First off, Im a HUGE Shakira fan, I've loved her for years and loved everything she's done since her she first debuted in the UK, and then loved her early stuff also. I have all her albums, DVDs etc. and listen to her music on a daily basis. One of my most prized possesions is a signed Oral Fixation tour poster!

I loved 99% of all her music, theres about 5 tracks from all her albums that I'm not keen on, the rest have been genius.
BUT, Im really not feeling this song at all!

Its just such a generic annoying Timberland track, I was even expecting him to show up in the video (you know, close up of his mouth going "ooh" or something). That rapper was dreadful too, looks like he needs to be locked up or something! Shakira's parts are a little generic too, you could have had anyone replace her (Nelly Furtardo, Fergie etc.)
The music video didn't leave much to be desired, especially the non-dancing parts. I did like the dancing, but I would have prefered a big routine like that in a video of the song "Spy" from her new album. I imagined that a routine like that would have gone well with the break down part in the song.
I just hope this Timberland track is a one off and they don't work together again, or stuff like this will end up stripping her of her unique sound and vision that I fell in love with all those years ago.
Lets hope it kinda blows over, and she releases a good song like "Spy", which in my opinion, is one of her best songs! I don't get why they havn't chosen it as a single yet! Especially after her biggest hit was also with Wyclif Jean.