 23:48

I'd swap Louis for...any of them. Simon/Cheryl/Sharon/Danni...I don't care haha. But out of the new ones, I'd swap Gary for Simon.

[Deleted User] · 22/10/11 - 23:50

I'd keep both Kelly/Dannii.

phill363 · 22/10/11 - 23:57

gary for sharon osborne

Darcyprincess · 23/10/11 - 00:03

OK Then!!! wrote: »

My ideal panel of current and former judges would be-

Simon (head judge, no category and making guest appearences)
Cheryl
Kelly
Dannii
Gary

I do really like Tulisa as a mentor, but as a judge i dont feel she gives great or original enough comments.

Yes, I totally agree with you but I think that I would get rid of Kelly as well and have Gary, Cheryl, Dannii and Simon on the panel. The panel was a total shambles tonight. Kelly was totally rude, and Tulisa and Louis were both out of order with the outing of Mischa. Then they were all brawling and it was a disgrace! I know that Simon wants drama, but this was way too much and it got out of control tonight!

[Deleted User] · 23/10/11 - 00:04

Kelly for Sharon/Dannii/Simon/Cheryl! I had faith in Kelly to begin.. but her comments are repeated constantly, and she turned every song into a ballad tonight, that isn't rock. Tulisa was spot on IMO. Kelly should've been on the US panel!