Please have Nicole Scherzinger as a judge next year!

iamasinger · 26/10/10 - 15:09

She's fun, absolutely gorgeous and I really think there was a good 'vibe' between her Louie and Simon. Loved it when she gets out her chair and started dancing, you could tell she was really enjoying it!:)
Really showed up the massive gulf in class between her and Cheryl too.

Nastyman69 · 26/10/10 - 15:10

Agreed!! Remove Cheryl and replace her with Nicole

Yuffie · 26/10/10 - 15:14

She was really good ... keep her for the USA version tho

iluvdannii · 26/10/10 - 15:15

unfortunatley if she's gonna replace anyone it will be Dannii. which i think is a mistake as cheryl is marketed as the young pretty girl which is what nicole is to so i think the panel would be really boring with 2 similar judges.

[Deleted User] · 26/10/10 - 15:17

I think i'm the only person who didn't actually like her. She irritates me:o
She seems nice though, and she is quite pretty:)

Yuffie · 26/10/10 - 15:18

tiggy145 wrote: »

I think i'm the only person who didn't actually like her. She irritates me:o
She seems nice though, and she is quite pretty:)

What irratates you about her then ???

[Deleted User] · 26/10/10 - 15:19

Americans wouldnt fit in tothe UK show

iamasinger · 26/10/10 - 15:26

BillyNidNod wrote: »

Americans wouldnt fit in tothe UK show

I thought she fitted in really well tbh.

[Deleted User] · 26/10/10 - 15:29

I really liked her as a guest judge, and it would be good to see her back again.
But isn't she rumoured to be doing US X Factor?

[Deleted User] · 26/10/10 - 15:30

Yuffie wrote: »

What irratates you about her then ???

I don't really know. She just does. Irrational dislike. She is beautiful and talented, but I just don't like her. Ellie Goulding is another one of my irrational dislikes. They just really really irritates me. I'm sure they really care what I think, as they are a billion times more talented than me:)
And I don't not like her because their more talented than me, I like plenty of other singers, it's just them among others, that I don't like.:)

[Deleted User] · 26/10/10 - 15:48

I agree actually I think she was fantastic and brought a genuine warmth to the panel that was distinctly lacking in Cheryl.

SteveOwen · 26/10/10 - 15:50

I agree, OP. Really liked her during her guest stint. She fitted in instantly.

summertime09 · 26/10/10 - 15:53

I havent watched the audition stages of XF for years as i cant stand them, i switched on to see Nicole, although i was not much of a fan of hers i REALLY enjoyed the show, i thought she brought a lot of grandeous to the panel, she seemed more authentic,genuine and honest, she also has the talent to back up her opinions, i thought visually the panel looked more authentic, i would love them to ditch Cheryl, just a little girl playing at grown-up IMHO!!

Yuffie · 26/10/10 - 16:11

tiggy145 wrote: »

I don't really know. She just does. Irrational dislike. She is beautiful and talented, but I just don't like her. Ellie Goulding is another one of my irrational dislikes. They just really really irritates me. I'm sure they really care what I think, as they are a billion times more talented than me:)
And I don't not like her because their more talented than me, I like plenty of other singers, it's just them among others, that I don't like.:)

Ah thats fair enuf too. we all have our unexplainable dislikes !! :cool:

davedub · 26/10/10 - 16:12

Simon will never get rid of cheryl its clearly dannii he doesnt 'gel' with

[Deleted User] · 26/10/10 - 16:16

I LOVED Nicole!! She is actually perfect looking (IMO) - totally, totally beautiful (my current girl crush), and I also loved how she got up and danced and really seemed to just enjoy herself! She makes Cheryl look like a ten year old kid!

davedub · 26/10/10 - 16:17

I think Nicole would be perfect for the Us show

[Deleted User] · 26/10/10 - 16:20

The rating shot up during the period she was there.

I really liked her. She can sing live, she can dance, she was a breath of fresh air.

[Deleted User] · 26/10/10 - 16:29

Yuffie wrote: »

Ah thats fair enuf too. we all have our unexplainable dislikes !! :cool:

I wouldn't mind her replacing Cheryl. At least she knows what shes talking about, and doesn't trundle out the same phrases.:D

[Deleted User] · 26/10/10 - 16:39

Agreed. I was no fan of hers to start with but I thought she was excellent: constructive and well-informed comments and she appeared to be very enthusiastic (which is rarely the case with the other judges). Considerably better than Cole.

garbage456 · 26/10/10 - 16:43

tiggy145 wrote: »

I think i'm the only person who didn't actually like her. She irritates me:o
She seems nice though, and she is quite pretty:)

If it means we can get rid of Cheryl then yes, but to replace anyone else, no

[Deleted User] · 26/10/10 - 16:44

No....

iluvdannii · 26/10/10 - 16:46

davedub wrote: »

Simon will never get rid of cheryl its clearly dannii he doesnt 'gel' with

which is strange seeing as he couldn't get enough of her in series 4!!!!!!

Vol · 26/10/10 - 17:07

Yeah, in the couple of shows she was on I completely forgot about Cheryl Cole. She was the only guest judge that wasn't completely cringe worthy + imo she's a lot more attractive than Cheryl Cole. Would be a welcome change as far as I'm concerned... but I can't see it happening

willywonker · 26/10/10 - 17:10

Nastyman69 wrote: »

Agreed!! Remove Cheryl and replace her with Nicole

Agree.:)

[Deleted User] · 26/10/10 - 17:47

iluvdannii wrote: »

which is strange seeing as he couldn't get enough of her in series 4!!!!!!

Agreed; but she was a novelty then and he smarmed up to Danni to get at Sharon. It was a five minute wonder, and now he has his head so far up Cheryl's behind he's turned into a soppy parody of himself.

I'd be more than happy if the panel consisted of Simon, Nicole, Danni and Louis.

Hey there!

Quick Links

Please have Nicole Scherzinger as a judge next year!

Comments