DS Forums

 
 

Chris and Ola's Charleston was better than Ali and Brian's!


Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 28-11-2009, 22:40
Spinaker5
Forum Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 3,143
No I didn't - when was that?
After she fell over in training this week. Ali lost at least two days training this week because she was unable to walk. She hasn't banged on about her injury at all.
Spinaker5 is offline   Reply With Quote
Please sign in or register to remove this advertisement.
Old 28-11-2009, 22:47
Spinaker5
Forum Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 3,143
It is not totally subjective though, to do the foot swivel you have to be on ball of your foot, which means you have to have an element of bounce but it is not such an obvious up and down bounce as in the samba. Chris definitely was flat footed which is why he was not swivelling his foot, that much was obvious and is not subjective and will have contributed to the difference is scores along with her better arm and leg work. Saying that I preferred Chris and Ola's routine but that is subjective and not what the judges are purely marking on.
You've put it very well. The fact that people liked Chris & Ola's routine doesn't mean that Ali's dance shouldn't score more highly with the judges. I think they are sometimes too subjective (forget Alesha's '10' as it made no difference to the overall order) but not on this occasion. It's a bit hard on Ali as it makes her a target for negativity.
Spinaker5 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 28-11-2009, 23:39
thenetworkbabe
Forum Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Posts: 34,226
That may be true, I'm no expert. But I really can't see how that relates to the three Charlestons we saw tonight.
Are you saying Chris and Ola's routine was panto, but Ali and Brian were more professional ?
I thought the idea behind bringing back the Charleston was to invoke the spirit of the Roaring Twenties, to transport us back to a smokey speakeasy in Chicago. In that respect, I thought Chris/Ola and Laila/Anton were far more successful than Ali/Brian.
Chris did a please the crowd comedy routine that you might just see in a music hall. Elements of circus with people rolling around on the floor too. It didn't work for me because the dance was set somewhere in the US and the face was doing Frank Spencer meets Norman Wisdom. More East End than Chicago.

Brian took a scene from Act 1 of Chicago ( We Both Reached For The Gun) and used the same puppet theme to add to the dance . He also borrowed a few (difficult) moves from Chicago - hence the comments about the high kicks. The kicks are major features of Velma's role and one reason why not that many people can play Velma. Problem is the judges have seen Chicago, I almost had a season ticket early this year and most people havn't seen it at all. Melissa and Kelly on Dancing With The Stars also borrowed moves from Chicago (more from Hot Honey Rag at the end) and Melissa got top marks that night, so there's nothing strange about using it. Chris started with a theme from Bugsy Malone (not sure if what he did had anything to do with that story) and Brian added a 20s theme to a modern dance.

Laila and Anton were doing some sedate country club version of a Charleston. That fitted the remit too and no one had to work out what was going on . It might have been in Chicago or Tunbridge Wells though and it was clearly somewhere where prohibition was enforced.
thenetworkbabe is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 28-11-2009, 23:46
Starpuss
Forum Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2008
Posts: 11,311
Chris did a please the crowd comedy routine that you might just see in a music hall. Elements of circus with people rolling around on the floor too. It didn't work for me because the dance was set somewhere in the US and the face was doing Frank Spencer meets Norman Wisdom. More East End than Chicago.

Brian took a scene from Act 1 of Chicago ( We Both Reached For The Gun) and used the same puppet theme to add to the dance . He also borrowed a few (difficult) moves from Chicago - hence the comments about the high kicks. The kicks are major features of Velma's role and one reason why not that many people can play Velma. Problem is the judges have seen Chicago, I almost had a season ticket early this year and most people havn't seen it at all. Melissa and Kelly on Dancing With The Stars also borrowed moves from Chicago (more from Hot Honey Rag at the end) and Melissa got top marks that night, so there's nothing strange about using it. Chris started with a theme from Bugsy Malone (not sure if what he did had anything to do with that story) and Brian added a 20s theme to a modern dance.

Laila and Anton were doing some sedate country club version of a Charleston. That fitted the remit too and no one had to work out what was going on . It might have been in Chicago or Tunbridge Wells though and it was clearly somewhere where prohibition was enforced.
This is what I have been trying to say but I don't have enough dance knowledge to make any sense. Thank you.
Starpuss is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 28-11-2009, 23:49
Chrissi_1986
Forum Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2008
Posts: 1,832
Chris did a please the crowd comedy routine that you might just see in a music hall. Elements of circus with people rolling around on the floor too. It didn't work for me because the dance was set somewhere in the US and the face was doing Frank Spencer meets Norman Wisdom. More East End than Chicago.

