Originally Posted by Cookie Jar:
“Noo, it has to sell!
Some Metallica, or maybe even Dokken! Breaking the Chains Around Me!
Or, maybe, shock horror, something Christmas related!
Hell, even Wham! would be a change!”
I think the reason RATM did so well was a combination of the message in the name of the band and the lyrics of the song and what they stand for. They are anti-establishment, campaign for moral, right-on issues like anti-capitalism, anti-racism and fascism, and are a real grass roots, genuine band. That is why they captured the imagination of so many people of all ages, races and backgrounds.
They were the perfect anti-X Factor band, and it was the perfect anti-X Factor song.
In order to replicate this next year, a similarly perfect X Factor antidote would have to be chosen. I mean, I wouldn’t buy Wham or anything like that – it’s almost as bad as the X Factor and has been done before.
I also think that the choice of X Factor song this year - insipid, boring, uninspiring and dull, coupled with a guy you couldn’t pick out of a crowd singing it - was another reason it was beaten to the top spot. You couldn’t have done it with Alexandra Burke or Leona Lewis.