Options

Corrie - Who would you axe?

The_soapThe_soap Posts: 185
Forum Member
Who would you Axe from Corrie?

My axe list:
Sophie Webster
Dev Alahan
Maria Connor
Tony Stewart
Sean Tully
Lloyd Mullaney
Michelle Connor
Anna Windass
Gary Windass
Izzy Armstrong
Steph Britton
Kal Nazir
Andrea Beckett
Maddie Heath
Sharif Nazir
Luke Britton
Alya Nazir
Yasmeen Nazir
Zeedan Nazir
Callum Logan
«13

Comments

  • Options
    LakieLadyLakieLady Posts: 19,722
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    All of the above, plus Todd Grimshaw, Liz Macdonald and Tony, Curly Simon, Tyrone and Fizz and possibly Kevin and Baby Jack.

    ETA: Actually, I'd let Dev stay. He makes me laugh occasionally.
  • Options
    SuperSoaperSuperSoaper Posts: 5,724
    Forum Member
    That's the real problem with Corrie right now. They have so many characters who we want to get rid of. But Eastenders only has a handful.
  • Options
    Lucy LouLucy Lou Posts: 8,574
    Forum Member
    The_soap wrote: »
    Who would you Axe from Corrie?

    My axe list:
    Sophie Webster
    Dev Alahan
    Maria Connor
    Tony Stewart
    Sean Tully
    Lloyd Mullaney
    Michelle Connor
    Anna Windass
    Gary Windass
    Izzy Armstrong
    Steph Britton
    Kal Nazir
    Andrea Beckett
    Maddie Heath
    Sharif Nazir
    Luke Britton
    Alya Nazir
    Yasmeen Nazir
    Zeedan Nazir
    Callum Logan

    That's quite a list :o can I just rescue the following: :D

    Dev Alahan - I am one of the few (very few :p) who likes Dev
    Maria Connor - a dull character but I can cope with that
    Tony Stewart - brings something different to the show, not likable but intriguing.
    Sean Tully - I actually don't mind him :o:o
    Lloyd Mullaney - I like Lloyds scenes in the cab office with Steve
    Anna Windass - a good actress IMO and 'believablish' character

    ...the rest of your list I agree with and they can go :D


    Edit: Fiz!!! ... she so needs to be on the axe list, preferably near the top
  • Options
    Yoshi FanYoshi Fan Posts: 13,913
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Stuart Blackburn.:)
  • Options
    Lucy LouLucy Lou Posts: 8,574
    Forum Member
    Yoshi Fan wrote: »
    Stuart Blackburn.:)

    Of course!....you win Yoshi :D
  • Options
    rollockingbatrollockingbat Posts: 1,038
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    The producer and a majority of the storyliners and writers. If the only option is to axe cast members or dramatically change their personality then they're not worth being in the job in my opinion.
  • Options
    Old Man 43Old Man 43 Posts: 6,214
    Forum Member
    The_soap wrote: »
    Who would you Axe from Corrie?

    My axe list:
    Sophie Webster
    Dev Alahan
    Maria ConnorTony Stewart
    Sean Tully
    Lloyd Mullaney
    Michelle Connor
    Anna Windass
    Gary Windass
    Izzy Armstrong
    Steph Britton
    Kal Nazir
    Andrea Beckett
    Maddie Heath
    Sharif Nazir
    Luke Britton
    Alya Nazir
    Yasmeen Nazir
    Zeedan Nazir
    Callum Logan

    The problem is that if you did all that you would not have much of a program left. What they really need to do is write better stories for those characters.

    Personally I think that most of those characters do have potential given the right well written stories.

    Even actors like Christian Bale, Daniel Day Lewis & Jennifer Lawrence would struggle with some of the stories in all our soap opera's.
  • Options
    ChipDouglas82ChipDouglas82 Posts: 6,700
    Forum Member
    Old Man 43 wrote: »
    The problem is that if you did all that you would not have much of a program left. What they really need to do is write better stories for those characters.

    Personally I think that most of those characters do have potential given the right well written stories.

    Even actors like Christian Bale, Daniel Day Lewis & Jennifer Lawrence would struggle with some of the stories in all our soap opera's.

    Agreed, list's like this one are usually fueled by "I don't like this particular character, so I'll put him/her on the list. Not always the best for the show.. (thank god, those lists have no power)

    I disagree with most on the lists so far, apart from Sean Tully!! (who has outstayed his welcome IMO) and Stuart Blackburke needs to go.
  • Options
    notdebbiedinglenotdebbiedingle Posts: 45,817
    Forum Member
    Agreed, list's like this one are usually fueled by "I don't like this particular character, so I'll put him/her on the list. Not always the best for the show.. (thank god, those lists have no power)

    I disagree with most on the lists so far, apart from Sean Tully!! (who has outstayed his welcome IMO) and Stuart Blackburke needs to go.

    Agree with all the last three comments!! Too much is made of axing characters in my opinion!! If everyone axed the characters they didn't like the cast would disappear!! The problem with current Corrie for me is too many sub standard new characters cluttering the show & leaving many of the established characters without any decent material!! Without decent material even the best character becomes stale!!
  • Options
    HotgossipHotgossip Posts: 22,385
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    All of the Asian family except Alyah. She is the only one who can act .... A bit.

