No deciding vote for Len.
Craig, Camilla and Len as judges. Bruno is just a comic caricature of a judge nowadays.
Craig, Camilla and Len as judges. Bruno is just a comic caricature of a judge nowadays.
3 judges better than 4
Agreed 3 judges would take less time in between dances so make to show shorter(far too long at mo)
But Craig Len and Karen Hardy for me, less show busy and more ballroom/latin biase please
But Craig Len and Karen Hardy for me, less show busy and more ballroom/latin biase please
Three judges would be a good idea - it works on DWTS. Just get rid of Bruno - used to love him when he started, but now he is just so OTT he is a total embarrassment.
I think that would increase the chances of ties....assuming each mark was out of 10 still....and that's not a good thing with the silly new scoring system.
Len, Craig and Carrie Ann Inaba.
I really like Carrie Ann on DWTS and if Len can do both then why not her?
If it's four judges - Camilla.
I really like Carrie Ann on DWTS and if Len can do both then why not her?
If it's four judges - Camilla.
Len for Ballroom Karen for Latin and Craig for "artistic interpretation" - for heavens sake Bin the Bruno - how irritating has he become this year
Originally Posted by petertard:
“No deciding vote for Len.
Craig, Camilla and Len as judges. Bruno is just a comic caricature of a judge nowadays.”
“No deciding vote for Len.
Craig, Camilla and Len as judges. Bruno is just a comic caricature of a judge nowadays.”
I think that there is something to be said for having a Len type judge, an ex-pro from the show and more of a choreographer type like Craig and that would be the right balance and keep the show tighter. I just feel that four is a better number to help spread the scoring. I'd look for a fourth judge who is also of Len's type, though probably a woman.
Originally Posted by riff:
“Len, Craig and Carrie Ann Inaba.
I really like Carrie Ann on DWTS and if Len can do both then why not her?
If it's four judges - Camilla.”
“Len, Craig and Carrie Ann Inaba.
I really like Carrie Ann on DWTS and if Len can do both then why not her?
If it's four judges - Camilla.”
Oh pleeeease noooooooooo
Originally Posted by ilovesooty:
“I seem to remember reading somewhere that Brendan would love to be a judge...
”
“I seem to remember reading somewhere that Brendan would love to be a judge...
”
Brendan is a judge. On Dancing with the Stars in New Zealand. With Craig.
Originally Posted by Quizmike:
“Brendan is a judge. On Dancing with the Stars in New Zealand. With Craig.”
“Brendan is a judge. On Dancing with the Stars in New Zealand. With Craig.”
During which - allegedly - they had their main falling out.
If Alesha left then three would be better than four. If another respected judge came arrived in place of Alesha then four would be better than three.
Take pity on the poor cameraman who has to keep the bouncing Bruno in shot. Bring back Arlene, keep Craig and bring in Karen Hardy for a panel of three with Arlene as "Head Judge" if one is needed.
Originally Posted by bobferret:
“Take pity on the poor cameraman who has to keep the bouncing Bruno in shot. Bring back Arlene, keep Craig and bring in Karen Hardy for a panel of three with Arlene as "Head Judge" if one is needed.”
“Take pity on the poor cameraman who has to keep the bouncing Bruno in shot. Bring back Arlene, keep Craig and bring in Karen Hardy for a panel of three with Arlene as "Head Judge" if one is needed.”
Not against the idea of Arlene returning, but surely the'head judge' needs to be someone from the world of ballroom and Latin?
Originally Posted by kaycee:
“Not against the idea of Arlene returning, but surely the'head judge' needs to be someone from the world of ballroom and Latin?”
“Not against the idea of Arlene returning, but surely the'head judge' needs to be someone from the world of ballroom and Latin?”
And someone who can bring a coherent sentence in at under three minutes.
Three judges is a really good idea. I would like to see someone well-known and respected:
My ideal panel would be:
Len
Karen Hardy
Una Stubbs or Lionel Blair
Before Strictly I had never heard of Bruno or Craig and after last Saturday's performance I would be quite happy never to see them again. It would be nice to see a panel who don't undermine the celebrities, give constructive criticism and judge contestants kindly without resorting to catty "animal imagery".
My ideal panel would be:
Len
Karen Hardy
Una Stubbs or Lionel Blair
Before Strictly I had never heard of Bruno or Craig and after last Saturday's performance I would be quite happy never to see them again. It would be nice to see a panel who don't undermine the celebrities, give constructive criticism and judge contestants kindly without resorting to catty "animal imagery".
