Would you all prefer it if Craig quit just like John Sergeant?

2 of 2

Jan2555*GG*

27-10-2009

Good Morning Bhoy

I can live with another thread on a slightly different slant if you resist posting your 'going to blackpool chant' is that a deal

No I dont think he should quit because the absolute LAST thing I want is the spectre of a 2 couple final AGAIN.

musicangel

27-10-2009

Yes craig should quit...

Bhoy1888

27-10-2009

Originally Posted by Jan2555*GG*:
“Good Morning Bhoy

I can live with another thread on a slightly different slant if you resist posting your 'going to blackpool chant' is that a deal

No I don't think he should quit because the absolute LAST thing I want is the spectre of a 2 couple final AGAIN.”

Yes I will try.I may if he actually gets there get the chant back out mind.

Look all I am doing is freshening up the discussion on Craig and asking another question.

I'm sure now this thread will became the main thread about Craig and the other one will die a natural cause

Hope thats OK with everyone

Yes an now to your point I agree the last thing anyone wants again is a 2 person final.They are really not as good as 3

lach doch mal

27-10-2009

Originally Posted by Bhoy1888:
“Yes I will try.I may if he actually gets there get the chant back out mind.

Look all I am doing is freshening up the discussion on Craig and asking another question.

I'm sure now this thread will became the main thread about Craig and the other one will die a natural cause

Hope thats OK with everyone

Yes an now to your point I agree the last thing anyone wants again is a 2 person final.They are really not as good as 3”

I must admit I have problems getting you, might be my fault though.

Why do we have to have a thread about whether Craig should quit or not? Surely, no-one has asked for it (you seem to be the only person coming up with improbable scenarios in relationship to Craig - no offence intended here). There isn't that much nastiness directed against Craig (IMO people quite reasonably state that he is one of the weaker dancers) and so far we had no repetition of last year's JS fiasco. Quite the contrary, this year celebreties seem to be leaving based on their weak dancing ability. If Craig by some miracle improves rapidly by next Saturday, and someone else is worse than him, then surely no-one would expect him to go or quit. However, if he is the weakest dancer next week, then he should be in the dance off and go home (however, if he gets the public vote based on popularity then he should stay). What shouldn't happen is that he stays solely because of his birthday, Blackpool or an ill pet fish

mimi dlc

27-10-2009

Originally Posted by Bhoy1888:
“Yes as I too have said that I don't believe any better dancers (apart possibly Martina) have actually gone home before him

I just think every year on SCD we get the same old argument that good dancers are going home at the expense of bad dancers

Well when you have a scoring system as we do I'm afraid thats the nature of the show.If you don't like that fact then I guess you should watch anothr show that awards points purely on dancing ability

I just feel that there seems to be an anti Craig feeling (actually it is probably not anti Craig ,more hes not worthy to still be here) developing on here and that reminds so much of JS from last year”

I don't think there is that much of an anti-Craig feeling on the thread, just a lack of pro-Craig feeling, which is not the same thing.
There is a distinct Anti-banging-on-about-Craig feeling.

cassieconvinced

27-10-2009

Originally Posted by mimi dlc:
“I don't think there is that much of an anti-Craig feeling on the thread, just a lack of pro-Craig feeling, which is not the same thing.
There is a distinct Anti-banging-on-about-Craig feeling.”

Yes!

I think, considering some previous years, that this year hasn't seen the plethora of "bashing" threads there usually are. Very sedate as a matter of fact.

mashedpotatoes

27-10-2009

Originally Posted by Deerd:
“Same ole, same ole... this FM, under another username, did the same persistently on DS:BB this summer past. All in the name of attention-seeking.”

Blimey Deerd, now you've got me racking my brains- give us a clue - were they a pro-Sophie person?

Bhoy1888

27-10-2009

Originally Posted by lach doch mal:
“I must admit I have problems getting you, might be my fault though.

Why do we have to have a thread about whether Craig should quit or not? Surely, no-one has asked for it (you seem to be the only person coming up with improbable scenarios in relationship to Craig - no offence intended here). There isn't that much nastiness directed against Craig (IMO people quite reasonably state that he is one of the weaker dancers) and so far we had no repetition of last year's JS fiasco. Quite the contrary, this year celebreties seem to be leaving based on their weak dancing ability. If Craig by some miracle improves rapidly by next Saturday, and someone else is worse than him, then surely no-one would expect him to go or quit. However, if he is the weakest dancer next week, then he should be in the dance off and go home (however, if he gets the public vote based on popularity then he should stay). What shouldn't happen is that he stays solely because of his birthday, Blackpool or an ill pet fish.”

I only asked the question as this Im sure is how the anti-JS stuff started with him.He seemingly outstayed his welcome cause better dancers than him were getting voted off

I appreciate at the moment its not as viscous as it was for JS last year but if Craig were to survive for say another 3 weeks watch this board go into meltdown

2 of 2