Girls Aloud - 20 Top 10 singles
Sugababes - 17 Top 10 singles
Saturdays - 5 Top 10 singles.


Who is your favourite?

The sugababes

Which one's which again?

Sugababes for albums, Girls Aloud for a few standout singles (Call The Shots, Biology, Untouchable) and The Saturdays.. well, really liked them to begin with, and their second album is good but feel they might be dropped soon.

For me it has to be Girls Aloud, a solid band for 7 years who put single after single onto the market and have been sucessful.

Sugababes, they just don't look like a band anymore, I don't see them around for much longer.

Saturdays, the success of their last album says it all.

Girls Aloud.

The Sats, then Girls Aloud then Sugababes.

I do like all of them though

Girls Aloud by a mile - they've got the most fun and inventive songs (thanks to Xenomania) and they've got some amazing album tracks and B-sides. But I thought their first two albums were a bit rubbish, and I don't like a lot of their singles choices (i.e. Long Hot Summer, See The Day, Jump, The Promise etc). Overall though they've got the best back catalogue, and Tangled Up is one of my favourite albums ever.

Then (after quite a bit of a gap) Sugababes.

Then (after a massive gap) The Saturdays - I loved both their albums when they came out, but I think they're fairly shallow, instant songs that get a bit boring after a while. I do like them, but they're basically a poor mans Girls Aloud.

Girls Aloud all the way... they can do no wrong

I like them all for different reasons. Girls Aloud for some pretty catchy tunes (The Promise, The Loving Kind, Can't Speak French), Sugababes for some amazing singles and albums and The Saturdays for some fun tracks.

Girls Aloud without a shadow of a doubt, such a better group imo. I think all you need to do is look at the audiences they manage to perform too week after week which proves it imo.

Girls Aloud

Girls Aloud

The Saturdays. Some great songs (Ego, Up, Work, Issues, One Shot, Chasing Lights, Forever Is Over), are HILARIOUS (watch their backstage clips ) and can sing pretty well.

The Saturdays, then Sugababes, then Girls Aloud

Sugababes up until the god awful Get Sexy and the trainwreck that has followed. The Mutya/Keisha/Heidi line up remains my favourite.

Love Girls Aloud and Saturdays as well though.

For me...
The Sugababes with Mutya > The Saturdays > Girls Aloud/The Sugababes sans Mutya

Girls Aloud by miles, I've always loved them!

I did like the Sugababes until Mutya left, it feels like they've been missing something since then, although I like Jade as part of the current line up. I loved The Saturdays' first two singles but since then I haven't really liked anything they've released.

Girls Aloud all the way!!

Girls Aloud by far! They all have strong, likeable personalities, have great videos, are good live and, mostly importantly, have brilliant, catchy, classic pop songs.

I loved Sugababes mk1 & 2, they made some great songs. I don't mind the odd song during the mk3 era but, if the latest stuff is anything to go by I don't think I'm going to like their new album much and the band just aren't the Sugababes to me any longer anyway.

The Saturdays I'm sure are very nice girls and they can sing but their music and personalities leave me totally cold. I just find them very bland and boring. The only song I like by them is Up, the rest of their stuff is just "in one ear and out the other" for me.

Girls Aloud. I like the other two as well, but I like more of their songs than the Sugababes or the Saturdays songs.

all of them

Sugababes 4.0, The Saturdays then Girls Aloud, who have never released a song I have ever liked. Glad Cheryl is getting the chance to go solo.

Girls Aloud



Sugababes




























































































































The Saturdays

There'd be a bigger gap but I didn't want to mess the thread up. Girls Aloud are the most consistently amazing. Chemistry is a really really really amazing album and if you don't own it then you are actually insane. Sugababes 2.0 are amazing too, Sugababes 1.0 were really good too but obviously there isn't much to judge them by. Sugababes 3.0 - About You Now and Red Dress are amazing, and I do love Amelle but otherwise haven't been too impressed. Sugababes 4.0 - hmm, we'll see. The Saturdays are OK.

Girls Aloud have the best catalogue of songs.
Sugababes have always been the better singers, though they are seriously not in form recently.

The Saturdays are personally my favourites as an all round package, but I dont think they have as much longetivity at all. I think the problem for them that they became to famous to fast - their popularity was massively overestimated and as a result, their album flopped.