Leona's good, but Rachel's voice was better at this song. Sorry Leona fans but I prefered Rachel's version and Rachel's voice.

On a side note.. I don't like Alexandra Burke but she was absolutely amazing tonight, outstanding along with JLS. They were unbelievably good together.

And on this years final, I cannot see Olly being even a third as big as JLS are now. Joe will do ok but I believe last year the two acts in the top 2 were the best in the shows history...

Still I loved Joe's don't stop believing. Knew he would sing that, think he's miles ahead atm..

I was actually about to post a thread about this. Leona's was dull dull dull. :yawn:

And by the way on Leona, I have some of her songs so I'm not being a dick about it.. Rachel was better. And Alex and JLS outshone her tonight

No one beats Oasis. I don't think Leona suits this song very much, and I usually love Leona's songs.

I also preferred Rachel's version

Rachel wasnt better than Leona

In your opinion she was but that's it

Haha nice. I know. I prefer Leona much more when she doesn't go so over the top and make it so dramatic. Her cover of Run was so dramatic it was ridiculous, but it was still good, this was average.

Olly's doing pretty well at this song suprisingly!! Lol!!! Although Joe will be better

I was only comparing Leona and Rachel lol

this

Leona's voice is better, but I agree that Rachel's was better.

Not just mine. HAHAHA.

come on!!!!!

I dont like this cover of the song but Leona has her own songs which she sings very well.

The second half of Leona's was world class singing.

But the fact is that she wasn't comfortable in the first half. Too low in her range for too long. It made the song memorable for that!

I'd take Rachel too. She nailed that song.

Rachel's version of this song is way better than Leona's.

Rachel nailed the song, it was a shame Dannii gave her sh*t songs and she never had a chance of really proving herself.

Leona's version is just soulless, completely emotionless and plain wrong. Just as the studio version (Not the Live Lounge) of Run was.

I though Leona was rather dull tonght. No her best by any stretch. I preferred Rachel's too (but obviously not as much as the original)

Rachel's version was soooooooo much better than Leona's, so much more passion.

leona looks fantastic but her voice seems weak and drowned out by the music and the song dull ..

Thanks guys! I agree Rachel was great at it.

She was hampered greatly by the fact 2 Leona and Alex had won and people were a bit bored of black females winning I think

I much preferred Rachels version.

I really do like Leona's voice but she was ultra dull tonight.