Doctor Who vs. Torchwood

TranceClubber · 27/08/11 - 20:09

Which one you think is the best and Why ?

[Deleted User] · 27/08/11 - 20:13

I think that TW's COE is better than any series of NewWho.

The current series of TW is no where near as good as the current one of DW though.

So DW overall.

[Deleted User] · 27/08/11 - 20:15

You should have put love both as I won't chose between them.

[Deleted User] · 27/08/11 - 20:17

The best episodes of Doctor Who beat the best episodes of Torchwood for me.

Some of the filler episodes of DW though (eg. Pirate episode) drop the overall standard, it still beats Torchwood though overall.

[Deleted User] · 27/08/11 - 20:19

Doctor Who. Torchwood is just gay porn. :rolleyes:

Scorpio2 · 27/08/11 - 20:22

Doctor \who this series of Torchwood is porn.

Tim Cullen · 27/08/11 - 20:26

I'm preferring the current series of Torchwood to Matt Smith era Doctor Who but the Tom Baker era trumps all.

[Deleted User] · 27/08/11 - 20:27

I'd say Doctor Who, but Torchwood is rather close!

Residents Fan · 27/08/11 - 20:39

Where's the SJA option?

[Deleted User] · 27/08/11 - 20:44

If you asked me a couple of years ago I would have said Doctor Who. But I don't really enjoy Doctor Who much at the moment (Unpopular opinion, I know, but I really don't dig River Song/11th Doctor) Who knows, I may start liking it more after lets kill Hitler, but for now it's Torchwood. Mostly down to Eve Myles but still...

TheSilentFez · 27/08/11 - 20:48

I made this thread ages ago, but couldn't make a poll on it, so thank you for making one.
Doctor Who definitely.
Torchwood gets worse while Doctor Who gets better.

Muttley76 · 27/08/11 - 20:54

Doctor Who will always win out on a poll like this for me, because of it's long and glorious history. I like Torchwood very much, however.

[Deleted User] · 27/08/11 - 20:58

During Tennant era, I would have said Torchwood, but then I was never overly fond of the Tennant era. I'm loving the new Torchwood, but Matt Smith/Moffat's Doctor Who is one of the best things on TV this decade.

Scorpio2 · 27/08/11 - 21:16

Residents Fan wrote: »

Where's the SJA option?

SJA beats them both.

[Deleted User] · 27/08/11 - 21:33

Probably Dr. Who. Dr. Who for me is a little extreme this year, some episodes are okay but some are brilliant.:D Torchwood started out great this year but now Davies seems to be turning it into a male version of Tipping the Velvet, which is really boring for a sci-fi show!:sleep:

davethorp · 27/08/11 - 21:35

Well I like Doctor Who. And I like Torchwood. But which is better? There's only one way to find out....... FIGHT!!

Ideally involving Eve Myles, Karen Gillan and Jelly

[Deleted User] · 27/08/11 - 21:41

I've always loved Doctor Who, and I don't think you an really compare the two, but at the moment I'm enjoying Torchwood more.

Face Of Jack · 27/08/11 - 21:47

Doctor Who definitely. Torchwood - loved it at first, but this recent run is a bit too drawn out and boring.
Actually, after tonights DW, that's going the same way!

Talma · 27/08/11 - 21:51

Who, no question, though I loved Torchwood series 1 & 2 and am very attached to Jack, who's now the only reason I'm still watching it.

[Deleted User] · 27/08/11 - 21:55

davethorp wrote: »

Well I like Doctor Who. And I like Torchwood. But which is better? There's only one way to find out....... FIGHT!!

Ideally involving Eve Myles, Karen Gillan and Jelly

Eve would win the fight without a doubt. But I'd quite happily watch it anyway...

sionnaigh · 27/08/11 - 21:59

Doctor Who no question. Why? Well, Torchwood hasn't got Matt Smith, Arthur Darvill, Karen Gillan and Alex Kingston in it for starters :-).

Hey there!

Quick Links

Doctor Who vs. Torchwood

Doctor Who or Torchwood ? 71 votes

Comments