Dont like Alesha as a judge - doesn't know what she's talking about and she has no credibility - 3 months training - so what!

The perfect 4th judge would be Karen wassaname - as an ex strictly professional dancer she has interesting and pertinent comments to say and as a trainer herself, her critisism would be constructive/encouraging for celebs

in fact i thought Arlene was 'starting to lose touch'

in sports world, recent ex professionals (Boris Becker, etc)are always my favourite commentators
.

Yes Karen would be an excellent judge. In fact almost any pro dancer could replace Alesha and improve the show.

Nope replace Len or Bruno with Karen for me.

I think that Karen would make a superb judge, she'd balance out Craig and Bruno very nicely with reasoned analysis and less claptrap.

I've left Len out, I realise. I'd like to hear from him more often something that reflects his status.

parthena

How about replacing Len AND Bruno with Karen? 3 judges gets rid of Len having the deciding vote!

Karen was great on choreography corner on ITT during the week. She'd make a terrific judge.

Yawn!!!! ~Repeat thread warning.....zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

Karen or Camilla would have been great, and neither would have generated anywhere near the negative reaction Alesha did.

Karen would make a brilliant judge and yes, I think she should replace Alesha. The problem is that the BBC doesn't want to admit it was wrong to appoint Alesha and lose face by climbing down. But unless it has the courage to do so, the show can only continue to slide down the pan.

I'm one of those who continues to "boycott" the show because of the BBC's general disrespect towards viewers, typified by last year's farcical final and by the added insult of putting any amateur on the judges' panel.