Originally Posted by Eugenie:
“ Alesha made comments about the dance performance but also chose to throw in comments which:
- made it clear she is biased
- made it clear she personally did not like Craig
- sought to humiliate him by saying he thought he was better than he was. Whilst this MIGHT be true (who knows?) there was no need to say that in front of millions.”
Biased in favour of Zoe - your interpretation. Biased in favour of every improving dancer - my interpretation. Both are interpretations, Alesha's comments made neither view clear.
I heard nothing that showed that her criticism was personal. What exactly are you referring to?
Craig has been repeating the same refrain week after week. "I thought it went quite well actually" "I didn't think it was that bad." That flew in the face of the judges' scores and comments week after week. Dozens of posters on ten or more threads here have called him deluded about his talent.
So how do you know Alesha sought to humiliate him rather than to shake him out of cloud cuckoo land? What
exactly did she say to make you believe that?
So which comments are you talking about Eugenie? Come on, let's have chapter and verse.
I have nothing against you personally, but I fear you're letting your own bias show here. If you are one of those people who make specific claims (in your list) without being able to produce the evidence for those claims, I'm afraid I must (dis)regard you as a sloppy and prejudiced thinker.