• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • Entertainment
  • Music
Great #2 songs that were beaten by poor #1 songs?
<<
<
3 of 4
>>
>
Deep Purple
02-08-2009
Originally Posted by Terrence Chant:
“Which begs the question: how did it happen? As you intimate DP, this was hardly the days like Westlife only having to announce a new single and it go staright to number one on pre-sales......

The song must have been popular and well-known before it was released presumably? Was it featued on a tv show or something? Throws a mean dart does old Engle, incidentally.......”

The Beatles were in a league of their own in terms of popularity, and the quality just kept on improving, therefore people would rush out on the day of release to get the latest record, knowing it would be a winner.

I cant recall whether the songs were played on the radio before release, but they probably were a week in advance or similar.

Most singles did climb the charts for a few weeks before peaking though, and then gradually slid away. The Beatles were a real exception to the rule.
Stube
02-08-2009
Originally Posted by Terrence Chant:
“Boyzone's 'A Different Beat' (no, I can't remember that one either) kept TB off the top initially, then the two songs you mention

Just looking at the charts from that time, I note that Tori Amos then knocked the Spice Girls off with 'Professional Widow'. I didn't know TA had a number one hit to her name.....”

Alright, that makes UMH now eligible. Kept off by a ghastly forgettable piece of Louis Walsh cheese.
QwertyGirl1771
02-08-2009
A-Ha's Take On Me beaten to number one by that friggin Jennifer Rush and her friggin Power Of Bloody Love!
jackol
02-08-2009
Originally Posted by 9ct mould:
“The Pogues and Kirsty MacColl - Fairytale Of New York

Probably the best Christmas song ever, and always beaten to to the top spot on three occasions I think. The first one being the Pet Shop Boys *cringe*”

It only made Number 2 once, it also made Number 3 in 2005
RussellIan
02-08-2009
I know I'll be derided for this but in 1986, for a period of four weeks Sinitta's So Macho was kept off the top first by Chris De Burgh's Lady In Red and then Boris Gardner's I Wanna Wake Up With You, which in my opinion were a much bigger pair of 'number twos'.
Capablanca
02-08-2009
Originally Posted by Terrence Chant:
“Which begs the question: how did it happen? As you intimate DP, this was hardly the days like Westlife only having to announce a new single and it go staright to number one on pre-sales......

The song must have been popular and well-known before it was released presumably? Was it featued on a tv show or something? Throws a mean dart does old Engle, incidentally.......”

I'm pretty sure the Hump had made quite an impression on the Great British housewives when he appeared on Sunday Night At The Palladium singing 'Release Me'. He was a handsome chap with a strong voice singing the type of country tinged ballad that was popular back then (Green, Green Grass Of Home, Distant Drums etc).

I think by '67 the Monkees had stolen the teenybopper's hearts and Beatles' 45s weren't selling in quite the humungous quantities that they had in their 'Fab Four' 63-65 heyday.
gareth_williams
04-08-2009
The Saturdays - Just Can't Get Enough. Although not a great song but it would have been much better than Flo Rida's Right Round and it would have given The Saturdays their first number 1.
Nicola37
04-08-2009
The ones that stick are Ultravox , Coldplay etc but here's some other occasions where the better song has been kept off IMO.

Gorillaz - Feel Good Inc kept off Number 1 by Akon - Lonely

Libertines - Can't Stand Me Now kept off Number 1 by 3 of a Kind - Babycakes

Kelis - Milkshake kept off Number 1 by Michelle McManus - All This Time.

Britney/Madonna - Me Against The Music kept off Number 1 by Busted - Crashed The Wedding.

Justin Timberlake - Cry Me a River kept off Number 1 by TATU - All The Things She Said.

Kelly Rowland - Stole kept off Number 1 by TATU - All The Things She Said.

Oasis - Little By Little kept off Number 1 by Will/Gareth - Long and Winding Road (and I say this as a Will fan!)

Destiny's Child - Bootylicious kept off Number 1 by Atomic Kitten - Eternal Flame.

Blink 182 - All The Small Things kept off Number 1 by Geri Halliwell - Bag It Up

Eminem - My Name is kept off Number 1 by Mr Oizo - Flatbeat

Natalie Imbruglia - Torn kept off by Aqua- Barbie Girl

Oasis - Wonderwall kept off by Robson and Jerome - I Believe

Bon Jovi - Always kept off by Whigfield - Saturday Night
tiggerkev
05-08-2009
Kylie's - I Believe in you kept off by Band Aid 20 (yes it was great Band Aid 20 got number 1 for the charity reasons, but it was still a god awful remake/cover).....
smartie3
05-08-2009
Originally Posted by gareth_williams:
“The Saturdays - Just Can't Get Enough. Although not a great song but it would have been much better than Flo Rida's Right Round and it would have given The Saturdays their first number 1.”

This I like the Saturdays

also Stole by Kelly Rowland and Torn by Natalie Imbruglia
x+y
05-08-2009
Supermen Lovers' Starlight kept off number 1 by Bob The Builder's Mambo No 5
Terrence Chant
05-08-2009
Originally Posted by gareth_williams:
“The Saturdays - Just Can't Get Enough. Although not a great song but it would have been much better than Flo Rida's Right Round and it would have given The Saturdays their first number 1.”

