lloyd is clearly a better singer than j&E who require backing tracks to cover the singing bits in their songs.

But he is clearly the weakest singer out of the singers....I love the suggestion he learns to madly dash around the satge and fall over to progress!

sadly it'll be down to the public again who goes and they'll probably both survive another week.

It does beg the question....can you imagine if J&E could actually sing? jesus they'd be bigger than the beatles!!!!!!

Actaully lloyd has been very much in tune for most of his performances...even in the worst ones he has manged some of it in tune.

Rock Dj is a song that you can pretty much shout loudly and it sounds ok.....make the twins sing a slow ballad and lets see who is better singers.

Oh no I can`t disagree with you your so right.

I think the operative word in your post is "some". The many notes out of tune are very cringeworthy. I found it interesting and significant that the cross selection picked from the studio audience appearing on Saturday's "The Xtra Factor" all announced in unison when asked [LIST=1][*]Who do you think will be in the bottom two?"
Answer LLoyd. [*]Who do you think should have gone last week?
Answer LLoyd. [*]Who do you want to go?
Answer LLoyd.[/LIST]
So the sound created was as unpleasant in the studio as it came across our airways!

Whereas the Twins were of ahigh standard in the sing off and just as entertaining without the chorus around them. In fact their singing was better as they did not have to concentrate on their many dance moves.

Indeed...I'm glad people are noticing this

Yes but they were not asked:
WHO DO YOU THINK CAN SING BETTER THE TWINS OR LLOYD?
(i would bet most would say lloyd...in fact almost all)

they said lloyd should go because they probs find him boring, whereas the twins are a bit of fun....

TBH your suggestion that lloyd is the worse singer its just ridiculous.

Lloyd has some power in his voice and a loely tone the twins USE BACKING TRACKS to make them sound ok.
In lloyds sing-off he had no backing track and was ill and imo still sounded lovely.

The twins sing-off had backing track which again as always masked thier vocals.

Give them a soft ballad like lloyd did for his sing off....and it will suck!!

Why the hell did Cheryl put him through? if she was going for looks she should have just picked Ethan, who isn't a great singer, but he is better than Lloyd.

Ah, Ethan. *sighs dreamily*

I understand why Ethan didn't go through (he'd have been competition for the overs) but I still don't get why Lloyd is there. Or Rikki for that matter. It's one of life's great mysteries!

Wrong...look back at judges house lloyd was better...

Ill say this again and again Ethan was smokin BUT when cheryl picked lloyd she was going for the "teen omgzz he is soo fittt" appeal not just good looks.

Ethan did not have that same appeal that lloyd has with the teens and pre-teens....thereby im pretty sure ethan would be gone by now.

Its not just about good-lloks its about which market they would appeal to and almost everyone would agree lloyd is more marketable for 12,13,14 year olds than ethan.

Let me make this clear. Both Lloyd and John and Edward can sing. I personally think Lloyd has a nicer voice but I would say John and Edward are far more talented performers.

Lloyd is a shocking bore. Nobody seemed to care when Rachel went instead of him. Why the fuss about Lucie?? Seems a bit racist to me cos Rachel was better than her

Rachel had been in the bottom 2 three times. It was, unfortunately, her time to go.

People were annoyed at the result.

Lloyd & Jedward are both cR@p.

I wished Holly had asked that question and I wouldn't have been surprised at that answer either.

Lloyd has no intonation in his voice and that is where he falls down and out of his depth big time. As soon as he has to go down or up the scales he fails miserably and, imo, painfully so to my ears!

If you could write him songs to suit his kind of monotonous singing then the lad would do ok but I reckon it'd be a very short career because listening to a few tracks would get tedious very quickly.

My son's girlfriend's sisters pet guinea pig ....





.... probably

...good chance your son's girlfriend's sisters pet guinea pig's auntie could sing better as well!

I cannot believe that members are saying that those horrible little kids are better singers, than the rest.

They cannot sing, and people reckong there good, get on the right planet, this is earth not pluto.

Didn't you realise that all the "singing" was done by the backing singers and all the "talking" was done by J & E , it is very hard to talk out of tune.

I give up with people I think they only see and hear what they want to

It's like arguning whether it's less painful to gouge out your left eye or the right. Most people would rather do neither....

You would think so, but they even manage that...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=myIKo...B56D0&index=51

I agree. Lloyd is MUCH worse than Jedward!

Theyre both naff vocally why are we even arguing ? lol

Oh my goodness, some people must be tone deaf on here!

Lloyd has not got the best of voices but at least he can hold a tune ocassionally, the twins cannot sing at all, they are always out of tune and they have no co-ordination. They just jump all over the place like a couple of nutters! How on earth can you call that entertainment.

If the X factor purely goes on singing then both the twins and Lloyd should be in the bottom two with the twins going!

The twins are a total disaster, even though I have not got anything against the lads, this is a singing contest for goodnes sake!

The reason both these two acts have got this far is because they have got all the teens and youngsters voting for them. Youngsters dont care about the voice, they just go for the cute boys!

Exactly, I am so glad that somebody speaks some sense!

The backing tracks of the twins is so loud you can barely here the twins at all! This is because they cannot sing!

Its about time that they were made to stand still and just sing without any backing tracks! Then you would soon find out who can sing better out of the twins and Lloyd!

Lloyd would win hands down every time!

Just to throw a spanner in the works - how anyone can possibly claim this isn't one of the most dreadful vocal performances EVER seen on British TV is utterly beyond me...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8BXZXg7Lj9U

Abysmal beyond all belief and actually quite embarrassing to watch.

At least with the twins they can get away with it because it's being perceived by many as tongue-in-cheek.