Originally Posted by Jan2555*GG*:
“I dont want to start a row but obviously as a fan I have seen Gethin doing a lot of live presenting (not always on the TV) but large events with a live audience. He is witty and charming and extremely natural in fact he is better with an audience to feed off than recorded I think, I am not saying that hosting strictly wouldnt be a big thing because it would and is for most people but Just because you havent seen him doesnt mean he isnt doing live work. He has done 2 years of proms in the park (in fact he took over from Aled) as I said I dont want to start a row and wont say anymore but would just like to point out that just because you havent seen someone on your TV doesnt mean they are not doing appropriate work.”
If you notice , I didn't say I haven't seen him live . I have and I still think he has a way to go before he reaches his best .
I do know he does Proms in the Park in Swansea . I have seen him .

He is very good . And at the Hay Festival ! And I saw him many times at the Pop Factory in the Rhondda with my daughter . I didn't see him present Mardi Gras as it really isn't my thing at all .
I have met him and know his family as my offspring used to play in County orchestras and so on .
And I also didn't say I hadn't seen him on TV .

In fact as you can see from my earlier post I watch regularly on S4C and on other shows and listen on the radio


I assure you my pro Welsh presenter credentials are very sound and may well be better than yours

And on the subject of Welsh presenters , there genuinely is NO ONE better than Aled , whom I do know very well . He is known as One Take Jones BTW


Witty , clever , funny and very ,very quick . That is ,I am sure where Gethin is heading , but he doesn't quite match him yet , but then Aled has 28 years experience and is 8 years older .