Originally Posted by
bel110:
“I don't mind Howard and have nothing against him, I think his performance has been okay, consistant and he's a nice enough person to work with, although I think his stint at PM was weak ... but I think it would be a shame if he won as I don't think he's been as interesting, dynamic or had as many good ideas as either Kate or Yasmina...
Also we've had two years of the winners being young, respectable, run of the mill males ( SA seems to favour this type of winner ) and as Howard fits perfectly in this mould I hope we don't see a repeat of this pattern, it would just be really nice to see a sparky young female win instead .... and I'm not just saying that cos I'm a female
I think the girls do have more to offer this series ...”
That's how I feel. I don't think he has done anything that has made me sit and take notice once, isn't better at one thing than someone else etc... It's just pretty average, but not bad, at most things. And someone like that and someone who has been in the background so much imo, at this late stage in the show, hasn't done enough for me to see as a worthwhile winner. he isn't even going to get to PM again most likely so we probably won't even see that.
Kate - has consistently been one of the top pitchers overall and has shown good leadership skills and got involved heavily in tasks (except 1 mistake). She is also very astute. She makes lots of very valid points in the programmes and seems very perceptive when it comes to the other candidates and how things will come across, what went wrong, what someone did that will be acknowledged as great etc...
Yasmina had one of the best wins as PM for the show and has been shown to be one of the best PMs as well as being a good allrounder. A little autocratic in her leadership, but seems a nice woman.
Lorraine - Great instinct, but a lot of negatives about her. But she has shone in a few tasks. I just can't see SAS hiring someone so eccentric, alienates people, poor communication skills and someone who doesn't bring out the best in people.
James - love him personally, but as a candidate, he hasn't shone so much as just been a generally likeable guy who tries his best. But he does have the creative flair SAS is looking for. But he one of the best tellywise for his one-liners.
Howard - shows he has some good skills, but where has he excelled. I didn't even properly know who he was until last week he has been that much in the background. So unless he is the top telly salesperson next week then I don't know.
Debra - for all her faults, has balls, initiative and drive. She is a top salesperson and is a gogetter. My only real issue with Debra is her autocratic and pushy nature. If she calmed that down she would be great. But out of all of them, you probably know best how you stand with Debra.