Brian took a scene from Act 1 of Chicago ( We Both Reached For The Gun) and used the same puppet theme to add to the dance . He also borrowed a few (difficult) moves from Chicago - hence the comments about the high kicks. The kicks are major features of Velma's role and one reason why not that many people can play Velma. Problem is the judges have seen Chicago, I almost had a season ticket early this year and most people havn't seen it at all. Melissa and Kelly on Dancing With The Stars also borrowed moves from Chicago (more from Hot Honey Rag at the end) and Melissa got top marks that night, so there's nothing strange about using it. Chris started with a theme from Bugsy Malone (not sure if what he did had anything to do with that story) and Brian added a 20s theme to a modern dance.

Laila and Anton were doing some sedate country club version of a Charleston. That fitted the remit too and no one had to work out what was going on . It might have been in Chicago or Tunbridge Wells though and it was clearly somewhere where prohibition was enforced.
Fantastic post thenetworkbabe
Chrissi_1986 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 28-11-2009, 23:52
Ignazio
Forum Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 17,110
Fantastic post thenetworkbabe
Yes indeed - though somewhat long.
Ignazio is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29-11-2009, 00:15
ianswaiting
Forum Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 1,836
No disrespect to Ali, I thought she was good and I know she's had a tough week but Chris and Ola's Charleston was much better imho. It was the dance of the series for me, and im going to vote for them for the first time this series.

Why is Ali so favoured?
She isn't, she was just better. Chris & Ola's had a lot of gimmicks and was, therefore, very crowd pleasing but it lacked a lot of actual charleston dancing and Chris wasn't so much dancing it but walking through it. This was obvious because he was doing the same moves as Ola and as others have said I found myself watching her more than him. That's not to say I didn't like it but it wasn't the best of the night.

Ali's was perhaps less crowd pleasing but it had lots more dance content and danced with a high degree of technical precision. It was, therefore, inevitable it would score higher with the judges.
ianswaiting is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29-11-2009, 00:27
bendymixer
Forum Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2005
Posts: 15,185
She isn't, she was just better. Chris & Ola's had a lot of gimmicks and was, therefore, very crowd pleasing but it lacked a lot of actual charleston dancing and Chris wasn't so much dancing it but walking through it. This was obvious because he was doing the same moves as Ola and as others have said I found myself watching her more than him. That's not to say I didn't like it but it wasn't the best of the night.

Ali's was perhaps less crowd pleasing but it had lots more dance content and danced with a high degree of technical precision. It was, therefore, inevitable it would score higher with the judges.

Although Ali danced well I did not think technically it was any better than Cola's I thought Chris had good bounce and swivel action of the dance teachers I have spoken to tonight we would all have marked Cola a mark above Ali
bendymixer is offline Follow this poster on Twitter   Reply With Quote
Old 29-11-2009, 02:01
bobbla
Forum Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 11,211
Well i loved them both for different reasons. Chris's was full of pizazz and excitement. Ali's was full of character (that has been a bit lacking previously) and dancing skill.

I think as the judges are primarily judging dance ability then Ali deserved her higher score. I can understand why some preferred Chris's performance but thats why we have the public vote.
bobbla is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29-11-2009, 02:19
Bhoy1888
Inactive Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 1,642
Well i loved them both for different reasons. Chris's was full of pizazz and excitement. Ali's was full of character (that has been a bit lacking previously) and dancing skill.

I think as the judges are primarily judging dance ability then Ali deserved her higher score. I can understand why some preferred Chris's performance but thats why we have the public vote.
Chris's was better
Bhoy1888 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29-11-2009, 02:19
afterthoughts
Forum Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2008
Posts: 115
She isn't, she was just better. Chris & Ola's had a lot of gimmicks and was, therefore, very crowd pleasing but it lacked a lot of actual charleston dancing and Chris wasn't so much dancing it but walking through it. This was obvious because he was doing the same moves as Ola and as others have said I found myself watching her more than him. That's not to say I didn't like it but it wasn't the best of the night.

Ali's was perhaps less crowd pleasing but it had lots more dance content and danced with a high degree of technical precision. It was, therefore, inevitable it would score higher with the judges.

You got it!! Some people think its quantity, but it's quality that counts. Doing the period dance must contain the character of the dance especially when it comes to the footwork. Bouncing on your bum has nothing to do
with Charleston. Nice trick, but can also have been used in
the Rock & Roll. Therefore a cute tricky little thing, but nothing to do with Charleston.

