I thik X-Factor needs an injection of Dr Fox, Pete Waterman or someone else, rather than Cheryl Cole. The way she comments is rubbish, nearly always on the fence, and her singing or "talent" is nothing special at all. The show really needs some cutting judges, who judge on music ability not just the way the person looks.

Mark

Completely agree, the bar really has been raised. The Girls Aloud members would have been lucky to get through the second auditions if they walked into the 2009 X Factor auditions (bar Nadine beause she can sing quite well.)

I understand Cheryl Cole being a judge (admittedly she can't sing, however she was in these auditionees place once upon a time, so getting her in as a judge was a clever move on Simons part), Danni annoys me a bit but ok, she's been in the industry a while and had relative sucsess (even though in my eyes she rode off of her sisters success to get there), and Simon is of course the brains behind the whole operation.

But Louis?? He had hits ten years ago with Boyzone, then with the carbon-copy of Boyzone (aka Westlife). The guy has no idea what he's talking about most of the time (and this is evident in all the other artists he's attempted to manage), it's laughable!

The whole show is a bit of a gimmick and a joke anyway so I suppose it shouldn't be taken seriously anyway!

Cheryl, Kimberley and Sarah would have been laughed out of the first round of auditions. Nicola and Nadine may have made it to boot camp but probably not the live shows.

I like her. I dont think the single is smashingly brilliant but its OK... and people do make mistakes you know!
- has she repeated the incident? NO

so just move on!!

she has, what's stopping you? (considering it doesn't even CONCERN you people) :yawn: :sleep:

Because people rarely change deep down.

But how can you prove Cheryl hasnt changed? :yawn::sleep:

Fair enough, she's a weak singer but... the incident occured yearrsss ago, jeez!

No one can prove it, but from experience most violent people don't change. Im just saying that this act of violence she showed has stayed with me, and thats why I don't like her.

Total BS.

Chas and Dave are legends and have more talent in their little fingers than both Minogue sisters and Girls Aloud put together.

You've obviously never seen Chas and Dave live.
One of the best nights out you can have.

One conviction for assault doesn't make someone 'a nasty piece of work' does it really?

To me, yes it does.

Well I hope you are never unfortunate enough to have a love one who makes one mistake. Has she been in trouble before or since?

Double post/

I don't know what your problem is really, Im hardly making some huge statement that no one knew about. Its common knowledge she assaulted someone, and for that, I don't like her. If you chose to like her, thats fine. You know, everyone sees the world in a different way.

Im not saying some people don't change, but its the fact that she is supposedly a role model, and is showered with praise, as being the 'nations sweetheart'. I don't think she deserves all the adoration.

this!!

I have always liked them.
Never seen them live not likely to now as Dave has quit.
But I would put money on it being a great night out and they have been about 40 years as well and the 2 Ronnies seem to love them.

Fight fight fight fight fight for this Love is a good pop song

If sang by a decent singer it could have been potentially awesome

Who cares ... she is drop dead BEAUTIFUL !!!

Can't stand the bint. Shes a good looking girl but she has a grating voice and doesn't exactly come out with constructive comments oh and her attitude reeks, don't know if people notice she gives cold hard looks and is quite snappy on the X/Xtra factor

I dig Cheryl's single . . . . . . .

Personally, I think it's a good record. . . . .

I love it . . . . .

More power to Chezza. .. . .

She's a sexy motha, & so's the single . . .

Go Chezza .. ..

I dig Cheryl's single . . . . . . .

Personally, I think it's a good record. . . . .

I love it . . . . .

More power to Chezza. .. . .

She's a sexy motha, & so's the single . . .

Go Chezza .. ..

Dani was famous before Kylie made it, Kylie just is more well known

Though I see your point, most of them probably sing better than Louis and Simon too- you don't really need to be a great singer to be able to judge a talent show- just good at spotting 'talent', whatever that seems to be these days.

Dannii is older so attempted to get famous before Kylie (obviously, being older.) She did some random TV work from a young age, (as did Kylie) however she actually signed with Kylies record company a few years after Kylie had signed with them, and by this time Kylie already had a huge hit single under her belt.

Regardless, I personally find Dannii quite irritating, but not as much as Mr Walsh

Dannii is younger.
She was a huge star on YTT got a record deal being on the show. She invited Kylie a couple of times, and that gave Kylie the chance. She invited Dannii once in the U.K but Dannii never got the chance to make it but was always dragged down.

Still Dannii doens't care about that but keeps on inviting her sister. She's incredible like that.

Yes true, i just had a look. However i still believe she's only stuck around in the industry and not disappeared into oblivion because of her sister; Kylie has broken records with her music and will always be known as the 'bigger' star. I'm actually not a fan of either of them really, haha!!