Options
3G Tethering On Unlimited Plans That State "No Tethering"?
[Deleted User]
Posts: 996
Forum Member
✭✭
I have been looking online, O2, Vodafone & Orange only have limited data plans with tethering available, I currently get 3GB on Orange with tethering included. Only Three and T-Mobile offer unlimited data, T-Mobile don't offer tethering on The Full Monty but do on the limited plans and Three only offer tethering on The One Plan with unlimited data.
My question is If I got a SIM only on T-Mobile The Full Monty or a Three SIM Only with AYCE data but not The One Plan would I still be able to tether now and again, I use Android so it's not blocked or anything and I literally only tether like once every few months so don't want to pay especially for tethering and minutes I won't use.
I know Three flash up a page saying no tethering! Do T-Mobile do that as well? Also are Three and T-Mobile just as good at catching people tethering that shouldn't be or would you get away with it more on one vs the other?
I would rather use Three for like £12 rather than than T-Mobile as for what they charge for unlimited I could just get the one plan... But I was just wondering what one would you get away with unlimited tethering best?
I'm not changing from Orange for a while either, i'm simply curious :P
Surely if it's just a small amount of data now and again (hardly ever) neither network would notice?
Thanks!
My question is If I got a SIM only on T-Mobile The Full Monty or a Three SIM Only with AYCE data but not The One Plan would I still be able to tether now and again, I use Android so it's not blocked or anything and I literally only tether like once every few months so don't want to pay especially for tethering and minutes I won't use.
I know Three flash up a page saying no tethering! Do T-Mobile do that as well? Also are Three and T-Mobile just as good at catching people tethering that shouldn't be or would you get away with it more on one vs the other?
I would rather use Three for like £12 rather than than T-Mobile as for what they charge for unlimited I could just get the one plan... But I was just wondering what one would you get away with unlimited tethering best?
I'm not changing from Orange for a while either, i'm simply curious :P
Surely if it's just a small amount of data now and again (hardly ever) neither network would notice?
Thanks!
0
Comments
Three and tmobile both have a blocked page and can both see when you're tethering.
They also detect if a phone SIM card is used in a (3 branded?) dongle, particularly when you have unlimited data.
I haven't found T-Mobile to care about my tethering, but I do not have unlimited data and only use it sparingly. I have an iPhone and they haven't even turned the tethering feature off.
Lucky
Yep what moox said is 100% correct. T-mobile do the same with the blocked page.
But then again I know people with 3 payg ayce sims who use like 60gb a month and three don't care. Where as others get cut off straight away for just mentioning tethering
This was over a year ago with someone else's PAYG AYCE SIM but I noticed that 3 only appear to detect dongles that they sold.
I have a 3 branded HSPA+ dongle and an Ericsson 3G card in my laptop. The 3 dongle didn't work, everything was redirected to a "put the SIM back in a phone" page, with the laptop it was fine as I guess the IMEI isn't recognised. Traffic wise web browsing seemed to work, I didn't try much else.
Apparently Dropbox and iTunes cause the connection to shut down as it's quite obviously not things a phone could be doing.
Plymouth how come u still have tethering allowed on Tmo then?
Plymouth has tethering because the early full monty allowed tethering but they soon stopped allowing it.
Btw did you check out the £12 virgin deal?
AFAIK, since they removed tethering from the Full Monty tariffs, everyone gets blocked.
Not true, I can still tether ok
The OP is aware of tethering being allowed on the One Plan, his question is whether he would be able to get away with occasional tethering on one of the cheaper Three tariffs with unlimited data.
I think Step meant for new users. Not people like yourself on the original full monty
You mean within 2GB right? That's because usually networks with data limits let you tether as part of their allowance where as networks who give you unlimited data for say £12 would rather not let you tether as using 700GB tethering for £12 is just not sustainable to the network You're more likely to use much less on a phone.
It's an excellent deal. I just found i can get 15%| off as a student as well so i'm happy. Just be aware there is a 10GB speed cap but you say you have 3GB atm so this won't affect you.
If you use a site like quidco you can get cash back to make the sim only deals more affordable.
Your tariff includes tethering, if the OP were to sign up to a Full Monty plan now, it would not and they would be blocked from using it without paying a charge in advance.
I'm on the 'new' Full Monty and I can still tether without issues.
if you have a monthly contract sim with THREE, you can simply add the tethering option for £5. Then the month after if you dont need it, remove it. only add it when needed.
But tbh i'd never sign up to a 24 month contract (without tethering) with the plan to tether 24/7 as the company can cut you off any time for breaching the T&C.
It's why we had a lot of Giff Gaff complaints this time last year. It said in their T&C that tethering was not allowed and so they started to cut off heavy users of tethering and people started to complain. Thing was they should have read the T&C before they even attempted tethering. So like i said it's better to sign up to a plan with tethering that one without and run the risk of getting cut off anytime.
With deep packet inspection the networks can be quite clever. You never know when they are going to tweak the detection either.
They can see all of the data and headers in the packets traversing the network. If some packets coming from you are not in keeping with a mobile device then they can display a tethering block page. If more and more people keep abusing it and not adding the tethering addon then it's likely the detection measures will become more sophisticated.
Here are some things to think about - these are things they could use to detect tethering, I'm not saying they do, but with deep packet inspection they could.
Does your phone do Windows updates or send packets to check to see if there are new updates available. These are done over HTTP with hardcoded desktop user agent strings.
Not just your browser but any software doing anything that connects to the internet over HTTP will use a user agent string. We've seen instances where Three's detection was being triggered by an android app with the wrong user agent string coded.
Even more advanced and unlikely, but if people continue to try and bypass it they could even look at things like the differences in the TCP protocol window sizes between windows desktop / laptop devices and Android / IOS.
If people are on unlimited phone data you can see why the networks would want them to pay £5 more to add another device on the unlimited data plan, as a desktop or laptop device is likely to use a lot more data than a phone.
I read Giffgaff are going to implement sophisticated anti-tethering techniques on plans that don't allow it. it was in the slide deck that they put out when they talked about the price rises, they did say which quarter they planned to introduce it, but I can't remember when it was, sometime in the next 6 months I think.