Originally Posted by peugeot:
“I don't think most people do criticise everything on the show but from about the second series it was obvious that Brucie wasn't up to it. The show moves too quickly for him and being oldschool he doesn't do the technology and never seems to be on his cue and you can see Tess yanking him about and trying to stop him rambling because they have to hit the timing and he won't wear an earpiece. It was particularly irritating tonight that he seemed to repeat the first sentence that everyone said during the judging.
I can think of several people who could do the job better and I do happen to thing Anton could do the job because he is just a younger Brucie (I can remember him when he was younger and much more on the ball and quicker witted). Most people I know, asked for one single thing they dont' like about the show say Brucie.
I think the Alesha thing is a totally different subject and unproven after two nights, I don't think it is working at the moment but she is still 'bedding in'. Shame the Beeb couldn't just add one onto the panel instead of replacing.”
I think we're going to have to agree to disagree on the amount people who seem to come on just to criticise the show and it's format. I am not Brucie's biggest fan but, I really think he is a big part of the show. You say that Alesha is a totally different subject but, I'm afraid that it isn't. We viewers take for granted a lot of what makes SCD work and Arlene was one of the many parts that made a winning formula. Therefore I think to lose Bruce would change the show dramatically and I'm not as confident as most that it would be for the better.
I also believe that they're more likely to bring in Tess's other half as a replacement than Anton! Remember they both co-hosted Just the Two of Us for the Beeb. I for one don't really rate Anton or Veron over Brucie and his awful jokes.