Its basically confirmed by Robin Antin that theres going to be a new line up. Only Nicole has been confirmed to stay so far.

My bets are that Kimberly and Ashley go cause they've been on and off the most and have caused the most drama, I think Kimberly has a solo album out anyway. I hope and think Melody will stay cause PCD will sound so different without her plus shes vocally the best imo. Jessica is in the middle for me i don't know about her but i hope she stays.

I hope these new girls are great aswell.

will they be wearing more or less clothes than the originals?

will they be wearing more or less trowelled-on make up than the originals?

will they be as totally unrecognisable and forgettable as the originals?


i, for one, cannot wait to find out the answers to these all-important questions.

I think the provocative clothes and sexy makeup will stay cause its kinda become the trademark of the PCD when people think or talk about the PCD the first thing that come to mind is the clothes, and they made there own clothing range aswell.

Robin has been bombarded with many questions about the slutty dancing and clothes ect and she hasn't done anything so i think they're keeping it that way.

Kim was always my favourite, dunno why...just was. Noticed it will still be "based around Nicole"

EDIT: http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/music/ne...nd-nicole.html


"It will be Nicole and some new faces"....Nicole's credited seperately?!? Why...?

of course they'll keep it, it's the only thing they can cling to to keep people (men and little girls) interested... there's nothing else about them.

honestly we all saw this coming if you look at youtube, myspace, other forums ect you could tell that we knew the other girls were getting sick and jeleous of all the attention going to Nicole especially Melody remember her little stunt she did on tour?

true. Sad, really.

i would't just put it down to there style cause they can do very good songs imo and Nicole does have great vocals (even though she sings like 99% of the song)

yeah i mean Melodys vocal range is off the scale she can those high notes easily but she knows shes being screwed over and tbh her stunt she did might just get her kicked out

if they didn't dress the way they do, they'd hardly be noticed.

plenty of girls have good voices, but if you're willing to dance around nearly naked you have a certain advantage fame-wise.

double post.

oh yeah like i said it was there trademark it does get them noticed but compared to other girls Nicole's voice does get some recognision all the critics compliment her (though Melody deserves some aswell)

she doesn't have the sort of voice i like at all, but i suppose it's true it's better than a lot of girlband singers.

the issue with their clothing (or lack therrof) is my particular grievence. little girls wanting to dress like that to emulate them... i don't like the impression it gives them much.

her solo album is amazing (even if it flopped) but anyway just as long as they don't dress up like that everyday (Katie Price) then its fine i think they only go to the extreme in tour and in live performances

Oh I hope not. I like Melody. But I see your point.

EDIT: Do you think Nicole has a say in who gets kicked out of/into the group??
Last edited by .Mimi. : 29-12-2009 at 21:27

Yeah Melodys in hot water at the moment but with Kimberley and Ashley blabing and crying to the press that PCD are splitting up i think shes got a chance .

I think Nicole would like to too cause she obvious doesn't like Melody but i think Robin calls all the shots. She pretty much does everything like the styling, choreography, promotion and she even produces the songs and MV's.

Also Tiffany from Girlicious tried to do that and take control but she ended up getting fired so yeah.........

Nicole seems to be the only who has songwriting credits on the last album too.....the others seem like backing dancers/singers....which is a shame, because they are talented too and have not been given a fair chance at all

....tbh with you I don't blame the other girls going off and doing their own thing with some of their self-respect/dignity intact....because it kinda takes the piss Robin shifts all the attention to Nicole, which is ok....but they are called the Pussycat Dolls! not Nicole and the PCDs....shouldn't they all get their moment to shine? isnt that what happens in bands?!

....I feel sorry for the rest of them, I agree what Melody said @ that Britney concert when they were supporting her and the other girls highfived her besides Nicole.....Melody is by far the strongest singer in the group followed by Nicole

....I like some of their songs but not the dynamics of the band...who's not to say that the same thing will happen again, the new girls will get sick of the attention given to Nicole?! then what?! replace 'em again ala sugababes style (who I prefer over the PCDs)

......I imagine Nicole has some sort of control, maybe Robin talks to her about or consults with her or something, who knows what really goes on?!...kinda of sick of seeing Nicole's face everywhere, bored with her now....reading some of the reviews for Doll Domination, I think the press is kinda of getting sick of Nicole too....xo

I've just found out that Jessica aswell as Kimberley both have solo albums planned for release. Thats Jessica gone then cause shes got other commitments aswell as highfiving Melody for her stunt on the Britney tour and as sad as it sounds the PCD won't change that much without her cause shes been very average through out .

Jessica's always the ignored when she dances or even when she sings.

I want Melody to leave and release her own solo album. She has a fantastic voice and doesn't deserve to be second fiddle to Nicole.

Why even bother with new members? You could hear Melody and Carmit (ex-member) on PCD, but on Doll Domination it's only Nicole's voice in every song.

Me too....I like Melody, I heard on YT once singing Christina Aguilera's Hurt, wow! she blew me away with her voice....if you haven't heard it, you should have a listen! ....I know Kimberly doing some judging on some new uk dance show on Sky which is a bit like the american SYTYCD....Melody saw her on the AMAs solo....I don't know about Ashley or Jessica though

I know, if there going to stick with Nicole's voice on there only....why don't they just ditch the PCD thing and give the material to Nicole make her into a solo act? xo

It's the US Sugababes.

Lol, true! ....I prefer the Sugababes anyday, despite how many times the line up has been changed!...atleast they all get a chance to sing unlike the PCDs xo

Does that make Nicole, Keisha?

I really thought she'd have ditched the group by now to try her luck solo again after the somewhat lacklustre first attempt. Wonder if this means she's stuck in the group until the management decide she's surplus to requirements and getting a bit long in the tooth prior to kicking her out?

I saw the 'Hurt' video too. She was amazing singing it.
That's what I don't get. Why is Robin Antin hell-bent on having a girlband? Give the bloody songs to Nicole as a solo artist. No one will care.
I think Kimberly is an amazing dancer and she could be a chereographer for other artists or something.

This is ridic...the reason why the last album bombed....was because it was always about that attention-WHORE Nicole!

As her solo album couldnt be released, we got shoved it through PCD and we werent buying it.....Nicole Domination...I mean Doll Domination was joke. I remember that last video with Nicole in the bath, it took over a min for any of the other girls to appear, what group spirit!

Them getting new members will finish them even quicker because that makes it more blatantly all Nic-Ho, if that was humanly possible!