Originally Posted by jtnorth:
“If you don't like it, fine, that's your opinion, but I think it's very unfair to call it cheating. Part of SCD is how the pros will interpret the dance and how they'll mix up the moves - if they'll put disco in a samba, what kind of lifts they put in an AS, etc. We vote if we like it. Where's the line. Was Natalie 'cheating' because she couldn't do the samba very well?
Chris and Ola had feeling. It had emotion and connection and a sense of a partnership. I LOVED it.”
“If you don't like it, fine, that's your opinion, but I think it's very unfair to call it cheating. Part of SCD is how the pros will interpret the dance and how they'll mix up the moves - if they'll put disco in a samba, what kind of lifts they put in an AS, etc. We vote if we like it. Where's the line. Was Natalie 'cheating' because she couldn't do the samba very well?
Chris and Ola had feeling. It had emotion and connection and a sense of a partnership. I LOVED it.”
Sorry, I don't agree. If you are dancing a viennese waltz, there needs to be some viennese waltzing in it. It isn't a question of interpretation - pivot turns are not a viennese waltz step so they shouldn't be used regardless of how you interpret the dance. You could dance a foxtrot to rumba music (and in Ricky and Erin's case last night you could certainly have danced a cha cha to their tango music) but that doesn't mean you should do it!
You can always tell the celebs who are rubbish at the VW. They have an endless introduction, an endless finale and lots of pivots with virtually no viennese steps. Because most of the public can't tell the difference, they usually get away with it, helped by public anger at the judges telling them they didn't do it very well (as Alesha did last night) when because they know no better it looked OK on the TV screen.
To be fair to Chris & Ola, I've seen a lot worse and they intro/finale sections weren't as protracted as some but still...





Why the public voted her into the bottom two but saved Laila who didn't do half as well carrying her injury I can't understand 