I think you will find that the original was a daytime show! The new series is on every day Mon-Fri at 4.30.
I'm aware of that. I used to rush home from school to watch it every day. But daytime TV is inherently dumb (15 to One, like Countdown, being a rare exception) and it's arguably even more dumb now than it ever was when 15 to One first aired. I doubt the reboot will be bucking that trend.
Be interesting to see how the new show pans out. I dont think anyone could replicate Bill Stewart but will give Sandi Toksvig a chance as the show itself was so good. I hope they retain the concept of quick firing and fairly difficult questions to up the ante from some of the dumbed down afternoon quiz shows weve seen over the last couple of years
If they're going to change it that much, why bother resurrecting an old, much loved tv series at all? Why not create a brand new, chatty quiz format or are channel 4 totally devoid of original ideas now? Stupid question, really.
It's because the celeb version was successful on the C4 anniversary night.
The celeb version was szanny and dumbed down like you would expect but I hope the series is more like the original. It sounds as though they are doing some chat and getting to know you stuff which I could do without and I suspect many agree as it was something that the original didn't have and why it was loved.
If they're going to change it that much, why bother resurrecting an old, much loved tv series at all? Why not create a brand new, chatty quiz format or are channel 4 totally devoid of original ideas now? Stupid question, really.
The C4 of old always used to fob off any popular demand for remakes with the line that it is not in their remit to even consider them. So, the fact that this is even happening probably answers your question.
I will give it a shot as I have fond memories of the show and quite like Sandi, but an hour, really? I wouldn't be dreading it as much if it were half an hour, or even 45 minutes.
It's because the celeb version was successful on the C4 anniversary night.
The celeb version was szanny and dumbed down like you would expect but I hope the series is more like the original. It sounds as though they are doing some chat and getting to know you stuff which I could do without and I suspect many agree as it was something that the original didn't have and why it was loved.
Me too. The implication of course is that the original format of the show and the type of questions asked was in some way imperfect and it needs perfecting, and making more popular, by having a random celebrity doing the presenting and including inane drivel about people's private lives. I don't care what someone does for a living, where they come from or how they feel getting to the final round.
As I said, I hope the whole thing crashes and burns. That'll teach them to mess with highly-thought of formats.
Just like when ITV brought back Through the Keyhole - how dumbed down can you get (although I actually enjoyed that!)
15-1 doesn't need "getting to know you" with it's contestants - who cares about their story, they'll be gone within three episodes! Just get on with the game!
Just like when ITV brought back Through the Keyhole - how dumbed down can you get (although I actually enjoyed that!)
15-1 doesn't need "getting to know you" with it's contestants - who cares about their story, they'll be gone within three episodes! Just get on with the game!
Good question. Is anyone ever interested in the background stories of various contestants??
15-1 doesn't need "getting to know you" with it's contestants - who cares about their story, they'll be gone within three episodes! Just get on with the game!
Absolutely right! What made it so good was that there was ZERO inane banter, even to the extent of introducing us to the guests during the opening music. Perfect but I fear 15 to 1 MKII will simply prove that the days of quality daytime quiz shows are long gone.
Being honest, the fact it's been extended for 'padding' and the fact it has someone who we're told wants to build a relationship with the contestants is a worry. It's why I generally record and fast forward through Pointless (which I really like), as I have no interest in the fluff. Basically, it ought to be how it used to be, no farting about, just quick fire questions, no fluff, and get on with it.
I'm willing to give it a try, but I'd be lying if I said I feel the new version will be an improvement in ANY way over the William G Stewart version. I might be pleasantly surprised, but I'm not counting on it.
In response to Kapellmeister's question, quite simply no, nobody gives a flying monkeys nuts about a contestant's story, I've no doubt everyone is happy enough to just hear "I'm Bill from Clyde" rather than "I'm Bill from Clyde, I work in IT, I used to be a semi professional footballer and now live with my wife and 3 kids, and I enjoy reading, watching TV and having a few drinks with my friends, I also once met Cheryl Cole backstage at an awards ceremony and got her to autograph my chest"
The fact it's on Saturday tea-time tells us everything we need to know about it.
While I strongly suspect that you're totally correct in this case, that time slot isn't necessarily the waste bin of television. For example, there was a rather successful series that used to be shown then in which two teachers were kidnapped by the grandfather of one of their pupils...
Sandy Toskvig on the One Show - mainly about her same sex wedding, but some stuff on 15 to 1. Not only does she "get to know the contestants" but also she "can't stop herself from comedy"....
Sandy Toskvig on the One Show - mainly about her same sex wedding, but some stuff on 15 to 1. Not only does she "get to know the contestants" but also she "can't stop herself from comedy"....
Sandy Toskvig on the One Show - mainly about her same sex wedding, but some stuff on 15 to 1. Not only does she "get to know the contestants" but also she "can't stop herself from comedy"....
I am sure she won't be cracking a joke after every question..just adding in a little something here and there..surely that isn't the end of the world? I would be surprised that she would try and get to know all 15 contestants..surely that part would be when they have whittled down?
Of course I could be completely wrong but I will see on saturday first and then post my disgust lol (if I am)
The fact it's on Saturday tea-time tells us everything we need to know about it.
