Originally Posted by Caytom:
“Another 2 very good reviews.
http://www.gaydarnation.co.uk/UserPo...D=25468&sid=53
Excerpt:
http://www.thelancasterandmorecambec...ville__London/
Excerpt:

The one thing I have found interesting, and at times, humourous, about all these different reviewers and critics, is that they seem to have contradictory opinions on Diana's Impersonations, as to which ones are spot on, and which ones are not quite right.
Does this then suggest that ALL of Diana's Impersonations are 'Spot On'.
The other 'bone of contention' seems to be with the finale song. I think that it's only 2 reviews that I've read, thus far, that didn't like the fact that the Finale Song was changed from the original play and movie (a Judy Garland song was sung), and that it is sung in Diana's own voice. Obviously, these 2 critics/reviewers had seen the original play etc..
However, isn't one of the points of the story, that LV finds her own voice? So, having found her own voice, why would she sing a Judy Garland song, in Judy Garland's voice??
(The first review I've posted doesn't like the 'change' of song and ending, whereas the 2nd Review suggests that it's LV/DV's 'Finest Moment')
I've just recently seen the Little Voice movie, and the new ending to the Play/Story, i.e. new song (unheard song) in LV's own voice, makes much more sense to me.
”
“Another 2 very good reviews.

http://www.gaydarnation.co.uk/UserPo...D=25468&sid=53
Excerpt:
http://www.thelancasterandmorecambec...ville__London/
Excerpt:

The one thing I have found interesting, and at times, humourous, about all these different reviewers and critics, is that they seem to have contradictory opinions on Diana's Impersonations, as to which ones are spot on, and which ones are not quite right.

Does this then suggest that ALL of Diana's Impersonations are 'Spot On'.

The other 'bone of contention' seems to be with the finale song. I think that it's only 2 reviews that I've read, thus far, that didn't like the fact that the Finale Song was changed from the original play and movie (a Judy Garland song was sung), and that it is sung in Diana's own voice. Obviously, these 2 critics/reviewers had seen the original play etc..
However, isn't one of the points of the story, that LV finds her own voice? So, having found her own voice, why would she sing a Judy Garland song, in Judy Garland's voice??

(The first review I've posted doesn't like the 'change' of song and ending, whereas the 2nd Review suggests that it's LV/DV's 'Finest Moment')
I've just recently seen the Little Voice movie, and the new ending to the Play/Story, i.e. new song (unheard song) in LV's own voice, makes much more sense to me.

”
The only negative reviews (the one over the page and another in the Independant) rest on the strange logic that nothing comes as a surprise as it did when Jane did the role originally. That argument would have killed off every work ever written after its first night. It seems a very minority reaction. Agree finding your own voice seems a rather important theme to end on.......
Off to see the show today.........