One cover version keeping another cover version off the top doesn't seem much of a travesty really though
Subrosa
05-08-2009
Originally Posted by Stube:
“Alright, that makes UMH now eligible. Kept off by a ghastly forgettable piece of Louis Walsh cheese. ”

Oh come on, someone must remember the great 'eee-yeah-o, eee-yeah-o, eee-yeah-o byaaaaah' chorus?

I'm gonna have A Different Beat in my head all evening now!
Taz93
05-08-2009
Originally Posted by gareth_williams:
“The Saturdays - Just Can't Get Enough. Although not a great song but it would have been much better than Flo Rida's Right Round and it would have given The Saturdays their first number 1.”

I agree.
Lightning T5
05-08-2009
Pet Shop Boys~Go West (7th September 1993) charted at #2, when the #1 was Mr.Vain by Culture Beat, not a very good song in my opinion
Brummy Girl
06-08-2009
In 1998, George Michael's Outside, with its tongue in cheek video following on the back of 'that' incident in a LA toilet, spent 2 weeks at No2. What was at No1? Only mutton dressed as lamb Cher with her vocoder assisted single Believe which ended up being the biggest selling single of that year as well as of her career
mooneus
06-08-2009
R Kelly's Ignition kept Girls Aloud - No Good Advice of the top

Westlife - Mandy kept Girls Aloud - Jump from No.1

Eric Prydz - Call on Me stopped Love Machine by Girls Aloud reaching number 1

On a separate note, Fedde Le Grand and McFly left Girls Aloud - Something Kinda Oooh to settle for no. 3
ClareB
06-08-2009
Originally Posted by RussellIan:
“Aha's Take On Me - I can't remember what was number one at the time but then, isn't that the point? Look how iconic and, at the risk of sounding fulsome, immortalised the song has now become (eclipsing their actual number 1 that followed it).”

Maybe this should be another thread entirely, but this got me thinking about groups/singers whose no.1 songs aren't really their most well known. If you mention A-ha, most people would know them for Take On Me than The Sun Always Shines On TV, which was No.1. The same goes for Right Said Fred - I'm Too Sexy is more well known that their No.1 Deeply Dippy. Bros's When Will I Be Famous didn't get to No.1, but I Owe You Nothing did. I'm sure there are loads of other examples.

While I don't think many people would say that You're The One That I Want is poorer than The Smurf Song, it must have been frustating for kids who loved the song and saw it kept in the no.2 spot for 6 weeks in 1978.
Capablanca
06-08-2009
Originally Posted by ClareB:
“
While I don't think many people would say that You're The One That I Want is poorer than The Smurf Song, it must have been frustating for kids who loved the song and saw it kept in the no.2 spot for 6 weeks in 1978.”

Well said...we were big Smurf fans in our house
Stube
06-08-2009
Originally Posted by mooneus:
“R Kelly's Ignition kept Girls Aloud - No Good Advice of the top

Westlife - Mandy kept Girls Aloud - Jump from No.1

Eric Prydz - Call on Me stopped Love Machine by Girls Aloud reaching number 1

On a separate note, Fedde Le Grand and McFly left Girls Aloud - Something Kinda Oooh to settle for no. 3”

It might seem like a random question but; Do you love Girls Aloud by any chance?

Oh, and you forgot The Show, that went to #2 Held of by Usher's Burn
mooneus
06-08-2009
Ye but you must admit, Love Machine, Jump & Something Kinda Oooh deserved number 1.
Not to mention Biology and Call The Shots.
Stube
06-08-2009
Originally Posted by mooneus:
“Ye but you must admit, Love Machine, Jump & Something Kinda Oooh deserved number 1.
Not to mention Biology and Call The Shots.”

Yeah, they have had lots of potential number one singles but there's always a song that beats them to it. I think Wake Me Up was also underrated, not to mention Untouchable earlier this year (#11 was a travesty)
cody jarrett
06-08-2009
Tears For Fears - Everybody Wants To Rule The World

No1 all over the planet apart from the UK. Kept from the top by USA For Africa's We Are The World.
smartie3
06-08-2009
Originally Posted by Stube:
“Yeah, they have had lots of potential number one singles but there's always a song that beats them to it. I think Wake Me Up was also underrated, not to mention Untouchable earlier this year (#11 was a travesty)”

I liked Wake Me Up. Should have done better than 4 though. Untouchable is good too, that should have gone top 10 really
Multimedia81
27-01-2010
Originally Posted by shackfan:
“As soon as I saw the thread title I thought of this. I was GUTTED at the time as i was a massive new romantic fan and particularly a fan of Ultravox. Saw them 3 times live in 81/82/83 ish. Have NEVER forgiven Dolce

Mind you I suppose that Vienna is talked about MORE because of it, so it had its up side.”

Not only that but Vienna was no 5 in the chart of the year compared to no 8 for Shuddup Your Face. So in terms of sales Ultravox had the last laugh!

I agree with you Nicola37 that it was outrageous that Torn was kept off the no 1 slot by Barbie Girl. Torn sold 982000 copies and is one of the biggest-selling no 2s of all-time!
<<
<
3 of 4
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map