Originally Posted by Gill_Brett:
“I've been watching Matt and Harry's dances on you tube and I can honestly say there isn't a dance I haven't enjoyed. I think Aliona's choreography is brilliant it's never boring she must work so hard with them to get it to that standard.”
Aliona's work stands up to inspection.
It can be a matter of taste or if people actually 'get' or understand what Aliona intended with the dance. Len is an example of someone who doesn't 'get' it.
All of Aliona's dances with Matt were full of content with the exception maybe of the Jive, where they were short of time that week through having to struggle through blizzards and flight delays while visiting the Outer Hebridies.
Len complained about a spin at the start of the Quickstep as 'time wasting'. I'd like him to go looking for another quickstep on strictly that contained more steps in the 90 seconds than that one. Len complained that it was too manic.
With Matt, the problem was shortage of training time and travelling all over the country. They had to work very fast and very intensely when they did get a chance to train and its remarkable how much they achieved. Matt's gymnastic background and a bit of previous dance experience helped.
With Harry it was all about teaching a novice, and while he didn't learn as fast as Matt, Aliona adapted the training pace to develop him through the series. Harry's ballroom was as good as anyone's had been by the end of the series and his latin was good but still improving.
Harry's first ballroom dance (the Foxtrot) didn't get delivered the way it should, so Aliona reduced the quantity but not the quality for a few dances to give Harry a chance to learn how his body learns to dance. Then the last 8 dances were all full content from start to finish.
An impression seems to exist that Aliona's dances lack content, have a lot of props and go outside the rules.
From my studying of her dances, she did use props as requested by the producers but in ways that didn't spoil the dancing and has been probably below the average in use of them.
Few of her dances lacked content and when they did it was for good reasons or because it was a themed week.
She also tries to stick to the producers rules, which are the rules that matter and which the judges should be taking into account.