    That grandmother tonight was truly awful ..... I kept expecting her to say "goodness gracious me" and wobbling her head like a nodding dog.
  • Options
    notdebbiedinglenotdebbiedingle Posts: 45,817
    Forum Member
    For the record just to keep the OP happy I'll say Michelle, Liz, Sean & Julie do nothing for me personally, along with the whole Nazir family & worst of anybody the horrendous Andrea!! Those however are merely the characters I don't like & would happily see the back of!!
  • Options
    tripitakatripitaka Posts: 5,636
    Forum Member
    Hotgossip wrote: »
    All of the Asian family except Alyah. She is the only one who can act .... A bit.

    That grandmother tonight was truly awful ..... I kept expecting her to say "goodness gracious me" and wobbling her head like a nodding dog.

    She does act like she's a character from "goodness gracious me". I would ditch her and her ridiculous community centre, is she really meant to be funding that herself. Her husband should go too but I'd give the rest of the family another chance. Alya can act but she's prone to vacant stares.
  • Options
    soap-leasoap-lea Posts: 23,851
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    wouldnt it have been quicker to list your keepers 😄😄

    I wouldnt axe anyone but the writers.
  • Options
    Jean_DanielsJean_Daniels Posts: 5,031
    Forum Member
    sean/sean/sean
  • Options
    QueenAmyQueenAmy Posts: 3,094
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Characters which NEED to be axed
    Dev Alahan
    Kirk Sutherland
    Todd Grimshaw
    Fiz Brown
    Tony Stewart
    Simon Barlow - Should have left with Peter, really
    Sean Tully
    Chesney Brown
    Michelle Connor
    Maddie Heath

    Characters which COULD be improved, but are **** at the minute
    Sophie Webster - I don't actually mind her, but I can't think of one thing she's done since Sian left
    Leanne Battersby - I used to love her, but now I forget about her half of the time
    Tyrone Dobbs - Same situation as Sophie, what has he done since Kirsty? Oh yeah, been with Fiz
    Jason Grimshaw - I would have put him in the list above, but with Sarah returning he COULD improve
    Julie Carp - I find her so boring
    Anna Windass - Might aswell just get rid of the whole family/ families
    Gary Windass - " "
    Izzy Armstrong - " "
    Faye Palmer - " "
  • Options
    zendo59zendo59 Posts: 119
    Forum Member
    I think most are let down by the poor scripts the actors currently have to deliver.

    Having said that, I personally believe the following character is beyond help:

    Sean Tully
  • Options
    Redhead69Redhead69 Posts: 1,002
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I would like the axe to come down on : Maddie, Simon (agree he should have left with Peter), Michelle, Tony, All the Nazir family, Gary, Izzy, Dev, Julie, Callum and Maria. They need better storylines.
  • Options
    vaslav37vaslav37 Posts: 69,565
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    The_soap wrote: »
    Who would you Axe from Corrie?

    My axe list:
    Sophie Webster
    Dev Alahan
    Maria Connor
    Tony Stewart
    Sean Tully
    Lloyd Mullaney
    Michelle Connor
    Anna Windass
    Gary Windass
    Izzy Armstrong
    Steph Britton
    Kal Nazir
    Andrea Beckett
    Maddie Heath
    Sharif Nazir
    Luke Britton
    Alya Nazir
    Yasmeen Nazir
    Zeedan Nazir
    Callum Logan

    Maddie
    Luke
    Steph
    Maria
    Izzy
    Dev
    Sean
    Michelle
    Gary
    Eileen
    Lloyd
    Andrea
    Kirk

    I am wiling to give the Nazirs a chance as I have not watched Corrie enough to say they should be axed.
  • Options
    Pink_SmurfPink_Smurf Posts: 6,883
    Forum Member
    Who I'd axe
    Zeedan Nazir
    Sean Tully
    Kal Nazir
    Dev Alahan
    Sophie Webster
    Anna Windass

    Zeedan Nazir is a dreadful character. His lines are so boring. I think any actor would struggle with being written so badly.

    EDIT I'd also get rid of Lloyd and Andrea. Terrible pair.
  • Options
    Cheekymonkey09Cheekymonkey09 Posts: 713
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Sean
    Michelle
    Jason
    Eileen
    Tony
    Maddie
    Sophie
    Kirk
    Nazir clan
    Anna
    Gary
    Izzy
    Owen
    Faye
    Beth
    Todd
    Kylie
    Max
  • Options
    SuperSoaperSuperSoaper Posts: 5,724
    Forum Member
    Andrea
    Lloyd
    Luke
    Maria
    Michelle
    Jason
    Todd
    Liz
    Kal
    Alya
    Khalid
    Sharif
    Yasmeen
    Zeedan
    Tony
    Gary
    Izzy
  • Options
    Ella NutElla Nut Posts: 9,031
    Forum Member
    I find Sean very entertaining so he's on my keep list. However I would happily see the back of :

    Izzy
    Todd
    Maddie
    Siobhan (zero chemistry with Ches - they're weird together)
    Kal (worse than his parents and he can take his son with him)
    Curly Simon
    Andrea
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 4,035
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Zeedan and Callum
  • Options
    cardiff boyocardiff boyo Posts: 3,065
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Lloyd, Sean, Michael, Nick, Ken, Kal,Dev.
    Andrea, Maddie, Michelle, Yasmeen
  • Options
    warleywitchwarleywitch Posts: 2,541
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    THE HAT..... the rest will disappear in time like raindrops off a window. But them that are at the top need to go ASAP
Sign In or Register to comment.