• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Doctor Who
Planet of the dead a pitch black rip off?
<<
<
2 of 2
>>
>
crazzyaz7
11-04-2009
Originally Posted by floopy123:
“Well it's possible the dune sharks were invented prior to Dredd, I don't know. But the dune sharks in Dredd's world can fly, have razor teeth. The similarity is almost identical. Taking a guess, I reckon someone on the Doctor Who production team - writer, creature designer etc, is a fan of 2000AD and Judge Dredd and was inspired by the dune sharks. They do say "imitation is the sincerest form of flattery."”

I would agree with that....but for many its still a plain and simple ripp-off
floopy123
11-04-2009
Judge Dredd vs the dune sharks - from Judge Dredd Megazine, dated Sept 16, 1994. The date is in the bottom left corner.

http://www.2000ad.org/functions/cove...ne&choice=2.62
Orangemaid
11-04-2009
Michelle Ryan (from Eastenders ) in tonights one,,Hope she's good.!! and is it a one off for Easter..
Corwin
11-04-2009
Originally Posted by floopy123:
“Well it's possible the dune sharks were invented prior to Dredd, I don't know. But the dune sharks in Dredd's world can fly, have razor teeth. The similarity is almost identical. Taking a guess, I reckon someone on the Doctor Who production team - writer, creature designer etc, is a fan of 2000AD and Judge Dredd and was inspired by the dune sharks. They do say "imitation is the sincerest form of flattery."”

RTD himself has said he was/is a fan of 2000AD, he put Max Normal in Gridlock (it's continous motorway inspired no doubt by the roads of Mega City One) for example

Also I believe the female newscaster in Gridlock was based on one from "The Ballard of Halo Jones".
renno69
11-04-2009
I Remember dredd also had ripperjacks, think it was in one of the annuals, which were like flying piranahs
Stephen WBottom
11-04-2009
I immediately thought of Pitch Black, when i saw the trailer.

Mind you, David looks like a choir boy compared with Van Diesel

Doesn't the ex-eastender lass enjoy big muscles
Muttley76
11-04-2009
Originally Posted by crazzyaz7:
“Oh I love this bit......





LOL.....”

well i love RTD's reply, but it makes me quite sad that his other half is clearly upset by some of the stuff that has been said about him. This is the downside to forums, people in the public eye become dehumanised on sites like this and people sometimes say things about someone here that they would never dream of saying to them in person.

In a way the internet is the last refuse of the coward.
renno69
11-04-2009
Originally Posted by renno69:
“I hope its not true but it looks like it going by the trailers (minus the black lol) anyone else notice the simalarities?”

And it Wasn't glad my fears wearn't realised lol
SHAFT
12-04-2009
The OP was wrong - Planet of the Dead was actually a rip off of 'The Langoliers'!
StarryNight
12-04-2009
Thank god you wrote this because it's been bugging the hell out of me since yesterday what that film was called! It was simillar I agree but nothings that original anymore.
loracan
13-04-2009
If we take it back far enough - isn't every story ever written a variation of one of the classic Greek Myths or a combination thereof?
Supratad
13-04-2009
Originally Posted by SHAFT:
“The OP was wrong - Planet of the Dead was actually a rip off of 'The Langoliers'! ”

Indeed, and just like the TV movie of The Langoliers, the ending was ruined by poor CGI.
mrellis33
13-04-2009
it was basically pitch black meets flight of the phoeix for kids. It wasn't that great, felt like an average episode, just getting ready for the next 3. Plus points Tennant as great as ever and Michelle Ryan was very good as an assistant, liked her alot.
Uncle Dave
13-04-2009
Originally Posted by SHAFT:
“The OP was wrong - Planet of the Dead was actually a rip off of 'The Langoliers'! ”

That was what I was thinking too
renno69
13-04-2009
Originally Posted by SHAFT:
“The OP was wrong - Planet of the Dead was actually a rip off of 'The Langoliers'! ”

How could i be wrong, can you read minds? lol
I said what I THOUGHT it looked like PB based on the trailer i'd seen and i HOPED this was not the case, it wasn't.
i've never seen or read langoliers I dont read King he uses a 1000 pages where 100 will do.
WelshNige
13-04-2009
Originally Posted by renno69:
“How could i be wrong, can you read minds? lol
I said what I THOUGHT it looked like PB based on the trailer i'd seen and i HOPED this was not the case, it wasn't.
i've never seen or read langoliers I dont read King he uses a 1000 pages where 100 will do.”

How do you know that if you've never read his books?
renno69
13-04-2009
because i have read some, how else would i know you think id go to the book shop and say, 'wow there's a lot of pages in that book im not going to read it' ???? numbnuts!
WelshNige
13-04-2009
Originally Posted by renno69:
“because i have read some, how else would i know you think id go to the book shop and say, 'wow there's a lot of pages in that book im not going to read it' ???? numbnuts!”

Thanks for that, was just asking as you said you don't read King, don't see the need for the insult but if that's your style thats fine.
renno69
14-04-2009
i was outta line just dont like people suggesting that i just make up stuff without any idea what i was talkin about, if you weren't then im sorry
stvn758
14-04-2009
It was such a lazy episode to call it a rip-off would be too kind.
WelshNige
14-04-2009
Originally Posted by renno69:
“i was outta line just dont like people suggesting that i just make up stuff without any idea what i was talkin about, if you weren't then im sorry”

No worries and thanks for the apology, much appreciated.
<<
<
2 of 2
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map