Lucy should have won
Captain Birdsei
Posts: 1,409 Forum Member
✭✭✭
Very sad that she didn't win. Calibro didn't deserve it in my opinion.
0
Captain Birdsei
Posts: 1,409 Captain Birdsei
Posts: 1,409 Captain Birdsei
Posts: 1,409 Captain Birdsei
Posts: 1,409
Comments
Lucy will do very well
Richard and Adam came 3rd last year and are doing brilliantly
They had my vote last year and Collobro had my vote tonight
Sadly song choice...let her down.... If she would have sung a hayley Westenra number...one that allowed her to sing long, still, sweeping melodic lines....holding notes and gently bringing in the vibrato...she would have stormed this. Her semi final performance was so much better.
Be interesting to see the final voting numbers to see how close she was to winning.
You kind of prove my point. You're female and you voted for the good looking male singers. The other three on this thread before you disagree with you and are all guys who didn't vote. Well I know I didn't vote anyway and i wouldn't dream of voting on a show like this. Females have the power on a show like this.
I think that it always been that females prefer the male singers and males prefer the female singers
I did not like Jack Pack
I think that it is because that it is more females that go to musicals like Les Misrables or go to see classical cross over singers.
I can't see her doing Opera full stop - at least for a good few years. She'll need proper training first and foremost, and then she'll need a lot more experience.
They might throw her in to something fairly low key, but I think her immediate future lies with recorded music with a tour in a year or two, depending on how it sells.
Susan Boyle had the OMG unbelievable factor Lucy has an okay voice but would not pass muster in the Opera world if she were lucky she just might make the ensemble.
Bad song choice is what people were saying about Calibro, but you're saying it for Lucy? No, sadly it is what I said before. Females have the power on a show like this as they vote in massive numbers. They are hardly going to vote for a beautiful woman to win the show now, are they? The result was very predictable.
Subo does not attempt opera. She sings the stuff that Joe Public want to hear.
I totally agree Opera includes acting out the part in a really heart wrenching way and she just stands and sings. Would be better doing crossover songs and she wold be fabulous doing that!
They have the looks, girls vote, and they were a sure thing. Lucy will do well, if anything her finishing as the runner up will propel her to future success.
Did the posters who said Lucy should have won vote for her?
You can bet your boots she wont be doing opera at all. She is a very poor-man's Katherine Jenkins only her voice has none of the warmth or tone of Jenkins. Nessun Dorma is not intended for the female voice, it just sounds thin and reedy sung by a woman. Her vibrato was too broad. She was totally unremarkable in my opinion.