Can we get this clear, the new series is on Monday to Friday at 4.30pm. The Saturday slot would appear to be an introductory one off (unless it's going to be on six days a week).
Can we get this clear, the new series is on Monday to Friday at 4.30pm. The Saturday slot would appear to be an introductory one off (unless it's going to be on six days a week).
It's not scheduled for the following Saturday. 20 episodes over 4 weeks was what I gathered. Of course, with this Saturday show, there are now 19 to run over the weekdays, so it will either end early or be interrupted, somewhere.
I presumes she meant "off screen" she finds out what they want to do if they won the money
Unfortunately i'm thinking that in parts of the show they will stop for a breather and will be asked the ubiquitous question of 'What will you do with the money if you win?"
Perhaps it is unfair to judge the programme before we've seen it. But this is from the promo material on the Channel 4 website:
"Each hour long episode showcases Sandi Toksvig's camaraderie with the contestants,and throughout the show she will also offer up her near boundless knowledge on the topics that arise."
I don't recall William G. Stewart ever doing any of that. He just got on with asking the questions. It doesn't sound good. But we shall see.
A friend of mine is on Monday's show. He has not told me how he got on. I shall be watching with interest.
Perhaps it is unfair to judge the programme before we've seen it. But this is from the promo material on the Channel 4 website:
"Each hour long episode showcases Sandi Toksvig's camaraderie with the contestants,and throughout the show she will also offer up her near boundless knowledge on the topics that arise."
I don't recall William G. Stewart ever doing any of that. He just got on with asking the questions. It doesn't sound good. But we shall see.
A friend of mine is on Monday's show. He has not told me how he got on. I shall be watching with interest.
Comments
I'm aware of that. I used to rush home from school to watch it every day. But daytime TV is inherently dumb (15 to One, like Countdown, being a rare exception) and it's arguably even more dumb now than it ever was when 15 to One first aired. I doubt the reboot will be bucking that trend.
The celeb version was szanny and dumbed down like you would expect but I hope the series is more like the original. It sounds as though they are doing some chat and getting to know you stuff which I could do without and I suspect many agree as it was something that the original didn't have and why it was loved.
The C4 of old always used to fob off any popular demand for remakes with the line that it is not in their remit to even consider them. So, the fact that this is even happening probably answers your question.
I will give it a shot as I have fond memories of the show and quite like Sandi, but an hour, really? I wouldn't be dreading it as much if it were half an hour, or even 45 minutes.
Me too. The implication of course is that the original format of the show and the type of questions asked was in some way imperfect and it needs perfecting, and making more popular, by having a random celebrity doing the presenting and including inane drivel about people's private lives. I don't care what someone does for a living, where they come from or how they feel getting to the final round.
As I said, I hope the whole thing crashes and burns. That'll teach them to mess with highly-thought of formats.
Edit: Yes, I was completely wrong.
15-1 doesn't need "getting to know you" with it's contestants - who cares about their story, they'll be gone within three episodes! Just get on with the game!
I thought he did too, which is why I was surprised that he'd let it be so violated. Turns out he doesn't, unfortunately.
The fact it's on Saturday tea-time tells us everything we need to know about it.
Good question. Is anyone ever interested in the background stories of various contestants??
Absolutely right! What made it so good was that there was ZERO inane banter, even to the extent of introducing us to the guests during the opening music. Perfect but I fear 15 to 1 MKII will simply prove that the days of quality daytime quiz shows are long gone.
I'm willing to give it a try, but I'd be lying if I said I feel the new version will be an improvement in ANY way over the William G Stewart version. I might be pleasantly surprised, but I'm not counting on it.
In response to Kapellmeister's question, quite simply no, nobody gives a flying monkeys nuts about a contestant's story, I've no doubt everyone is happy enough to just hear "I'm Bill from Clyde" rather than "I'm Bill from Clyde, I work in IT, I used to be a semi professional footballer and now live with my wife and 3 kids, and I enjoy reading, watching TV and having a few drinks with my friends, I also once met Cheryl Cole backstage at an awards ceremony and got her to autograph my chest"
I don't hold out much hope
Nor do I frankly.
I am sure she won't be cracking a joke after every question..just adding in a little something here and there..surely that isn't the end of the world? I would be surprised that she would try and get to know all 15 contestants..surely that part would be when they have whittled down?
Of course I could be completely wrong but I will see on saturday first and then post my disgust lol (if I am)
Can we get this clear, the new series is on Monday to Friday at 4.30pm. The Saturday slot would appear to be an introductory one off (unless it's going to be on six days a week).
lol! Is that a sick joke?
I presumes she meant "off screen" she finds out what they want to do if they won the money
It's not scheduled for the following Saturday. 20 episodes over 4 weeks was what I gathered. Of course, with this Saturday show, there are now 19 to run over the weekdays, so it will either end early or be interrupted, somewhere.
"Each hour long episode showcases Sandi Toksvig's camaraderie with the contestants,and throughout the show she will also offer up her near boundless knowledge on the topics that arise."
I don't recall William G. Stewart ever doing any of that. He just got on with asking the questions. It doesn't sound good. But we shall see.
A friend of mine is on Monday's show. He has not told me how he got on. I shall be watching with interest.
It sounds awful.
:kitty: