Do you think BGT series 4 will see some changed to the judging panel or presenting.
It would be either Piers or Amanda going.
Simon wont go unless he quits. But he is irreplaceable.
Ant and Dec are safe.

X Factors series 4 saw some key changes. Or do you think BGT will be the show to try and keep the judging panel and presenters the same for as long as poss?

BGT doesn't need that. I hope everything remains as it is.

I loved Piers this series, especially on More Talent when he was being a 'rock star' after joining Air-o-smith!

i think the panel will remain the same, the judges performed well, no need to change imo

Personally I hope Simon would go - all the kerching element for him biases his views.

The X Factor made massive changes because they were desperately needed. Britain's Got Talent is fine how it is, so I doubt if anyone'll be sacked.

Yeah I agree with you'se, I dont think there is no need to change.

Why should any of them be sacked? We all might not necessarily like one (or maybe all) of them, but that isn't a reason to sack them.

The fact that the ratings are going up every year shows that they probably don't need much change to the panel. Adding Kelly Brook proved to be useless.

I doubt they'll change it until maybe Series 5, if Series 4 has significantly lower ratings than this series.

i hope amanda goes and they bring in sharon i love her on AGT

bringing a 4th judge in would be a mistake as they found out i like simon and piers

show woldn't be the same without ant and dec.
would'n mind fern britton being on itv2 bgmt i love her.

Yeah the only thing that could change is Stephen Mulhurn leaving BGMT and someone replacing him

The only reason for a judge to be sacked would to be to bring a fresh vibe to the show.

Sharon Osbourne and Fern Britton?

Sounds like my idea of TV hell.

The show doesn't need it - this has been the most popular series yet. I don't see why they should fix something that isn't broke.

I didnt say the show needed to be fixed. I just said reasons why they replace judges

If Amanda gets somewhere in this new job in the US then she might quit, I suppose. But I'd guess that has been exaggerated and she'll still be here.

Can't see him firing Piers, tbh. No chance whatsoever of Ant & Dec being booted. He was very flattering about Mulhern as well.

And Simon has said this is the one show he definitely won't be quitting. The 3 judges seem to really get on. When he was invited to dinner with Gordon Brown, he picked Piers and Amanda to go with him (those 2 have become particularly good friends as well).

It's gone a bit like American Idol in the sense that I can't imagine the show without them and the 4th judge hasn't worked. In one way it's a good thing because it means that the show is working as it is. In the long run, it might make it difficult to freshen up the format in future years if it does get stale (like AI).

If anyone goes, it should be Amanda, personally i find all the botox on her face very hard to look at, especially tonight.

I didn't mean to sound like I was disputing your post - I was agreeing with your point, and just adding to it.

Okk

Well if a judge does leave it would cause a bit of contoversy if it wasnt Kelly Brook who replaced them.
From the bit of BGT that I have seen, Simon is the one most likely to have a go at the contestants-Piers disagrees with Simon-and Amanda................well just looks endearingly at the contestants and cries at will.
Honestly, what more do you need?

What I would like to see them do is a sort of foreign exchange week in the auditions where the two judges who don't feature on BGT or AGT go over to their counterpart show on the other side of the pond. i.e. have all 5 judges on the panel (Sharon, David Hasselhoff, Simon, Amanda and Piers). I mean (for those of us who don't watch AGT) we all know what Sharon is like as a judge, so David would be the only new bit and the same would go for Amanda in America. I think it would be interesting to see how they would all interact and to have an American eye on our acts and a(nother) British eye on the American acts. Can you imagine 4 British judges judging AMERICA's Got Talent?!

I can't help but agree with you. If you watch America's got talent, you'll see a wider range of acts being picked.

Please God get rid of Amanda,she spoils it for me.

Shame things never worked out with Kelly,but must be hundreds who would be better than Amanda.

Mulhern should play a bigger role in the main programme imo. He is funny and the i think Ant, Dec and Stephen would be laugh!