Did I imagine the 9 from Alesha?

-Sid-

31-10-2009

I must have.

There is no way she could have awarded Zoe's awkward and bounceless Samba one mark less than perfect......

I know I must sound like a broken record, but this over-marking of Zoe is just getting silly now.

Robert Romarin

31-10-2009

To be fair there's a lot of overmarking and generally irksome judging going on tonight.

-Sid-

31-10-2009

Originally Posted by Robert Romarin:
“To be fair there's a lot of overmarking and generally irksome judging going on tonight.”

Len went a bit mad dishing out a 9 for Ali's rather reserved Paso.

I just feel the judges have been consistently too generous with Zoe.

Vincy82

31-10-2009

To be honest, I felt that Laila deserved a 9 more than Zoe - this week anyway.

SideshowStu

31-10-2009

Tbh Sid, I've found that ignoring everything the judges say and whatever scores they give helps my enjoyment of the show enormously

It's just too frustrating otherwise

-Sid-

31-10-2009

Originally Posted by SideshowStu:
“Tbh Sid, I've found that ignoring everything the judges say and whatever scores they give helps my enjoyment of the show enormously It's just too frustrating otherwise ”

Good advice Stu

missfrankiecat

31-10-2009

And quite why disco samba is bad choreography last week but passes without comment when James and Zoe do it this week?

Jake2008

31-10-2009

Originally Posted by Vincy82:
“To be honest, I felt that Laila deserved a 9 more than Zoe - this week anyway.”

TOTALLY AGREE
That 9 could of made her, shes now tied with Ali which IMO is very very risky!

icequeen

31-10-2009

i thought Zoe and James were well overmarked.....

Forget-me-not

31-10-2009

Originally Posted by missfrankiecat:
“And quite why disco samba is bad choreography last week but passes without comment when James and Zoe do it this week?”

What is it with them all sticking disco moves into the dances this year. I presume as disco moves are generally easier they are good ways of filling out the dances for the weaker ones but it is becoming tiresome.

Alesha's 9 has just made absolutely certain her judging is a joke, just when I was beginning to warm to her a bit. I don't think it will have done Zoe any favours either.

Ten_Rose

31-10-2009

I'm particularly annoyed at the gross undermarking that seems to be occurring on the opposite end of the scale.

Ricky and Erin did not deserve a 24. They were so much better than Craig and Flavia - who also weren't that awful this week - though the only good news is that people will probably vote to save them.

If they had given Laila a 9, she would have been straight third, which has been the most dangerous position 3 weeks running...

Muggsy

31-10-2009

Those b****** judges had better save Ali and Brian.

Paperbag_Writer

31-10-2009

I totally agree Zoe and James were overmarked tonight, as they were last week. But they shouldn't have been within a country mile of the dance off. The way the public seems to be voting, we are headed for something like a Ricky Whittle vs Ali Bastian dance-off in the next couple of weeks. Ridiculous!

boddism

31-10-2009

Originally Posted by -Sid-:
“I must have.

There is no way she could have awarded Zoe's awkward and bounceless Samba one mark less than perfect......

I know I must sound like a broken record, but this over-marking of Zoe is just getting silly now.”

It wasnt an appauling dance, but Alesha'a mark was SERIOUSLY over-rated! That was a 7-8 at best...

... btw- poor Zoe! she was quite good but didnt engage with the public...