• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Strictly Come Dancing
Anton Du Beke in alleged Racist Slur (merged)
<<
<
83 of 93
>>
>
Dr. Jan Itor
19-10-2009
Originally Posted by poppyr:
“Dr. Jan Itor you are spot on and I admire you for continuing to shoot Trunkster down in flames with your intelligent points.

I work in a Doctors surgery where we have had many Asian Doctors over the years from India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka etc. If any member of staff referred to them as P*** then they would definitely be disciplined whether it be a verbal or written warning. Just as if a patient referred to a Doctor with an abusive term then they would probably be struck off. There has to be zero tolerance of this type of language and it should be nipped in the bud.

That is what annoys me about the BBC they have not disciplined Anton Du Beke. If he had been given a warning of some sort then maybe this situation wouldn't have gone on for so long. It is immaterial that he has apologised he should still have been disciplined he used an offensive term at his place of work, not in private.”

I would say thank you for your compliment, but since we've been accused of mutual back slapping just because of your comment, I shudder to think what we'd be accused of if I did say thank you.
lori
19-10-2009
so is white trailer trash racist.

because I'm sure as hell that Jermaine Jackson used it in that way.
trunkster
19-10-2009
Originally Posted by lori:
“so is white trailer trash racist.

because I'm sure as hell that Jermaine Jackson used it in that way.”

Did he? when? If so I feel outraged and insulted on behalf of the person/persons it was aimed at.
nanscombe
19-10-2009
Originally Posted by poppyr:
“... That is what annoys me about the BBC they have not disciplined Anton Du Beke...”

And you know this for certain because ...

Just because he wasn't fined 10s of thousands of pounds, suspended from work for a month or, (as some would like) summarily dismissed doesn't necessarily mean that he wasn't disciplined only that we weren't informed of it.
gorlagon
19-10-2009
Good lord. I can't believe there are people on this thread who don't think P*** is an offensive term! Scary stuff!

My personal view is that it's unlikely Anton used it with racist intent. It comes across as rather embarrassing ignorance to me. Many of us have ingrained and subconscious prejudicial attitudes - I'm sure I've got some, but I don't think racism is one of them - and it often takes something like this to make us take them out and see them for what they are. The reflection of someone else's reaction to something we say or do should tell us a great deal and I'm sure Anton is a wiser man for this event.

There was a Channel 4 series a while back called "I'm Not Racist, But..." and it brought up a lot of the same issues that are being discussed here. People were frightened and shocked by their own attitudes when they were brought into the open and analysed and many of them gained a greater understanding of the world when it was seen from someone else's perspective.

I know many of you think this thread should be closed and I know it's fairly combative - but it's better argued out than left to fester.
lori
19-10-2009
i have heard some fms say piky,now i didn't know what until an other fm told me.

is this not as racist as **** as it is a derogatory meaning for an ethnic minority.
lori
19-10-2009
i would just like to point out,that at no time did i say anton wasn't wrong in what he said.

my point was and is that he did not mean it in a malicious way.
Half a Bee
19-10-2009
Originally Posted by lori:
“so is white trailer trash racist.

because I'm sure as hell that Jermaine Jackson used it in that way.”

Sorry but your memory is slightly out as what Jackson said was quoting another and in reality said that another housemate had called them white trash and that he didn't agree with that description, So yes while he did use the words "white trash" it can only be twisted without the full line he spoke and was only used by people that cared nothing for Jade and her cabal at the time but their own continued pathetic use of racist insults.
What name??
19-10-2009
Originally Posted by mickmars:
“So if a respected long serving member of staff referred to a pakistani colleague as a p"k" (as a descriptive term) thats not part of a heated argument/or personal verbal attack they'd be subject to a disicplinary action would they.

On what legal grounds exactly?”

On the grounds that an employer has an obligation to create and inclusive working environment under, I think, equal ops laws initially but there are other later laws extending this to other groups. Also for common sense to avoid being sued for constructive dismissal etc.

In compliance with this employers including the BBC are supposed to put policies in place so that staff have a clear idea of how to deal with a situation where for example a colleague is rude or insulting and the working relationship is strained. They also put an obligation on employees to be professional and polite at work and not insult their colleagues. The remedies if they aren’t include talking to them on a first incidence, sending them for respect in the workplace training, separating staff where there is awkwardness, a warning, or if the incident is serious enough or repeated sacking them. In this case obviously the BBC have torn that up all this in favour of ignoring the first incident and then having a Anton issue a half hearted apology for the second one and announcing that he has their full support.
trunkster
19-10-2009
Originally Posted by lori:
“i have heard some fms say piky,now i didn't know what until an other fm told me.

is this not as racist as **** as it is a derogatory meaning for an ethnic minority.”

I think you mean Pikey?

Pretty soon we won't be able to call anyone a name
lori
19-10-2009
Originally Posted by Half a Bee:
“Sorry but your memory is slightly out as what Jackson said was quoting another and in reality said that another housemate had called them white trash and that he didn't agree with that description, So yes while he did use the words "white trash" it can only be twisted without the full line he spoke and was only used by people that cared nothing for Jade and her cabal at the time but their own continued pathetic use of racist insults.”

nope shilpa was up set and he said,they are only white trailer trash.

he was being racist .
lori
19-10-2009
Originally Posted by trunkster:
“I think you mean Pikey?

Pretty soon we won't be able to call anyone a name”

well there you go thats my point.

a word can be used in a racist manner,but also the very same word does not mean the person using it is a racist.

i mean use the word to insult or cause offence to anyone.

now I'm

but at the end of the day anton didn't mean to offend anyone.
Dr. Jan Itor
19-10-2009
Originally Posted by trunkster:
“I think you mean Pikey?

