Vocal Talent.
Looks.
Overall.

Vocal Talent

1) Nadine (very strong, never really off-key, most consistant)

2) Nicola (I prefer her voice to Nadine's, she sings like an angel imo.)

3) Sarah (don't like the sound of her voice much but it is powerful)

4) Kimberley (not very dynamic but a clear, pretty sound)

5) Cheryl (good recording voice but not the best live.)

Looks

1) Kimberley
2) Nicola
3) Cheryl
4) Nadine
5) Sarah

^ the middle 3 positions were very difficult to choose.

Overall

1) Kimberley
2) Nicola
3) Nadine
4) Cheryl
5) Sarah

This isn't a thread to bash Girls Aloud on, so please don't.

Vocal Talent

1) Sarah ~ Has the strongest voice imo

2) Nadine

3) Kimberley

4) Nicola

5) Cheryl


Looks

1) Cheryl

2) Kimberley

3) Nadine

4) Sarah

5) Nicola


Overall

1) Sarah

2) Nadine

3) Kimberley

4) Cheryl

5) Nicola

I'm only rating on the voice.

1-Nadine
2-Sarah
3-Nicola
4-Kimberley
5-Cheryl

Vocal Talent
1. Nicola
2. Nadine
3. Sarah
4. Kimberley
5. Cheryl
Looks
1. Kimberley
2. Nicola
3. Cheryl
4. Sarah
5. Nadine
Overall
1. Kimberley
2. Nicola
3. Sarah
4. Cheryl
5. Nadine

Voices.

1) Nicola - Great, underrated.
2) Nadine - Good, overrated.
3) Kimberley - Not the strongest but my favourite voice. She could do indie songs or jazz songs amazingly.
4) Sarah - Bad
5) Cheryl - LOL

Looks

1) Kimberley
2) Cheryl
3) Nicola
4) Nadine
5) Sarah

Overall

1)Kimberley
2)Cheryl
3)Nicola
4)Nadine
5)Sarah

Anyone who doesn't put Nadine and Cheryl as top in the looks department seriously needs their eyes testing! Also, Nadine and Nicola are the only ones whol can actually sing.

beauty is in the eyes of the beholder, and i personally think kimberley has the most natrually pretty face, and has a gorgeous figure. i also think she's the most stylish.

i agree nadine & nicola are the best singers but i think the others can sing too. i'm not keen on sarah's sound but her voice can be very strong and powerful, kimba has a great voice for musicals and cheryl has a sexy recording voice. they all bring something to the table.

It's called opinion.
I think Kimberley and Nicola are better looking cause they don't have to try too hard. Cheryl is good looking but she's looking like a lampost lately while Nadine is pretty til she speaks (I'm from Northern Ireland and we don't all sound like that)

Vocal Talent.
1. Nicola
2. Kimberley
3. Nadine
4. Cheryl
5. Sarah

Looks.
1. Kimberley
2. Cheryl
3. Nicola
4. Sarah
5. Nadine

Overall.
1. Kimberley
2. Nicola
3. Cheryl
4. Nadine
5. Sarah

You must remember that it's not how loud you can sing, it's how you sing it. Sarah often shouts which when live seems bad. However, hearing songs like The Promise, her performance there in my opinion is one of the greatest in 2000s pop music. Anyway, here are the results from the People's Republic of Peterborough:

Voices.

5 points - Sarah (see above)
4 points - Nadine (she can hit those notes, but Sarah has the attitude)
3 points - Cheryl (not a ballad singer, as a pop singer she has a great tone)
2 points - Nicola (if only she sang more. Her performance in The Loving Kind is amazing)
1 point - Kimberley (good musical singer, bad pop singer this is why she doesn't sing much. Hear : The Crazy Life, a b-side from a few years ago. It's AWFUL)

Looks

5 points - Cheryl (oh come on!)
4 points - Nadine (look at those legs!)
3 points - Sarah (great with short hair, not long)
2 points - Kimberley (perfect body)
1 point Nicola (not my type, pretty face though)

Overall colateral tally

1) Nadine and Cheryl (8 points)
3) Sarah (7 points)
4) Nicola (4 points)
5) Kimberley (3 points)


They are all good at the end of the day, that's why we chose them 7 years ago! We could have had had the Cheeky Girls

PS. And who is my favourite member? Kimberley! She's just awesome and seems like such a nice and funny person.

dear oh dear how we clash!

What about their ears? . It's all a matter of opinion.

