Has that ever occurred ever?

In the past? Several times....I remember it happened to Louis once and he had to choose one of his acts.

yep. girlband and badlashes last year

and ray and nikitta leona's year

give me a complete set list someone please

It's actually not that uncommon. :s

Alisha vs Kimberley

Nikkita vs Ray

Girlband vs Bad Lashes

Cassie vs Tabby

Futureproof vs Hope

Rachel vs Daniel

G4 vs Voices with Soul

Thanks to Wikipedia, here is the full list of two acts from the same catergory that have been in the bottom two together, and who their mentor chose to eliminate.

SERIES 1-
Week Three- Voices With Soul vs 2 To Go
LOUIS ELIMINATED- 2 To Go

Week Four- G4 vs Voices With Soul
LOUIS ELIMINATED- Voices With Soul

Week Five- Cassy Vs Tabby
SHARON ELIMINATED- Refused To Vote

SERIES 2-
Week Four- Chenai vs Nicolas
LOUIS ELIMINATED- Chenai

SERIES 3-
Week Five- Ray vs Nikitta
SIMON ELIMINATED- Nikitta

SERIES 4-
Week One- Kimberley vs Alisha
SHARON ELIMINATED- Refused To Vote

Week Three- Futureproof vs Hope
SIMON ELIMINATED- Futureproof

SERIES 5-
Week One- Girlband vs Bad Lashes
LOUIS ELIMINATED- Bad Lashes

Week Six- Daniel vs Rachel
DANNII ELIMINATED- DID NOT VOTE DUE TO MAJORITY BEING IN FAVOUR OF ELIMINATING DANIEL


[b]SERIES 6- [/B
]Yet To Occur
Last edited by 21stCenturyBoy : 05-11-2009 at 23:07

so hideous Mrs O refused to vote every time she was faced with a tough decision! What a cop out!

How would cassy/tabby, nicholas/chenai and ray/nikitta be in the same groups. They were all under 25 weren't they?

Yep, but this was before they seperated it into Boys & Girls Under 25's. So during those series, they were in the same groups.

How did they group it previously then??

BTW I have watched Pop Idol and subsequently X factor from the start. Why do I not remember this?

Ahh. it was under 25, over 25 and groups. *lightbulb going off in head*

When they had 3 groups it was just, under 25, over25 and groups

Thanks, got there eventually

lol, I wasn't even a big fan back then. I remember my first time was the results show in Season 3, when Nikitta and Ray were in the bottom 2!!! SO annoyed SImon chose Ray over Nikitta!!! I remember he 'changed' his mind just before he announced aswell!

I remember him changing his mind.
And I forgot Sharon chose not to vote both times her acts were in the Bottom Two.

OH! I missed one out, in Week Three of Series 3- the one and only week where we had a bottom three, both Kerry and Dionne (over 25's) found themselves in the Bottom Three.

Drama queen. Just another reason why she is not on the panel anymore.

I know however I think he was thinking ahead he might have thought Nikkita a threat to the final.