Originally Posted by soundwave:
“Well we all know that Simon is a bully, but it seems most people on here think he's some kind of god who invented music! He should be a father figure for his acts not thorwing them on the scarp heap when he's finished with them!”
No, you & others who think like you might think he's a bully, but that doesn't make him one.
There are a lot of talented people who'd never usually get the chance to go in front of industry moguls like Simon. You can see from shows like this that some people have been doing jobs that pay the bills but don't include what they enjoying doing most (e.g. singing, playing a musical instrument, comedy). Then along comes such a show - they audition &, if they're good enough, they get someone like him to give his honest opinion on their ability.
There are also some people who are good enough to entertain their relatives, maybe the local pub, but who'll never be good enough for the national stage never mind the world stage, who'll never be good enough to make money for the people they want to invest time & money in them. Their family & friends praise them, they start to believe what they say, & they think they're much better than they are or ever will be. Paul Evans was right when he said a long time ago that there comes a point when it's no longer about their voices, it's about their ears. The same principle can be applied to comics who think they're funnier than they are, the baton-twirlers who can't go 20 seconds without dropping them, the dancers who forget their steps, are out of sync with each other or have a poor routine. Their family & friends, in trying to encourage them (which is a good thing) have unwittingly crossed the line into deluding them & each other (which is a bad thing), opening them up to the hurt that an eventually honest review by someone who actually knows what they're talking about is likely to bring with it.
Simon is telling them what they should have been told well before they entered the competition. They aren't good enough for what they want to do, which is go through to the next stage, maybe even win. He's looking for an act to entertain the Queen & other dignitaries or celebs, not their friends at school, the man who runs the corner shop or the two 5-year olds next door. If other people had been more honest with them before they entered the competition, they'd have either put more work into their act, seen it as nothing more than a bit of fun or not continued with it. Nothing that Simon says stops them deciding to do the same thing now - the only thing that will stop them is them.