Brian hit the nail on the head with his Charleston basic. Anton came next closest to he real thing. Of all the stars doing the dance Chris was furthest from the Charleston step. Tap step, tap step. Please!! If you don't do the basic step then everything else is irrelevent. Even Ola only did the real Charleston half baked.
afterthoughts is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29-11-2009, 02:21
thenetworkbabe
Forum Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Posts: 34,226
This is what I have been trying to say but I don't have enough dance knowledge to make any sense. Thank you.
I just saw Chicago an awful lot between this time last year and July.......
thenetworkbabe is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29-11-2009, 02:34
RichmondBlue
Forum Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Richmond, Surrey.
Posts: 13,814
Chris did a please the crowd comedy routine that you might just see in a music hall. Elements of circus with people rolling around on the floor too. It didn't work for me because the dance was set somewhere in the US and the face was doing Frank Spencer meets Norman Wisdom. More East End than Chicago.

Brian took a scene from Act 1 of Chicago ( We Both Reached For The Gun) and used the same puppet theme to add to the dance . He also borrowed a few (difficult) moves from Chicago - hence the comments about the high kicks. The kicks are major features of Velma's role and one reason why not that many people can play Velma. Problem is the judges have seen Chicago, I almost had a season ticket early this year and most people havn't seen it at all. Melissa and Kelly on Dancing With The Stars also borrowed moves from Chicago (more from Hot Honey Rag at the end) and Melissa got top marks that night, so there's nothing strange about using it. Chris started with a theme from Bugsy Malone (not sure if what he did had anything to do with that story) and Brian added a 20s theme to a modern dance.

Laila and Anton were doing some sedate country club version of a Charleston. That fitted the remit too and no one had to work out what was going on . It might have been in Chicago or Tunbridge Wells though and it was clearly somewhere where prohibition was enforced.
Many thanks for the detailed answer, I appreciate you taking the time. I have only seen the film version of Chicago, we have that on DVD, so I must take another look.
I see where you are coming from now, but still think calling Chris and Ola's effort "panto" is unecessarily disparaging.
I guess it depends whether there are some elements to the Charleston that are considered compulsory or at least "de rigueur"..I suppose there must be, otherwise it would it would impossible to make any genuine comparisons. Anyway, thanks again..I always find your posts interesting and educational, even if I don't always entirely agree with the content.
RichmondBlue is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29-11-2009, 02:35
thenetworkbabe
Forum Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Posts: 34,226
Well i loved them both for different reasons. Chris's was full of pizazz and excitement. Ali's was full of character (that has been a bit lacking previously) and dancing skill.

I think as the judges are primarily judging dance ability then Ali deserved her higher score. I can understand why some preferred Chris's performance but thats why we have the public vote.
It has to be said that Ola is very very good and its a pity she hasn't been recognised so much before because I think she always was this good. Arguably Ali isn't in competition with Chris as its Ola playing her role who people have just looked at, so I think its pretty good going when she can pull off something thats comparable and do a lot of the difficult stuff that the pros do. Chris I think would be more convincing if he would stop pulling funny faces - is he trying to act something badly or does he just pull them? Even if he got that righ,t though, I don't think you could look at Chris and Ola when they were dancing alone and not realise which was the pro very quickly.
thenetworkbabe is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29-11-2009, 02:51
Bhoy1888
Inactive Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 1,642
It has to be said that Ola is very very good and its a pity she hasn't been recognised so much before because I think she always was this good. Arguably Ali isn't in competition with Chris as its Ola playing her role who people have just looked at, so I think its pretty good going when she can pull off something thats comparable and do a lot of the difficult stuff that the pros do. Chris I think would be more convincing if he would stop pulling funny faces - is he trying to act something badly or does he just pull them? Even if he got that righ,t though, I don't think you could look at Chris and Ola when they were dancing alone and not realise which was the pro very quickly.
Ola is a great dancer and she loooks hot too
Bhoy1888 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29-11-2009, 02:57
louise81
Forum Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: London
Posts: 2,483
She isn't, she was just better. Chris & Ola's had a lot of gimmicks and was, therefore, very crowd pleasing but it lacked a lot of actual charleston dancing and Chris wasn't so much dancing it but walking through it. This was obvious because he was doing the same moves as Ola and as others have said I found myself watching her more than him. That's not to say I didn't like it but it wasn't the best of the night.

