How can she say danyl was flat as she ever heard herself sing. I can not stand her anymore. Danyl was amazing loved it.

cause his first few notes were flat?

But he was flat

And Cheryl's performance on CIN with SP this week was given very good reviews, so she can comment.

Because he WAS. A simple as that. Jedward FTW.

She was only good with Snow Patrol lol.

It's not about her singing, it's about her judging, and she thought it was flat. So did I.

How Cheryl herself sings is totally irrelevant.

Oh my god!? Why is it whenever cheryl criticizes someone for singing you then attack her for not being able to sing? With all fairness shes a far better vocalist than louis and simon. And im pretty sure shes a bettter vocalist than you.

She happened to be performing with them, yes, but the review was about her voice:

and Olly was out of tune will they say so.. thank god for DANNII only honest judge on this show.

Cheryl is pants.

Cheryl and Louis were both right. Danyl was flat at the start and at other times in the song. He was holding onto the notes for too long as well trying too hard like Louis said. Simon Cowell has a strange view of interpreting a song and putting your own mark on it. You can put your own mark on a song without changing the length of certain notes. Danyl seems to think he's already won the show the way he sings he's a turn off.

shame she didnt tell olly he was flat too

hmmm

Since there isn't a cat in hell's chance of her being sacked I suggest you chill out.

I thought Danyl was ace. Olly was a flat as the proverbial pancake.

there is a nicer way to say it...dannii's example is very good

Danyl was flat and out of tune and Cheryl was well within her right to say so regardless of how well or badly she sings.....

And Dannii said he was but didn't say Danyl was flat.

hmmm

If you need to be able to sing to comment surely pretty much all the comments in this forum shouldn't be allowed? The judges singing ability in no way affects what they can and cannot say to the acts.

Just proves to me she doesn't know what the f she's talking about.
Silly cow.

you have a point

but she does seem to have a thing against him

Im not a fan and can see that

Love how Lloyd and Olly can be so utterly crap to a level they would have never got through the 1st audition yet get singing praises from the judges. Danyl however, no - his performance has to be note-perfect, not flat, not cocky, not downbeat, not arrogant, needs a mojo blah blah - the judging (bar Dannii) is becoming a farce

If you think that he wasn't out of tune then you do not know what you are talking about. I am not trying to be rude but you are tone deaf if you think he was in tune.

Agreed.

And strangely she didn't mention Olly's terrible moments of being out of tune.

I'm starting truly to loathe the woman.

A sack Would look better than the dress she has on ATM.

Im guessing she is getting Freebies off posh fashion houses to wear those dresses.

Olly was flat crap and out of tune through out the whole song as she says how wonderful he is! Her opinions are useful and just based on who she likes or dislikes. The show would be better off without her.

Danyl was great.
Olly was cack.
Cheryl has totally lost it.
Dannii the only one who can be relied upon to speak sense, as ever.