• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • Entertainment
  • Music
How many bands are still going without any original members?
<<
<
2 of 4
>>
>
I love Ellie
23-09-2009
Originally Posted by Cinderelly:
“There are plenty of bands Evanescence, They only have one original member, Status Quo for a time I think.

Napalm Death, Juda Priest only have one member left from the original line up. The Pipettes, I think The Temptations, Thin Lizzy.

There's probably more.

Lynard Skynryd's only constant is Johnny I think.”

Surely there's 3 original members of Priest, KK, Ian and Glenn. Rob's back too, although not being the original vocalist, he's probably considered to be.
Cinderelly
23-09-2009
Haha too be honest I can't remember anymore. Though they're still going after all these years amazes me.
shoulderduff
23-09-2009
I`m sure that a few years ago `Frankie Goes To Hollywood` were touring America with not one single member from the originals.

I believe the New Seekers have no original members from their starting line up.
CLL Dodge
23-09-2009
Originally Posted by shoulderduff:
“
I believe the New Seekers have no original members from their starting line up.”

That's true. Seems to be another band where the management own the band name and hire and fire people at will.
gomezz
23-09-2009
I think the London Sympony Orchestra has no original members left in its current line up.
Deep Purple
23-09-2009
Originally Posted by TVGirl319:
“The Moody Blues still comprise of Justin Hayward, John Lodge and Graeme Edge!! They have just complete a USA tour and are still kicking ass some 40 years later!!!”

I saw them on their last UK tour, and I agree with you. Still superb. I was in New York last month, when they were playing there, but it was sold out, so couldn't see them again.
Urban Bassman
23-09-2009
Doctor Feelgood are still going without any original members.
I love Ellie
23-09-2009
Originally Posted by Cinderelly:
“Haha too be honest I can't remember anymore. Though they're still going after all these years amazes me.”

They are still going and are still shit hot!
stupid_cube
23-09-2009
cant believe no 1 mention
this top scottish rock group

Runrig
CLL Dodge
23-09-2009
Renaissance, formed by Keith Relf and Jim McCarty (ex-Yardbirds) in 1969. The original lineup had completey changed by autumn 1971.

Their 40th anniversary tour includes Michael Dunford (who joined in 1970) and Annie Haslam (who joined in 1971) plus various guest musicians.
Smiley433
25-09-2009
How much of Cher is still original?
chemical2009b
25-09-2009
Originally Posted by Smiley433:
“How much of Cher is still original?”

and Madonna?
misslibertine
25-09-2009
guns n roses only have axl left.. but that is one original member, so it doesn't count.

although he looks like a different person these days.
afcbfan
26-09-2009
So in summation then, the only band going without any original members, and who are in any way relevant, are the Sugababes?
Davey T
26-09-2009
And the Drifters as well. Still going, and relevant to the thread title.
Pink Wafer
26-09-2009
A bit embarrassing that I know about these but....

Menudo

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Menudo_(band)
afcbfan
26-09-2009
Originally Posted by Davey T:
“And the Drifters as well. Still going, and relevant to the thread title.”

When I say relevant, I should say that I mean to the music scene in 2009 which, with the greatest respect to them, kinda rules them out
Ezenden
26-09-2009
Originally Posted by afcbfan:
“When I say relevant, I should say that I mean to the music scene in 2009 which, with the greatest respect to them, kinda rules them out ”

Napalm Death.

Very relevant, even if you haven't heard of them.
Dizagaox
13-01-2012
Just came across this thread!

No Doubt are probably the most high-profile band with no original members. Gwen and Tony joined in 1987 (Gwen was a background singer for the band in 1986, but only part-time and occasionally - she wasn't a band member), Tom in 1988 and Adrian in 1989.
elnombre
13-01-2012
Originally Posted by TVGirl319:
“The Moody Blues still comprise of Justin Hayward, John Lodge and Graeme Edge!! They have just complete a USA tour and are still kicking ass some 40 years later!!!”

Not as much ass as they'd kick if their last 20 years output wasn't one decent regular album, a tepid christmas album and 3 or 4 hits/live compilations.
elnombre
13-01-2012
Originally Posted by misslibertine:
“guns n roses only have axl left.. but that is one original member, so it doesn't count.

although he looks like a different person these days.”

Bullshit, it's called getting older. He looks exactly like you'd expect a 50 year old Axl Rose to look.

Also Dizzy Reed has been in the band since about 1988 to present.
KingJJScott
13-01-2012
Originally Posted by bryemycaz:
“In view of the Sugababes still going without any original members are there any other bands who are doing the same.

Brotherhood of man started with a different line up but only had one Hit before the new one took over and had many more hits.

are there any more and were they sucsessful?”

Originally Posted by chemical2009b:
“I'm sure The Pussycat Dolls started with members that are not in the current line up.”

BIB - That scenario sounds pretty reminiscent of the Sugababes.. One hit, new line-up and huge success!!

The Pussycat Dolls formed the burlesque troupe in 1995 but the recording line-up not until 2003.. If Robin Antin gets her way, the group will return in 2012 with non of the TEN original members will be in the line-up.. They wiped an entire group out in one sweep and replaced them!!

At least the Sugababes had 8 years to get used to Heidi and 4 years with Amelle before Keisha went!!
edison
13-01-2012
Originally Posted by Pitman:
“tbh, it's utterly pointless to keep a band going if every member has left, this sugababes seems more like a brandname than a band ”

the sugababes has never been a band!

It is a marketing brand that's all
gpk
13-01-2012
Originally Posted by Pink Wafer:
“A bit embarrassing that I know about these but....

Menudo

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Menudo_(band)”

lol, let me correct that link for you. everyone has to start somewhere.
Urban Bassman
13-01-2012
Originally Posted by elnombre:
“Not as much ass as they'd kick if their last 20 years output wasn't one decent regular album, a tepid christmas album and 3 or 4 hits/live compilations.”

And Justin Hayward and John Lodge are not original members. They replaced Denny Laine and Clint Warwick in 1967 - after they had a hit with Go Now. So Graeme Edge is the only original member.

Mind you they became a completely different band after they joined.
<<
<
2 of 4
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map