lets say this was the last yr of the show, which judge will you remember the most?
Simon
Dannii
Sharon
Louis
Brian
Cheryl
Simon
Dannii
Sharon
Louis
Brian
Cheryl
Who will be the most memorable judge?
I'll guess the result on here will be Dannii! 
But realistically, it will be Simon Cowell given that it's his show (plus the whole Got Talent franchise and his roles on Pop Idol and American Idol).
But realistically, it will be Simon Cowell given that it's his show (plus the whole Got Talent franchise and his roles on Pop Idol and American Idol).
Simon. He *is* the show whether we like him and his inconsistency and his hypocritical nature or not.
Originally Posted by Unigal07:
“Simon. He *is* the show whether we like him and his inconsistency and his hypocritical nature or not.”
“Simon. He *is* the show whether we like him and his inconsistency and his hypocritical nature or not.”
Yep
and probably Louis next just because he was there from the start.
d
Kylie is a singer.
Dannii is a judge, and a darn fine one!
She has made a success of this. Maybe because she is the sister of Kylie it gave her an opportunity that she would not otherwise have had.
What on earth is wrong with that?
She had an opportunity and she took it. Then, she worked hard and made a success of it.
Dannii cannot help that her sister is more successful than herself. It happens.
So, what do you suggest what she should have done?
Sit at home all day knitting socks for soldiers.?
Originally Posted by Mr Blonde:
“Most: Simon...he is the main event...
Least: Dannii...riding on the back of her sister's success...”
“Most: Simon...he is the main event...
Least: Dannii...riding on the back of her sister's success...”
Kylie is a singer.
Dannii is a judge, and a darn fine one!
She has made a success of this. Maybe because she is the sister of Kylie it gave her an opportunity that she would not otherwise have had.
What on earth is wrong with that?
She had an opportunity and she took it. Then, she worked hard and made a success of it.
Dannii cannot help that her sister is more successful than herself. It happens.
So, what do you suggest what she should have done?
Sit at home all day knitting socks for soldiers.?
i like dannii, she seems nice and her judging is sound
but she's pretty crap as a mentor.
i think she took it for granted that lucie would get through so she gave her a song ('this is me') where lucie would have to be handicapped to screw up (ie, no risks).
she also gave rachel crap style advice
i think we all know it's better to be absolutely shite than just good on the x factor
if you're absolutely shite you'll get the fan vote (as is happening to lloyd, and what happened to eggnog last year)
danyl and miss frank felt the full force of this in week 3 when people just took for granted 'yeah, they were grand' so didn't vote for them
but she's pretty crap as a mentor.
i think she took it for granted that lucie would get through so she gave her a song ('this is me') where lucie would have to be handicapped to screw up (ie, no risks).
she also gave rachel crap style advice
i think we all know it's better to be absolutely shite than just good on the x factor
if you're absolutely shite you'll get the fan vote (as is happening to lloyd, and what happened to eggnog last year)
danyl and miss frank felt the full force of this in week 3 when people just took for granted 'yeah, they were grand' so didn't vote for them
Louis Walsh he brought me Jedward, Boyzone and Westlife ..love the man to bits and pieces. He does wicked limmericks, makes me laugh and has a sad puppy face at times.
GG
GG
Originally Posted by Green Goddess:
“Louis Walsh he brought me Jedward, Boyzone and Westlife ..love the man to bits and pieces. He does wicked limmericks, makes me laugh and has a sad puppy face at times.
GG”
“Louis Walsh he brought me Jedward, Boyzone and Westlife ..love the man to bits and pieces. He does wicked limmericks, makes me laugh and has a sad puppy face at times.
GG”
Agree on Louis for the good memories.
Dannii no contest for the bad—vile, fake, pompous piece of work.
Louis Walsh... not his amazing judging abilities, but for his sheer comedy and when he gets emotional... bless little looloo!!