Ali's was perhaps less crowd pleasing but it had lots more dance content and danced with a high degree of technical precision. It was, therefore, inevitable it would score higher with the judges.
Perfect answer imo
louise81 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29-11-2009, 03:14
Maggie 55
Inactive Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 2,492
Loved Chris and Ola's dance. Actually clapped at the end of it. (very unusual for me watching a TV dance)

However, I was blown away by Ali's and Brian's dance,] and clapped even longer.

Ali's dance was both crowd pleasing (though not as much as Chris's ) and technically excellent. The perfect combination.

Thought it was undermarked actually.



Maggie
Maggie 55 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29-11-2009, 05:48
parthena
Forum Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: SW London, Crystal Palace Tx
Posts: 2,769
Chris & Ola's had a lot of gimmicks and was, therefore, very crowd pleasing but it lacked a lot of actual charleston dancing and Chris wasn't so much dancing it but walking through it.
Dammit! You've stolen my thunder Cola are hugely enjoyable and a great pairing, but Chris didn't dance that dance.

While I'm at it, I know it's not the subject of this thread but I don't think that Rock 'n Roll should have been chosen as an extra dance, it's too much like Jive and it puts some couples at a serious disadvantage because of the acrobatics required - Nat & Vince are an obvious example.

It's past me bedtime :yawn: will catch up later.

parthena
parthena is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29-11-2009, 06:35
bobferret
Forum Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 72
No disrespect to Ali, I thought she was good and I know she's had a tough week but Chris and Ola's Charleston was much better imho. It was the dance of the series for me, and im going to vote for them for the first time this series.

Why is Ali so favoured?
Oh, no, it wasn't and oh, no, she isn't.
bobferret is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29-11-2009, 06:38
lach doch mal
Forum Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Sofas are deities
Posts: 16,123
I liked all three charlestons. They were fun and every couple brought something special to the dance. As I'm a Chris and Ola supporter, I enjoyed their dance more (but that's my bias).

I think where Ali was overmarked was the VW section. Her arm was again too high and full of tension (the judges seem to consistently overlook this problem). Also why penalise Laila for being led around the dance floor, but not Ali.
lach doch mal is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29-11-2009, 10:10
Ninja Kitty
Forum Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 498
Chris is SCD's equivalent of Jedward on X factor

I don't think so I believe Chris can actually sing!
Ninja Kitty is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29-11-2009, 10:18
FluffyEgg
 
Posts: n/a
Oh please, Ali and Brian are STREETS ahead of the gruesome twosome!

Out classed 100%.

Chris and Ola will be worthy runners up.
  Reply With Quote
Old 29-11-2009, 10:45
Servalan
Forum Member
 
Join Date: May 2005
Posts: 7,472
You got it!! Some people think its quantity, but it's quality that counts. Doing the period dance must contain the character of the dance especially when it comes to the footwork. Bouncing on your bum has nothing to do
with Charleston. Nice trick, but can also have been used in
the Rock & Roll. Therefore a cute tricky little thing, but nothing to do with Charleston.

Brian hit the nail on the head with his Charleston basic. Anton came next closest to he real thing. Of all the stars doing the dance Chris was furthest from the Charleston step. Tap step, tap step. Please!! If you don't do the basic step then everything else is irrelevent. Even Ola only did the real Charleston half baked.
So how come the same people choreographed all three Charlestons then? Did they deliberately choose to not give Chris and Ola basic Charleston steps?

They clearly thought Chris and Ola were doing a Charleston - and as performing professionals, they should know, surely? (Better than the judges!)

I can see why Ali and Brian's was marked as well as it was - but it didn't deserve a ten - and Chris should have got one more nine.
Servalan is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29-11-2009, 10:48
gorlagon
Forum Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 1,013
So how come the same people choreographed all three Charlestons then? Did they deliberately choose to not give Chris and Ola basic Charleston steps?

They clearly thought Chris and Ola were doing a Charleston - and as performing professionals, they should know, surely? (Better than the judges!)

I can see why Ali and Brian's was marked as well as it was - but it didn't deserve a ten - and Chris should have got one more nine.
My understanding was they were given the basics of the choreography and the pro worked from there?
gorlagon is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 29-11-2009, 11:14
rita1
Forum Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Geneva, Switzerland
Posts: 8,044
So what are these technical elements of the charleston that some think Ali and Brian's dance contained, while Chris and Ola's didn't? All I can find on wilkepedia is that the basic charleston step is a walking step and that creativity and innovation is prized above anything else. Is that true - all you dance experts?
rita1 is offline   Reply With Quote
 
Reply




 
Forum Jump


All times are GMT. The time now is 06:57.