So, if you could choose the new judge, who would you pick?

I'd like someone with a sense of humour who knows a thing or two about music and actually writes and composes their own music.

Katy Perry or Brandon Flowers maybe for me.

Though I know Brandon wouldn't touch the show with a bargepole!

I just pray we don't get Mel sodding B or Myleene Klass. In fact I'd burn my TV set if Myleene became a judge.

I wondered if Mylene might be in the frame.

I'd like to see Charlotte Church on there, especially if Cheryl does another year.

I want Cheryl and Dannii to stay!!!!

Love them both




*JOE TO WIN

Or Lily Allen !! But i doubt Princess Chez will let Simon do that!

Oh yeah, I hadn't thought of putting someone Cheryl has fallen out with on there. Lily or Charlotte would be too funny, and the fact they are better singers than Cheryl will add insult to injury too!

They should be replaced by a massive star. Celine Dion would be perfect, she would know what she is talking about

Charlotte Church. It'd help boost her pop career too, but she's got an ace personality, and she's lovely.