I wouldn't be too bothered about which of the solo singers won as they're all much of a muchness.The only one I wouldn't want to see is Lloyd.
Who do you NOT want to win?
3 of 4
Originally Posted by fairycakes:
“Thats the way that I see him so thats the way that I will judge him. That seems very logical to me as how else am I going to judge his personality unless I meet him in person which is not very likely.”
“Thats the way that I see him so thats the way that I will judge him. That seems very logical to me as how else am I going to judge his personality unless I meet him in person which is not very likely.”
Indeed so if you have only unreliable material to go on, why form a judgement
?
Quote:
“I don`t see why people can express their dislike of Jedward but if I mention anything less than nice about Danyl I get taken up on it.
”
“I don`t see why people can express their dislike of Jedward but if I mention anything less than nice about Danyl I get taken up on it.
”
Must of the comments negative comments about Jedward are about their singing and performance which is there for us to see.
The only person I'd mind winning is Danyl. Because I think he's vastly over-rated and I don't appreciate either the 'broken man' act or Simon shoving him down my throat all the time.
Originally Posted by quinners17:
“The only person I'd mind winning is Danyl. Because I think he's vastly over-rated and I don't appreciate either the 'broken man' act or Simon shoving him down my throat all the time.”
“The only person I'd mind winning is Danyl. Because I think he's vastly over-rated and I don't appreciate either the 'broken man' act or Simon shoving him down my throat all the time.”
That conjures up a nasty image........
Danyl, Lloyd, Joe (he bores me) and Stacey (she's in rapid decline) are the only ones I wouldn't like to see win at present.
Winning the X-Factor title isn't just about singing. I certainly believe that the title X-Factor doesn't end on the fact that one act can actually sing but the overall appeal of that particular talent which means personality, versatility and at the same time the charism he/she/they have...
This year's batch of contenders showed us a very different bunch of characters... but who among them deserves the title at the end of the series....
I can see three acts that possess the character, the charisma, the personality and most of all the talent...
Joe, Stacey and Olly
very likeable characters... unique personalities.... each performance is a reflection of who they are and not of who they want to be.... always effortless.... competition for them isnt a big thing, the experience matters the most.....
Jamie, Lucie
they try very very very hard every week.... instead of giving out a brilliant performace, they prefer to impress rather than to entertain.... their voices arent versatile and at some point irritating as well.... very good performers though but their personalities usually clash with the way they sing on stage...
John & Edward
very entertaining.... either love them or hate them..... they are having fun... its good to see them every week but then at some point we have to consider the fact that this is a talent show and they are actually struggling on that part... if it was britain's got talent, they might have a shot in winning the title but x-factor, i do have some questions.....
Lloyd
clearly face value over talent.... very timid and reserved.... he knows he is good-looking and he relies on that so much.... he has reached his ceiling point but cheryl is pushing him so hard and it just wont work.... the next person to go...
Danyl
i was never impressed of danyl... yes he got one of the best voices in the competition but i can't imagine him representing uk in a global scale and at the same time following the likes of leona, shayne and alexandra.... he knows so so so so so much that he is good and even if he denies it, his facial expression, his constant murdering of songs, his mannerisms reflect this cockiness in him... if he happen to have either stacey's bubbly and humbling charcater or olly's likability, he could be swimming till the end...
This year's batch of contenders showed us a very different bunch of characters... but who among them deserves the title at the end of the series....
I can see three acts that possess the character, the charisma, the personality and most of all the talent...
Joe, Stacey and Olly
very likeable characters... unique personalities.... each performance is a reflection of who they are and not of who they want to be.... always effortless.... competition for them isnt a big thing, the experience matters the most.....
Jamie, Lucie
they try very very very hard every week.... instead of giving out a brilliant performace, they prefer to impress rather than to entertain.... their voices arent versatile and at some point irritating as well.... very good performers though but their personalities usually clash with the way they sing on stage...
John & Edward
very entertaining.... either love them or hate them..... they are having fun... its good to see them every week but then at some point we have to consider the fact that this is a talent show and they are actually struggling on that part... if it was britain's got talent, they might have a shot in winning the title but x-factor, i do have some questions.....
Lloyd
clearly face value over talent.... very timid and reserved.... he knows he is good-looking and he relies on that so much.... he has reached his ceiling point but cheryl is pushing him so hard and it just wont work.... the next person to go...
Danyl
i was never impressed of danyl... yes he got one of the best voices in the competition but i can't imagine him representing uk in a global scale and at the same time following the likes of leona, shayne and alexandra.... he knows so so so so so much that he is good and even if he denies it, his facial expression, his constant murdering of songs, his mannerisms reflect this cockiness in him... if he happen to have either stacey's bubbly and humbling charcater or olly's likability, he could be swimming till the end...
All of the voted off contestants.
I would be happy for any of the remaining contestants to win.
Would love a Danyl, Lucie and Olly final. Possibly Jamie if he gets back to his Hurt best or Stacey if she can find her groove.
Joe, John and Edward and Lloyd are all sweet, not my favourites, but wouldn't be upset if either of them win.
I would be happy for any of the remaining contestants to win.
