Originally Posted by drbolognaise:
“
Oh its definately not a wind up. You can absolutely bruise a bone as it is very 'vascular' meaning it is surrounded by a lot of blood vessels. I didnt catch all of the update so Im not sure how Ali has injured herself but her injury will have cause the blood vessels in and around her bones to break, causing swelling and pain. I know it doesnt sound serious but it can be very painful and take a while to heal.
I cant pretend to know an awful lot about MRI results of bruised bone as I am not a radiologist, however, I can imagine the MRI (which is excellent at showing bones and similar tissue) will show that the bones she has bruised have a different shading due to the blood in the injury. Radiologists grade images by a priniciple giving different matter a different numerical number depending on its appearance, so the blood would have a characteristic appearance on the MRI. The MRI would also have definately given a clear image of any fracture or ligament tear.
”
Doctors view a situation dispassionately from books and pooled medical experience. The patient with a broken body knows about it from the inside. Some doctors will not listen to the patient, not in the least knocking the bolognaise which happens to be my favourite.
When injured the body protects itself by flooding the area with fluid for repair, so that overreacting healing and swelliing within the confined space of a foot can cause more pain than the injury itself. I am dead against Ali dancing when her body is not up to it.
I am however opposed to anybody getting an unconditional bye. Matt di Angelo performed 2 meltdown dances but was
voted through. Laila performed a non-dance but was
voted through. Some unkind person might say Craig Kelly made a profession of non-dances after which he was
voted through. This is in the gift of the electorate with well-established precedents. The rules provide for it, half on judges marks, half on phone votes.
To be consistent and even-handed, Kate, Letitia (dancing with a temperature of 100), Laila, Jade, Ali should all have been allowed a non-dance
for one week, marked zero by judges but relying on and hoping for the public to vote them through (i.e. voted clear of the bottom 2) if the public so wish. If the injured party finishes up in the bottom two, then the other uninjured couple should still dance. The injured couple will not get off their chairs and so will be evicted by the judges for non-performance, just like a boxer failing to answer the bell.
The bye as it now stands is a total exemption in the gift of the BBC disenfranchising the judges and the electorate. I suggest that in all such situations the judges should continue to mark (zero) and the public should continue to vote. This is a marking and voting competition.