Originally Posted by twingle:
“A couple of years ago Simon said he loved SCD and always taped it to watch so am surprised at this comment if indeed he did say it!
I am very fickle and one minute I hate Scowell with a vengeance then actually quite like him (draw the line at fancying him though!!)
While I do agree his shows churn out some dross we can hardly class them all as no hoper wannabees thinking Will Young, Leonie Lewis , JLS , and SuBo and many more who may not have made it in the music industry but are doing very well in the west end!
I agree about tired old covers but the reason is very simple for the winners song theydon't know who is going to win therefore have to do something generic which will sort of suit all voices and there is also the time schedule to get it out for xmas.
As for SCD, this is the first year i have been really tired of it. i hated the 2 hour shows(prob due to my short attention span!!) and am tried of the silly jokes and backbiting between the judges. The only highlight for me this year so far has been Flavia and Vincents Argentinian Tango and that is sad.
I won't be buying XF winners single and nor will i be buying any other unless I hear a song that I really love and thinks deserves a number one xmas slot. It doesn't sit well with me to buy a record out of spite
*gets off soapbox and returns to corner*”
Your post broadly sums up my views. I watch both shows and don't take either particularly seriously. However I'm enjoying TXF much more than Strictly this year and I can't wait for tonight's final (Joe FTW!)
Simon has said he'd love to own the rights to SCD/DWTS and even had a favourite during series 5 - he said he wanted Alesha to win. I don't blame him if he's since lost interest, but I know he still keeps an eye on DWTS as it's on at the same time as American Idol and even recorded in the same studio block in LA.
Regarding the RATM song, people are buying a Sony single on the back of a rather suspect campaign to sell a single no-one would be buying otherwise, in the misguided hope of displacing the Sony X Factor single from number one, which of course is
never going to happen. Simon Cowell and Sony benefit because Sony gets the RATM sales they wouldn't ordinarily get, the Joe/Olly/Stacey fans multibuy the winner's single in panic, both singles get extra publicity in the run up to the Top 40 countdown therefore even more sales... It all happened last year with Hallelujah after a similar internet campaign (in the end Alexandra's version predictably outsold the [Sony] Jeff Buckley version by a ridiculous margin). If it makes anyone happier, then go ahead and buy it, but like last year Sony, Simon and the X Factor winner will have the last laugh.