Originally Posted by floopy123:
“ Lee McQueen was quite good looking and he won so there you go - good looks and good business skills can work hand in hand but I doubt McQueen was picked based on his appearance.”
The bolded bit is exactly what I am saying! If you can have the best of both worlds, you should take it. And with all the applications this show gets, I am sure they can have that. They aren't seriously picking the 16 best candidates, they are picking the 16 best candidates who'll make good TV, and looks are part of that.
Also, I am pretty sure Lee's looks must have been taken into consideration. If nothing else it's been shown that we take this stuff into consideration at the unconscious level all the time. But if you're casting a reality TV show, you take it into consideration quite consciously too. I've even seen articles on how to get onto The Apprentice that had "be good looking" as a key piece of advice.
They may have made a conscious decision not to take looks into account this year for whatever reason. Presumably to make the show more credible? I think it was a mistake.
Also, Ruth was kind of hot in a Supernanny way. And there is no denying she made great TV.