VOCALS:

Nicola
Nadine
Kimberley
Sarah
Cheryl

LOOKS:

Kimberley
Nicola
Cheryl
Sarah
Nadine

OVERALL:

Kimberley
Nicola
Cheryl
Sarah
Nadine

Vocals

1. Nadine - Powerful, always in tune and has some amazing ad-libs
2. Nicola - Beautiful, sweet and lovely to listen to
3. Cheryl - Great emotion on record, crap on TV but INCREDIBLE on tour live, I swear to God.
4. Kimberley - Quite weak live but has some amazing bits on record
5. Sarah - Too shouty, has zero control and hits bum notes to make your ears bleed

Looks

1. Cheryl - Goddess
2. Nicola - Stunning
3. Nadine - She looked amazing on tour
4. Kimberley - Luscious lips and curvaceous hips
5. Sarah - very pretty but ordinary

Overall

1. Cheryl - actually an AMAZING popstar, in a pure pop definition
2. Nadine - incredible vocalist and performer and very very funny
3. Nicola - She should be made a Dame <3
4. Kimberely - Down to Earth and quite lovely
5. Sarah - Erm...

OK, so I don't like Sarah much. I can't help it.

Vocals:

1. Nadine - Duh, miles above the others!
2. Nicola - Quite a good strong voice.
3. Kimberley - Good but not as strong as Nadine and Nicola.
4. Sarah - Can sing well but has some REALLY bad vocals too because she tries too hard - like "that" note on GMTV singing The Loving Kind!
5. Cheryl - Her voice isn't anything special and she's weak live too.

Looks:

1. Cheryl
2. Nadine
3. Kimberley
4. Sarah
5. Nicola

Overall:

1. Nadine
2. Nicola
3. Cheryl
4. Sarah
5. Kimberley - not a bad singer and looks great, she just doesn't seem to stand out as much as the others who all have something to them.

That bum note was absolutely awful Only highlights that she has no control over her voice and tries to show off that she can hold a big note only to end up embarrassing herself and making our ears bleed in the process. How any one can say she is the best singer in the group is beyond me lol.

The best singers are;
1. Nadine (most consistent)
2. Nicola
3. Cheryl
4. Kimberley
(big gap)
5. Sarah

bump.

What definition?

Madonna, Lady GaGa, Britney, Kylie, Christina, hell even Geri Halliwell. All AMAZING pop stars in definition but what does Cheryl have to match them exactly?

Voice:
Top) Most of them
Bottom) The Ginger One

Looks:
Top) Most of them
Bottom) The Ginger One

Overall:
Top) Most of them
Bottom) The Ginger One

Vocal Talent

1) Nicola
2) Nadine
3) Sarah
4) Cheryl
5) Kimberley

Looks

1) Cheryl
2) Kimberley
3) Sarah
4) Nicola
5) Nadine

Overall

1) Kimberley
2) Nicola
3) Cheryl
4) Sarah
5) Nadine

Vocals
Nadine
Sarah
Nicola
Kimberly
Cheryl

Looks:
Sarah
Cheryl
Nadine
Kimberly
Nicola

Overall:
Nadine
Sarah
Cheryl
Kimberly
Nicola

Vocals:

Nadine
Sarah
Cheryl
Nicola
Kimberly

Looks:

Sarah
Cheryl
Kimberly
Nadine
Nicola

Overall:

Sarah
Cheryl
Kimberly
Nadine
Nicola

Vocal Talent

1) Nadine

2) Nicola

3) Cheryl

4) Sarah

5) Kimberly

couldn't decide 3 and 4th place!

Looks

1) Kimberly

2) Cheryl

3) Nicola

4) Sarah

5) Nadine


Overall

1) Nicola

2) Cheryl

3) Kimberley

4) Sarah

5) Nadine

Vocals:
1)Nadine
2)Nicola
3)Cheryl
4)Kimberley
5)Sarah

Looks:
1)Cheryl
2)Nadine
3)Kimberley
4)Nicola
5)Sarah

Overall:
1)Cheryl
2)Kimberley
3)Nicola
4)Nadine
5)Sarah

VOCAL
Nadine
Nicola
Sarah
Cheryl
Kimberley

LOOKS
Nadine
Cheryl
Kimberley
Sarah
Nicola

OVERALL
Cheryl
Nadine
Nicola
Sarah
Kimberley

Although I must say, just because I ranked them, I think they're all very good singers, all stunning, and all nice girls.

The looks, the sound, the talent, the likability factor, everything!