Originally Posted by howard h:
“Looks like you've been had for the sake of forty quid.”
If I can determine that my box
is faulty I will try and get my money back anyway. It was advertised as “full working condition” and the seller seemed very conscientious and communicative.
Originally Posted by swedish cook:
“Compared to every other STB and PVR (including the out of the box Topfield EPG), the EPG on the HDR is the best.”
I know there are much better EPGs than that. The DigiFusion FVRT200 is better (this is the box I’ve owned for the last 5 years and I’m well used to). The DigiFusion shows 10 channel listings at a time, and you can instantly switch to single-channel mode which shows 10 listings for each channel. The cursor zips around quickly, and you can look through half a day’s TV listings in less than a minute. Looking through half a day’s listings (for 30 channels) on the Foxsat would take me about 10 minutes, I reckon.
I can’t find a pic of the DigiFusion EPG, but I just found
this pics of a Mac-based EPG called EyeTV. This was the kind of thing I was hoping for from an HD box, but sadly Humax opted to keep the menu the same size for both SD and HD outputs, which is daft in my opinion. (No doubt more Freesat regulations!)
Seeing a PC-based EPG has made me seriously think about opting for a PC-based solution rather than a set-top box. It seems there is no HD box on the market that fully utilises the 1920x1080 resolution to show maximum listing information, and that is what I’m looking for.
Originally Posted by
swedish cook:
“The Topfield EPG can be seen here http://www.toppy.org.uk/newusers/manual2a.php - how bad is that ? Four channels at a time and you can't really read half the program names either.”
As you say, the default Topfield GUI is absolutely terrible. I was disgusted with how bad it was, both visually and functionally, and it’s extremely buggy.
But, in my opinion, even that GUI is better than the Foxsat GUI. At least it’s very fast and the cursor never slows down, and you can easily see the listings for each channel.
Originally Posted by swedish cook:
“The above posts are looking more and more like a troll - would anyone really buy a secondhand HDR from ebay to save just £40 ?”
I’d have gladly bought it second hand to save £10. Maybe even £5. The box is less than a year old so I didn’t anticipate there being any problems with it. It was advertised as being in full working order. That’s good enough for me.
Originally Posted by Portabletv2:
“Swedish cook.....yes I had my suspicions from the outset, especially given the Christmas morning timing,”
I posted it on Christmas morning because I only got it Christmas eve. The dish was put up on Friday and the box arrived Christmas Eve. I’ve been thinking about getting satellite for a long time (and put it off) but I was prompted to get it in time for Christmas because I wanted to watch the new Doctor Who in HD (and I was keen to get it working which is why I posted as early as I could on Christmas day).
Originally Posted by Portabletv2:
“and the complete absence of any positive comments which would be impossible from am impartial viewpoint.”
I made one positive comment, that it was nice to have all those channels. I honestly can’t think of anything else positive to say about it. There’s nothing I particularly like about it. It doesn’t have any features any other PVR doesn’t have, and in many respects it’s inferior to other PVRs I’ve owned.
Crucially though, I wasn’t posting a review. I was posting a request for help on 12 different problems I was having (and still am having).
Trolling is when someone tries to waste other people’s time at minimal effort of their own. A troll will typically post one message and leave the thread alone. I have been very active on this thread and clearly invested a lot of time here. That isn’t what trolls do.
Originally Posted by Portabletv2:
“To everybody else who has a Foxsat HDR, I suggest you enjoy it and avoid this feed.”
If you suspect someone is a troll, the most sensible thing to do is to have a look at their post count, and see what other posts they’ve made. If you’d done that with me, you would have realised straight away that I am a regular poster here on DS and certainly not a troll.
Troll accusations seem to be everywhere on DS, and it’s just getting silly. I’ve only ever seen one genuine instance of trolling in 16 years on the Web, and that was over 10 years ago. Why is everyone so wary about something that hardly ever happens?
Originally Posted by
hillel:
“Please, please, it is Christmas.
”
Sorry to be overly negative on Christmas Day! I was only being negative about a product though.
You have to see it from my point of view, my other PVR has been on the blink lately, and one of my family is ill and bedridden in the living room. She was counting on this box to make Christmas better, but we are really struggling with it, and can’t get it to do what we want.
Originally Posted by hillel:
“Humax follow the Freesat Specification, it is Freesat that impose the limitations you describe in Freesat mode. Given that, you are unlikely to get a better Freesat PVR.”
In that case, Freesat sucks!
Originally Posted by hillel:
“I agree that the ability to schedule and record programs on non-Freesat channels would be nice. However, the ability to record at all is a bonus. (I pay a hefty subscription to Sky and can't record any ITV region or BBC 3 or BBC 4.”
How come?
Originally Posted by hillel:
“Cm'on, that's well over the top.”
It’s just my opinion. Those things matter a lot to me. I would honestly rather never watch TV than use a box where I can’t rearrange the channels.
Since I was born, I have been able to arrange the channels on my TV into any order I please. I consider this my right as a TV viewer, and I’ll be darned if anyone is going to take that right away from me.
Originally Posted by hillel:
“If you don't like the Freesat approach, fair enough. However, don't hold Humax to account for issues outside their control.”
I’m starting to see it’s not really Humax’s fault. But my box is ridiculously slow, so that might be Humax’s fault, or it might just be a faulty box.
Originally Posted by hillel:
“What I really want is to integrate everything into a single solution such as Windows Media Player. The concept is simple - all media available on a single server, ideally with a touchscreen interface.”
I definitely would like a Freeview/satellite all-in-one box. It would do things like automatically switch to the satellite equivalent of a channel if both Freeview tuners were busy. Or it would allow you to watch a third Freeview channel while two are recording, allowing a total of 5 simultaneous channels at once.
Originally Posted by maxwech:
“This has to be the saddest thread of the year.”
What is sad about asking for help with your new PVR? I think you will find several thousand threads just like it all over these forums. DS is
the place to ask that kind of thing.
The only “sad” thing is that many of my questionst are still unanswered. And some of them were only simple things that every user should know, like how to record a programme you have just finished watching? (Which I still haven’t figured out how to do.)