Originally Posted by sk2007:
“Adored Virtue and Moir. I'd have them win too.
Robin Cousins' commentary annoys me though - he gives his opinion on who he likes, but doesn't back it up with any insight into anything other than "flow" and "great lifts" and "music". He doesn't specifically why Virtue and Moir are better, or why possibly the Russians could have won. I don't come away having learnt anything about figure skating after watching the BBC. Did Chris and Simon on Eurosport say anything more enlightening?
Kim Yu Na was just brilliant - am a big, big fan. I can't think of an Olympics as exciting Vancouver is going to be, with so many world champions entering; Kim Yu Na, Mao Asada, Miki Ando and presumably and Kimmie Meissner as well. Hopefully Sasha Cohen too, (as if things aren't interesting enough!) As much as I enjoy the big Kwan-Sluskaya, Yagudin-Plushenko type rivalries, it's as much fun to have such a diverse field where anyone in the top group could win it.
Can't say I feel the same about the men's comp sadly.”
“Adored Virtue and Moir. I'd have them win too.
Robin Cousins' commentary annoys me though - he gives his opinion on who he likes, but doesn't back it up with any insight into anything other than "flow" and "great lifts" and "music". He doesn't specifically why Virtue and Moir are better, or why possibly the Russians could have won. I don't come away having learnt anything about figure skating after watching the BBC. Did Chris and Simon on Eurosport say anything more enlightening?
Kim Yu Na was just brilliant - am a big, big fan. I can't think of an Olympics as exciting Vancouver is going to be, with so many world champions entering; Kim Yu Na, Mao Asada, Miki Ando and presumably and Kimmie Meissner as well. Hopefully Sasha Cohen too, (as if things aren't interesting enough!) As much as I enjoy the big Kwan-Sluskaya, Yagudin-Plushenko type rivalries, it's as much fun to have such a diverse field where anyone in the top group could win it.
Can't say I feel the same about the men's comp sadly.”
The women were in a league of their own really, Kim Yu Na was exceptional.
To respond to your question about Chris and Simon on Eurosport over Robin Cousins' commentry.
I find them a bit more interesting to listen to; they do the same thing as Robin at times but overall they are a bit more indepth; they disect the routine as its happening more and pick up on the technicalities more.
But I would suspect; and I may be making a sweeping generalisation here; that those who are really interested in the sport are probably watching on Eurosport rather than BBC highlights; and likewise the majority watching BBC highlights are probably those who are curious or have a mild interest; hence a dumbed down commentary.
I could of course be totally wrong and Robin might not be as good a commentator as Chris and Simon.




Even a dumbed down commentary needs more than just calling out the jumps - it just isn't interesting!