Pretty soon we won't be able to call anyone a name”

It's troubling that you find the thought of not being allowed to call people names reason for a sad face.
trunkster
19-10-2009
Originally Posted by Dr. Jan Itor:
“It's troubling that you find the thought of not being allowed to call people names reason for a sad face.”

Is calling someone a racist name calling then?
Dr. Jan Itor
19-10-2009
Originally Posted by trunkster:
“Is calling someone a racist name calling then?”

Generally I prefer to call what someone says or does racist rather than the individual, as I think it is unfair to label someone based on their worst moment. However, in extreme examples such as members of racist organisations who are actively devoted their lives to racism then I don't think it is name calling to call someone a racist.
Rum​Baa​Baa
19-10-2009
Originally Posted by CoolTango:
“Oh dear! This thread is well and truly passed its sell by date yet it's still going strong.

For those who have posted here who truly believe Anton has committed some dreadful and heinous crime (having read a lot of the thread, there are plenty of them) what do you make of this.

The Pakistan Embassy in London own the number plate - PAK1. Don't tell me the last letter is a number, for years people have been taking words and setting them to the rules of car registrations.

How come you don't believe this causes deep offence? Surely the car should be impounded! In fact it should probably be sent immediately to some racism correction centre.


Well, it's just four characters on a number plate. Anton was an idiot using a word which isn't in most people's vocabularly these days. But can someone really be typecast, pigeon-holed and vilified from the utterance of a single word?

Time to get a grip.

Today Britain has two new world champions - Jenson Button and Beth Tweddle - now there's something to get excited about !!”

The High Commission for Pakistan in United Kingdom haven't used those number plates for a couple of years now.

Here is list of some other UK diplomatic number plates:

AUS 1 Austrailia
BAH 1 Bahrain
BOL 1 Bolivia
BOT 1 Botswana
CAN 1 Canada
CHI 1 Chile
COL 1 Columbia
ELS 1 El Salvador
FIJ 1 Fiji
FRA 1 France
HAI 1 Haiti
ISR 1 Israel
ITA 1 Italy
MAU 1 Maurittius
MEX 1 Mexico
NEP 1 Nepal
NIC 1 Nicaragua
PHI 1 Philippines
SEN 1 Senegal
SEY 1 Seychelles
SUD 1 Sudan
TUN 1 Tunisia
UKR 1 Ukraine
ZAI 1 Zaire
ZAM 1 Zambia

I hope the meaning they spell out is easy for you to understand.
Rum​Baa​Baa
19-10-2009
Originally Posted by lori:
“nope shilpa was up set and he said,they are only white trailer trash.

he was being racist .”

You've added the word trailer...so your recollection of the events is questionable.
lori
19-10-2009
Originally Posted by Rum​Baa​Baa:
“You've added the word trailer...so your recollection of the events is questionable. ”

no it is not.

he clearly said white trailer trash.

i fed up of some fms thinking that to call a white person a name can not ever be racist .

ah must be because white people NEVER get called names. by any ethnic minority's.
Rum​Baa​Baa
19-10-2009
Originally Posted by lori:
“no it is not.

he clearly said white trailer trash.

i fed up of some fms thinking that to call a white person a name can not ever be racist .

ah must be because white people NEVER get called names. by any ethnic minority's.”

No he didn't...go ask in the BB forum, if you dare!
What name??
19-10-2009
Originally Posted by lori:
“i would just like to point out,that at no time did i say anton wasn't wrong in what he said.

my point was and is that he did not mean it in a malicious way.”

You can't know any more than those who insist he definately meant it in an offensive way can since none of us are mindreaders. We can only realistically state whether we think it was meant malicously or not and why.

The point is that it was reasonable for a person to take it as malicous especially as it was not an isolated incident. The second point is that it did offend her and he knew it but when questioned by the press about it originally he denied it had happened, thus making the situation even more awkward for her. He then issued a non-apology apology when the matter was taken up by the tabloids which indicates to me that he was sorry his actions were highligted rather than because he was sorry that he had made his partners SCD experience so difficult.

I think even if he didn't mean it malicously, which I doubt as it wasn't a one off, that his actions afterwards indicate that he was selfish and not really sorry.
Monkseal
19-10-2009
He said "white trash" and he was reporting that Leo Sayer had said it.

That Jermaine Jackson, who did more than anybody else to try smooth over the uneasy relations in that house, has apparently come out of it as some sort of standard bearer for "reverse racism" is frankly appalling.
Half a Bee
19-10-2009
Originally Posted by lori:
“nope shilpa was up set and he said,they are only white trailer trash.

he was being racist .”

Sorry he was quoting H ( Ian ) And why would anyone say "white trailer trash" ? White trash ( agreed racist ) or trailer trash yes but to put the two together ? Perhaps the answer lies in the fact that there was no action taken against Jackson apart from the rumblings of a few forum members trying to justify their own racism.
Half a Bee
19-10-2009
I suggest that anyone still wanting to defend Du Beke would probably be best advised to avoid watching Panorama tonight.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/panorama/hi/fr...00/8303229.stm

I'm also wondering if BBC bosses have brought forward this episode to try and defuse the row as they probably didn't expect Jan Moir to have taken over all the flak so suddenly.
Annsyre
19-10-2009
Originally Posted by Rum​Baa​Baa:
“No he didn't...go ask in the BB forum, if you dare! ”

You are correct.

He did indeed say "white trash" - I remember it well. I even joined in the debate.
Annsyre
19-10-2009
Originally Posted by lori:
“no it is not.

he clearly said white trailer trash.

i fed up of some fms thinking that to call a white person a name can not ever be racist .

ah must be because white people NEVER get called names. by any ethnic minority's.”

He said "white trash" I heard him say it and joined in the lengthy BB debate on the subject.
<<
<
83 of 93
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map