Would love a Danyl, Lucie and Olly final. Possibly Jamie if he gets back to his Hurt best or Stacey if she can find her groove.
Joe, John and Edward and Lloyd are all sweet, not my favourites, but wouldn't be upset if either of them win.
Is it bad to say that I don't really want any of them to win? Actually that's incorrect, there are reasons why all of them shouldn't win.
Lucie - Not got a strong voice really and on a second listening her vocal performance on Sweet Child Of Mine (my favourite performance of hers) was just not that good.
Stacey - Only does one thing. Seriously. Although she does have a lovely singing voice.
Joe - Again good voice but too much vibrato and not all that interesting to be honest.
John and Edward - seem lovely. Seem really into it, seem like that would be good celebrities but really can't sing so there is just no way they should win.
Lloyd - Voice is not strong enough. LW was right when he said he would be great in a boyband though.
I'd rather one of the over 25s wins but really there are reasons why they shouldn't at the moment.
Jamie - Far too arrogant in my opinion. His voice isn't amazing but he gives a good performance and makes the crowd work. Plus Angel of Harmlem was one of the best performances of big band week.
Danyl - When he's good he's good when he's bad he is really bad. Gives a good performance when he's on a role though.
Olly - Probably my favourite to win at this point. But his voice isn't as strong as some of the others. The first performance of the Live shows was actually pretty bad but I like him nevertheless.
So I'm sitting on the fence in all respects because I want someone to really win me over.
Lucie - Not got a strong voice really and on a second listening her vocal performance on Sweet Child Of Mine (my favourite performance of hers) was just not that good.
Stacey - Only does one thing. Seriously. Although she does have a lovely singing voice.
Joe - Again good voice but too much vibrato and not all that interesting to be honest.
John and Edward - seem lovely. Seem really into it, seem like that would be good celebrities but really can't sing so there is just no way they should win.
Lloyd - Voice is not strong enough. LW was right when he said he would be great in a boyband though.
I'd rather one of the over 25s wins but really there are reasons why they shouldn't at the moment.
Jamie - Far too arrogant in my opinion. His voice isn't amazing but he gives a good performance and makes the crowd work. Plus Angel of Harmlem was one of the best performances of big band week.
Danyl - When he's good he's good when he's bad he is really bad. Gives a good performance when he's on a role though.
Olly - Probably my favourite to win at this point. But his voice isn't as strong as some of the others. The first performance of the Live shows was actually pretty bad but I like him nevertheless.
So I'm sitting on the fence in all respects because I want someone to really win me over.
Danyl - just think not a good singer or performer
Jamie - just sings his pub showbook each week (eg big band week)
J and E - no singing ability so would make mockery of whole prog
Stacy - not a great singer and poor performer
Jamie - just sings his pub showbook each week (eg big band week)
J and E - no singing ability so would make mockery of whole prog
Stacy - not a great singer and poor performer
"I can see three acts that possess the character, the charisma, the personality and most of all the talent...
Joe, Stacey and Olly"
They may possess some of the above qualities, but what the show really sets out to do is find a recording artist that is current and marketable: Leona, Alexandra, JLS.
I don't feel any of the above are marketable, maybe Olly at a push, even though he just reminds me of a Stars in Your Eyes version of Will Young.
Joe is by far the least marketable. Yes he has a very good voice and appears to be a genuine guy. However, how would they sell him as a recording artist? He's a young camp boy that's good at singing pop music. There's no demand for pop music, nor does he have the stunning looks that encourages people to often look beyond talent.
As for Stacey he poor vocals for 2 weeks in a row now, shows she is a bad one-trick pony. Why has no-one demanded she sings an uptempo number yet?
Lucie is my top choice for contestant with the X-Factor. She is current, likeable and has an amazing voice.
Joe, Stacey and Olly"
They may possess some of the above qualities, but what the show really sets out to do is find a recording artist that is current and marketable: Leona, Alexandra, JLS.
I don't feel any of the above are marketable, maybe Olly at a push, even though he just reminds me of a Stars in Your Eyes version of Will Young.
Joe is by far the least marketable. Yes he has a very good voice and appears to be a genuine guy. However, how would they sell him as a recording artist? He's a young camp boy that's good at singing pop music. There's no demand for pop music, nor does he have the stunning looks that encourages people to often look beyond talent.
As for Stacey he poor vocals for 2 weeks in a row now, shows she is a bad one-trick pony. Why has no-one demanded she sings an uptempo number yet?
Lucie is my top choice for contestant with the X-Factor. She is current, likeable and has an amazing voice.
Lucie - Sourpuss. Comes across as very false. Also the crying over an ounce of criticism. Get over it. She'll have to be stronger than that in the music business.
Jamie - He's just not good enough.
John & Edward - Don't get me wrong, they're my favourites by a mile but winning won't do them any good. They are much better off making the final and coming 2nd or 3rd.
Jamie - He's just not good enough.
John & Edward - Don't get me wrong, they're my favourites by a mile but winning won't do them any good. They are much better off making the final and coming 2nd or 3rd.
Screamy, shouty, stroppy, spoilt, self-centred DANYL!
Silly way to spell his name as well! How pretentious!
Silly way to spell his name as well! How pretentious!
3 of 4
